Drawings and documents
Published accounts: specification
Specification printed in the Journal of the Franklin Institute
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 6 (1830), p. 309 · View the page
Text of the specification as printed in the Journal, from OCR; not proofread.
Specification of a patent for an improvement in the art of Cutting and Casting Music Type. Granted to GEORGE B. LOTHIAN, City of New York, August 11, 1830. The staff lines are fitted on single bodies, and dress up to the face on the extreme edge of the body, leaving no shoulder. What I claim as new, and my own invention and discovery in the above described type, and for the use of which I ask an exclusive privilege, is: In cutting and casting but one staff line on #623468 the time marks, they are, therefore, as readily made to line as a plain staff line. The type thus cast projects nearly one-half over the body, and fits on to the plain staff lines, above and below. In cutting and casting the angular quavers without any projection over the body, and a line, thus -, or an angle thus, or thus, is cast on a body equal to an entire quadrate, or half the size of the body of the staff lines, which is placed in the composing stick first, and then the quaver on it, which causes the quaver to run on the next line below, thus. An en quadrate or character on the half body is placed next in the composing stick, and makes up the two lines. The notes in the lines are made in the common manner; as also seconds, thirds, and choosing notes, and make perfect joinings in the stems of the notes, without kerning, or projecting over the body. The slurs are cut and cast in the spaces of the staff, and come on the body without projecting. This improvement reduces the number of sorts in a fount, and facilitates the manufacture. GEORGE B. LOTHIAN. Observations on the Paddle Wheels invented by Mr. PERKINS, and those patented by Mr. BENJAMIN M. SMITH, of Rochester, New York, November 20th, 1829. In a letter from Mr. J. DOOLITTLE, of Bennington, Vermont. To which are subjoined some remarks by the EDITOR, and the specification of Mr. SMITH'S patent. To W. Hamilton, Esq. Actuary of the Franklin Institute, Philadelphia. Bennington, Vermont, August 4th, 1830. MY DEAR SIR,-You know how much I admire the general spirit of frankness, candour, and judiciousness, which characterizes Dr. Jones' remarks on the multitude of pretended inventions which throng the patent office. And I should be exceedingly loth to ascribe to him any thing like a bias in favour of the inventions of particular individuals, without regard to the merits of the inventions themselves. I am led to these remarks by the following circumstances. Some three or four days after I received the June number (No. 6, vol. v.) of the Journal of the Franklin Institute, I left Bennington on an excursion to the west. On Saturday evening, 10th July, being at Syracuse, I saw a steam boat arrive, on the canal, from the west. Some gentlemen present, who had already seen that boat, observed that her machinery was of an unusual construction. I immediately went to the quay, and in the few minutes the boat remained, got into conversation with the person whom I was led to believe was the inventor; he invited me on board to examine the machinery. I had only time to see the wheels, and you may judge of my surprise when I found that, in the inclination of the buckets, and in the angle which the axes of the wheels formed with the plane of the keel, they were exact fac similes, or rather, perhaps, exact prototypes (for they were probably made first) of the wheels invented by Mr. Jacob Perkins, and described in the above number of the Journal. The gentleman above alluded to informed me that the specification for these wheels had been sent to Washington in November, 1828, and a patent obtained in November, 1829. On my return home, I sought in vain among the notices of patents, for some indications which should, at least, lead to the discovery of the name of the author or inventor, and it was not until yesterday, that I learned, by a letter from a friend at Syracuse, that it is Mr. Benjamin M. Smith, of Rochester, Monroe county, New York. On recurring to the Journal, with these data before me, I find at page 136, vol. v. that Mr. Benjamin M. Smith did obtain a patent on the 20th of November, 1829, (ten days prior to the date of Mr. Perkins' patent.) There is nothing, however, in the editor's notice of Smith's patent which can induce the belief that he thinks the invention entitled to the least consideration, or respect; on the contrary, he says, "wheels of the above kind have been patented, tried, and abandoned, long since," while, in speaking of an exactly similar contrivance by Mr. Perkins, he says, page 385, same volume, "should the advantage produced by the present paddle wheel be, in its amount, but one-half equal to the ingenuity manifested in its construction, we think it will will be the best, by far, which has yet been proposed." I have not the honour of a personal acquaintance with Mr. Perkins, though I have long known him by reputation, and feel a high respect for his mechanical talents. Of Mr. Smith I have never heard until now; but, it seems to me that, if an invention is to be judged of by the intrinsic merits, either of its ingenuity or its usefulness, the same thing which in one case could call forth such unqualified encomiums, ought, in another, to command, at least, a small share of courtesy, even though its production should not be accompanied by a name already resplendent with distinguished honours. As I am unwilling to suspect Dr. Jones of either intentional injustice or undue partiality, I must suppose that either the drawings or the specification, or perhaps both, were so defective that he could not derive from them a correct understanding of Mr. Smith's invention. But, however this may be, I beg leave to repeat that the two inventions, (though no doubt both original) are exactly similar in every respect. The boat I saw is called the "Novelty," and her wheels are fixed in the stern. I beg you will attribute this intrusion to its true motive-my love of truth and justice. I am, sir, very respectfully, your obedient servant, J. DOOLITTLE.
Editor's remarks. Although the above letter is dated in August last, it has but just come into the hands of the Editor, or it would have received an earlier notice. We have not the temperament which will admit of our sitting at ease under the grave charge of partiality, from an intelligent correspondent, who is actuated only, as we really believe, by the "love of truth and justice;" we are prompt either to correct our mistakes, or to repel an unworthy insinuation, or a false charge. Whether the animadversions made in this Journal, have been tinctured with partiality, let some of our friends tell, whose inventions have passed under review; and whether such has been the fact in the case before us, will soon appear. We are far from Syracuse, and far from the boat which Mr. Smith had put into actual operation, but we have the testimony of Mr. Doolittle, and the patents of Mr. Perkins and of Mr. Smith before us, and will place them before our readers, when it will plainly appear that either Mr. Doolittle saw "what is not to be seen" in the angles of the buckets and shafts of Mr. Smith's wheel, or the latter gentleman, finding that his " smoke jack" wheel must take its place among those which had "been patented, tried, and abandoned," had determined to essay that, upon the ingenuity of which we had passed "unqualified encomiums." We believe the latter to be the case. That our readers may see the grounds of our belief, we now give his specification, and a cut from the drawing which accompanies it.
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents, with remarks
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 6 (1830), p. 301 · View the page
4. For an improvement in the art of Cutting and Casting Music Type; George B. Lothian, City of New York, August 11.
Remarks. (See the specification.)
About this record
- Patentee
- DATAMP
- Date
- the Name and Date index of patents, DATAMP
- Invention
- DATAMP
- Listed in
- the Name and Date index of patents, DATAMP, Jim Shaw's X-patent list, the Journal of the Franklin Institute, Burke's List of Patents (1847)
- in_burke