Drawings and documents
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 5 (1830), p. 299 · View the page
26. For the manufacture of Paper from Straw, Hay, or other Vegetable Substance; William Magaw, Meadville, Crawford county, Pennsylvania, February 19.
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents, with remarks
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 5 (1830), p. 314 · View the page
Remarks by the Editor. We have never been more completely posed than in endeavouring to find out what the patentee claims to have invented in this, confessedly, "old invention." Nothing certainly can be more vague and general than his description; nor can we well conceive how any one could have more completely overlooked both the letter and spirit of the patent law, which declares that " every inventor before he can receive a patent, shall deliver a written description of his invention, and of the manner of using the same, in such clear and exact terms as to distinguish the same from all other things before known, and to enable any person skilled in the art or science of which it is a branch, to make the same." Act of 1793, Sec. 3. Instead of distinguishing his invention from all other things before known, he seems to have embraced all things past, present, and to come, appertaining to the subject. More than twenty-five years ago Gen. Stevens, of Hoboken, near New York, tried the spiral wheel " at the stern of the vessel, or boat; the shaft of the spiral in the direction of the travel of the vessel, or boat," and abandoned it as a very inefficient mode of propelling, although he made the essay with all that skill and perseverance which have distinguished him and his sons in their numerous and valuable experiments. We do not recollect when the first patent was obtained in the United States for a screw, or spiral propeller, but we remember that when Wm. J. Lewis, Esq., of Virginia, obtained his patent, on the 3d of February, 1819, it was not the first which had issued for the same thing, and we know that several have since been obtained for using the spiral principle, both in a continued thread and in disjointed sections. a We think it unnecessary to refer to the several instances in which we have had occasion to allude to this mode of propelling since commencing our monthly analysis of the patents. We have distinctly given our opinion that the mode itself is bad one in all its forms; an opinion founded on some knowledge of the nature of the fluid medium on which the propeller is to act, and confirmed by the best test in all such cases, the test of experiment, perseveringly repeated, and ingeniously varied, but uniformly resulting in disappointment. Our present object has been to point out the entire want of conformity with the law when descriptions and claims are couched in terms like the foregoing, which, we are convinced would render any patent unavailable, however valuable the invention might be for which it was taken. Specification of a patent for preparing Straw, Hay, or other Vegetable Substances, for the manufacture of Paper. Granted to WILLIAM MAGAW, Meadville, Crawford county, Pennsylvania, February 19, 1830.
Remarks. THE following endorsement has been made upon the specification at the patent office. " Improvement in the manufacture of paper, for which two patents have been granted to the said William Magaw, one dated on the 8th day of March, 1828, the other the 21st day of May, in the same year; both of which patents being hereby cancelled on account of defective specifications." The new specification is as follows. This improvement or discovery consists in the use of ley and its salts, in preparing straw, hay, or other vegetable substance, for the manufacture of paper, in the following manner, viz. To one hundred and twenty pounds of straw, or hay, take the ley procured from three or four bushels of ashes, or from fifteen to twenty pounds of the salts of ley, according to the quality; dilute it with a sufficiency of water to boil the straw or hay, which need not be all immersed at the commencement, as it will sink during the process of boiling. Boil the materials together until the vegetable matter and the knots become soft, or pulpy; or steep the materials in the solution several days until the same effect is produced; draw off the remaining liquid and rinse the materials to cleanse them from any dirt, or sediment, then grind them in the usual way, to be manufactured like rags into paper. The petitioner claims as his exclusive improvement or discovery, the use of the ley, and its salts, and the mode of preparing the materials so as to render them fit for the manufacture of paper. WILLIAM MAGAW. Remarks by the Editor. If straw had never before been used for making paper, its application to that use would undoubtedly present a legitimate claim to a patent; or if a particular mode of applying it to this purpose had been discovered and patented, an improved method would likewise entitle the discoverer to an exclusive privilege to use it. That Mr. Magaw's patent does not rest upon either of these circumstances, must, we think, plainly appear by a reference to what we have formerly said upon this subject. At page 416, new series, will be found the two former specifications, now surrendered, and a reference to a patent granted some years previously, both in France and England, for using the same material in the same manIn our remarks upon Mr. Bomeisler's patent, page 415, vol. iv. we have also spoken fully upon this point. ner.
About this record
- Patentee
- DATAMP
- Date
- the Name and Date index of patents, DATAMP
- Invention
- DATAMP
- Listed in
- the Name and Date index of patents, DATAMP, Jim Shaw's X-patent list, the Journal of the Franklin Institute