Drawings and documents
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 4 (1829), p. 287 · View the page
This experiment has further confirmed the theory which he endeavours to controvert; viz. that the powers of bodies in motion are as the squares of their velocities, and that the momentum destroyed by friction, will be equal in equal spaces passed over; thus it appears, although "one experimental truth may be of more value than a thousand ingenious theories," that in this case, as it undoubtedly is in many others, when truths have been established by experiments, different individuals make different deductions from them, to suit their preconceived theories, instead of carefully examining the laws which govern the results; the neglect to do which, may, and frequently does, lead to practical errors; for if J. P. E. should wish to erect machinery requiring a fly wheel of a given weight, to be moved with a given velocity, but, from a change of arrangement, or some other cause, he should find it more convenient to drive the fly with only half the computed velocity, he would double the quantity of matter to compensate for the diminished velocity, whilst his antagonist would quadruple the weight to obtain the same effect. In such a case, although they both suppose themselves acting with knowledge obtained by practical experiment, either one or the other of them must have committed a serious practical error, which a careful "inquiry into causes would have prevented." Method of Preserving Eggs. If J. P. E. wishes a further investigation of this subject, will it not be best for him first to state particularly such experiments as he may have witnessed, or that are "laid down in the books," which are most relied on by him to establish his theory? JERSEY. Mode of Preserving Eggs. The Revue Encyclopedique (vol. 38, 1828) contains the annunciation of a mode of keeping eggs fresh, by placing them in a solution of chloride of lime. A later number of the same magazine, (vol. 40, October, 1828) gives an extract of a letter from M. Peschier, of Geneva, claiming for his brother, a druggist of that place, the merit of the discovery of a more economical mode of effecting the same object, by placing the eggs in lime water. This letter is accompanied by an account of the results of experiments made, in which eggs had been kept sound for six years by this method. A friend educated in Connecticut, assures me that this method of keeping eggs has long been known and practised in that state. B. FOR THE JOURNAL OF THE FRANKLIN INSTITUTE. Notice of an article at p. 214 of the last number of the Journal of the Franklin Institute. MR. EDITOR,-On looking over the last number of the Journal of the Franklin Institute, I noticed some remarks on a "Reply to the query, does a body descending on an inclined plane with an accelerated motion, press the plane with the same force through every portion of its length?" The conclusion drawn in your remarks, appears to me to be incorrect. You say that the rapidity of motion acts in the same manner as a centrifugal force in preventing the body from pressing the plane. This cannot be so, for the plain reason, that there can be no effect produced without a cause, no matter what projectile velocity you give the body in the direction of the plane, it cannot, in the least degree, affect that portion of gravity which acts perpendicular to the given force. It must be clearly perceived that that portion of gravity will remain constant, and will, consequently, cause the body to exert a uniform pressure on all parts of the plane, as shown in the diagram given in my previous solution. The only effect that an increased velocity can have, in the matter in question, is, to cause the body to remain a less portion of time on each particular part of the plane. Philadelphia, September 24th, 1829.
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents, with remarks
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 4 (1829), p. 410 · View the page
27. For a machine for Planting, and Preparing Seeds for the same; Zebina Lane, Harrisburg, Lewis county, New York, September 21.
Remarks. The specification of this patent is of considerable length, and describes the machine without reference to the drawing, and although evidently written with much care, is not, alone, very intelligible. The drawing is miserably executed; the details of the apparatus cannot therefore be understood without the devotion of more time than we can at present spare. At page 343, vol. 2, of the new series, a planting machine is described, which was invented by Messrs. Robbins, of Lewis county, in New York; and to us it appears that the machine now patented, is the child of the former; how near the resemblance may be, we are unable to state, for the reason already given.
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents, with remarks
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 5 (1830), p. 51 · View the page
B AG DE Again, let BC represent the plane, and A the body that is to descend upon it. Suppose the body to have no gravity, but let the weight, D, be suspended at F, the point of contact on the plane, and the weight, E, at G, to represent the gravity of the body, and let the weight, D, represent that portion C of the body sustained by the plane, now it is very clear that the weight, D, has no tendency to move the body forward, but only to press on the plane. All that can move the body is the weight E, which is a direct gravitating force, and would move the body in the direction of gravity; but the plane prevents that course, and compels it to move in the direction of the plane; the weight, E, will be accelerated in its descent, and the body accelerated in the direction of the plane, and these 'accelerations will be equal as before stated. The weight, D, will remain unaltered, except by its inertia, to give greater acceleration to the two forces, therefore " the pressure on the plane will be the same through every portion of its length." It will be perceived that a body descending an inclined plane with an accelerated motion, is not analogous to proposition 2, because in that proposition the body is acted upon by two forces, and these are composed into one, in the direction of the diagonal of these forces, urging the body in that course, whereas, in the inclined plane, the body is acted upon by one force only, and that force resolved by the plane into two, the body taking the direction of one of these forces. A body will not descend on a plane in the same time that it would descend in free space, because all that portion of the body that is sustained by the plane, has no tendency to fall, but must be carried along by the part that is unsustained. It is a curious fact, that when a body is descending an inclined plane, the forces are equally accelerated, notwithstanding the friction of the plane or the resistance of the atmosphere, and it is presumed that a more perfect instance of equal accelerations cannot be found. From the above, it will be seen that, in the communication on this subject in the September number of the Journal, correct conclusions were drawn from wrong premises. Replies to certain questions submitted to the Monthly Meeting of the Franklin Institute. By CHARLES Potts, read October 22, 1829.
Remarks. Reply to the question "What is the absolute centrifugal force of a body revolving in a circle of a given diameter, d, with a given velocity, v. The periodic time of a body revolving in a circle, by means of its own gravity at the circumference of the earth, is ordinarily determined to be equal C✓ -; where R is assumed equal the radius 2 R g of the earth, g = 165 feet, and c = 3.14159, &c. As the correctness of this expression depends upon the accuracy with which the terms are assigned in the following theorem, viz. tha the central force of a body moving in the periphery of a circle is as the square of the arc divided by the diameter; it may be of use to give the usual manner in which this theorem is demonstrated. Thus, let the arc AE (Fig. 1,) be described by a body revolving in a circle in a given moment of time; then, from the nature of a circle (the arc AE being very small, and, consequently, nearly equal to its chord) AE, Fig. 1. = AE B C DA AB × AD, and, therefore, AD= Now AB AD is the space through which the body is 7 drawn from the tangent in the given time; and E though 2 AD is the proper measure of the central force, yet when the forces compared are all computed in the same manner, the ratio in both cases will still remain to be the same. Hence, if g (= the space through which a heavy body descends at the surface of the earth in one second of time,) be represented by AD, and AC be put equal R = the radius of the earth, then the space described by the body revolving at the circumference of the earth in one second of time, will be represented by AE = ABXAD = √2 g R and the circumference of the earth being 2 CR, we have 2 R g the following analogy; as √2g R:2CR::1″: C -=the time in which the body would pass around the entire circumference of the earth, as above stated. I have adverted to the foregoing theorem because it might be urged that however near the arc AE may be supposed to approach to its chord, it can never be considered as absolutely equal to it; and hence the deductions for the centrifugal force which are predicated upon this supposition, as will be the case in the following remarks, are not such as the question demands: it may not, therefore, be amiss, if greater accuracy is required, to give the following series expressing the arc in terms of the diameter and versed sine, viz. putting 2 R = D; the arc. Reply to a Question on Centrifugal Force. g 3 ga 3.5 g³ AE =(1+ + + + &c.) vg D; 2.3 D 2.4.5 D 2.4.6.7 D3 where the order of the series being evident may be continued at pleasure. This expression being substituted for the value of the arc or the space described by the body in one second of time, the periodic time may be found as in the preceding analogy. Having now the periodic time of a body revolving at the circumference of the earth, it follows, that as the central forces of two bodies moving in different peripheries are in a ratio compounded of the direct ratio of the diameters and the reciprocal one of the squares of the periodical times; if t be put for the time which the body requires to perform one revolution around the circle, the diameter of which is given = d; then, by the above law, the central forces of the two circles being denoted by F and f respectively, we have F: f :: t × 2R: 2 R (c) xd and consequently f= g Cad gt force required. Or because the time t = of F, d, g, and the given velocity, v. f = × F = the centrifugał Cd υ 22 gd we shall have in terms × F = the centrifugal force of the body, the weight of which, at the surface of the earth, is equal F. The solution of this question being essential to the determination of many useful and interesting problems in mechanics, it may be useful to give an example of its application. Let one of the balls of a governor of an engine weigh 30 pounds; and suppose that it revolves in a circle, the diameter of which is 3 feet, in one second of time. Here F 30 d = 3 and t = 1" 3 x 30 x 3 141592 Therefore f = 16 gal force of the ball. 55.177 pounds, the centrifuIf now it is required to find how long the arm of a governor must be in order that the above conditions may be fulfilled. Let the length of the arm AD = l. Put CD a and AB = d as before. Now it is known that CD: AC as the force of gravity on the body, is to the centrifugal force, that Fig. 2. D is, a:d:: F: Cod F g t from whence results a = g ta 2 C = .814, &c. in the present case. B But AD = 1 = √ AC® × CD² = 1.7 foot C DA nearly the length of the arm required. Again, suppose the arm AD of the governor to be 2½ feet long, and the diameter of the circle in which the ball moves to be 3 feet, to find the time the ball occupies in moving round the periphery. From the above equation, a = gta 2C2 we have also t 1.108 √a = the periodic time of revolution. Now, by the question CD = a = 2 feet. =CV 2 a g = Therefore t = 1.108 × √2 = 1.108 × 1.4142 = 1".5669, or one second and a half nearly. It is obvious that if s be assumed to represent the ultimate centripetal force of a revolving body (the strength of the arms and rim of a fly wheel, for instance,) then by equating this with the general expression for the centrifugal force given above, we may determine the velocity with which a fly wheel (or the like) by the centrifugal force would be torn asunder. In a similar manner, also, it would be easy to assign the relative strength of the arms, &c. when at rest, and when revolving with a certain velocity. Which will move down an inclined plane with the greatest velocity, a wheel of two, or one of four feet in diameter, supposing their weights the same and the matter of each to be all disposed around in its periphery? It is evident from the given proportion of the two wheels, that the spaces described by them in passing over the same length of the plane will be equal: for let the length of the plane on which the two wheels are supposed to roll down, be assumed equal to the periphery of the largest wheel; then the space described by the larger wheel in descending this plane, will be equal to that of a cycloid, the base of which is equal to the length of the plane, and axis equal to the diameter of the wheel. The length of this cycloid, it is known, is equal to four times the diameter of the generating circle, therefore 'the space described by the larger wheel in descending the assumed plane will be equal to sixteen feet. Now as the peripheries of circles are to one another as their diameters, and the diameter of the lesser wheel is half that of the larger, by the question, the length of the plane will be twice the length of the peripheries of the smaller wheel. Hence it follows that the small wheel in passing down half the length of the assumed plane, will describe a space equal to four times its diameter; and in rolling down the whole length of the plane, it will describe a space equal to eight times its diameter, that is, equal to sixteen feet, the same as that of the larger wheel. With regard to the relative forces of these two wheels down the inclined plane, upon which it is known that their respective times depend, the following may be taken as an evidence of an opinion which is somewhat prevalent in matters of this nature. It is observed in Jacobs' Observations on Wheel Carriages, "that in the draught of carriages ascending inclined planes, the moving power acts not only against the vis inertia, which is always equal to the absolute gravity of the load, but also against its relative gravity, which increases with the inclination of the plane; and with respect to carriages raised on wheels, it is to be observed, that the higher the axle is removed from the plane, the farther is the centre of On Descents of Bodies on Inclined Planes. gravity removed out of the perpendicular line of support; so that the lower the wheel, the less is the relative gravity of the carriage. Hence it is inferred, that, supposing the friction of two carriages of equal weight, but of different sized wheels, to be equal, the low wheeled one would be drawn up hill, on a smooth plane, much more easily than the high wheeled one, though on a smooth horizontal plane, the latter would be drawn more easily than the former; on the contrary, in going down hill, the high wheeled carriage will be urged forward by its relative gravity more than the low wheeled one." The fallacy of the above reasoning, applied either to carriages or to the two wheels in question, which are analogous, must be obvious, when it is recollected that the power, or relative force that urges a body down an inclined plane, is as the sine of the angle of the inclination of the plane, the weight of the body and the length of the plane being the same in both cases. Hence, when the angle of elevation is the same, as is the case in the present instance, the relative forces of the two bodies are equal. It is, therefore, concluded, that as the velocities of bodies uniformly accelerated are in the subduplicate ratio of the forces and spaces directly, and the weight of the bodies reciprocally, and as these have been shown to be equal, the velocity of the two wheels will be equal. It is hardly necessary to observe, that, in this investigation, the resistance to the two wheels in rolling down the plane has been supposed equal, and the force of gravity uniform. Does a body descending on an inclined plane with an accelerated motion press the plane with the same force throughout every portion of its length? In the Journal of this Institute for September last, is published a solution to this query. The ingenious author of the solution therein demonstrates, by a brief resolution of the acting forces, the affirmative of the proposition. The Editor of the Journal in controverting the solution, has advanced an opinion, which, if correct, must tend ultimately to overthrow Galileo and all his celebrated demonstrations relative to accelerated motion. It has been observed, in the remarks of the Editor, after supposing the case of a ball fired from a gun, that " a rapid motion in the descending body resembles a centrifugal force, and operates in the same way in counteracting the effect of gravity." It is acknowledged by the Doctor in the previous part of his remarks, that "a body rolling down a plane has its motion accelerated in the same ratio as when falling through free space:" it will be proper, therefore, to inquire, as the uniformly accelerated motion of a body falling through free space, supposes the accelerating force to be constant and uniform, whether the ratio will still be the same, when the accessions of velocity to the body rolling down the inclined plane are supposed to counteract the effect of gravity, that is, whether the motion of the body down the plane will be uniformly accelerated. Let the body be supposed to commence its motion from a state of rest, and by the effect of gravity upon it, to roll down the inclined plane, the length of which is AB, and height BC. = BC AB Now the first impulse or effect of gravity to urge the body down the inclined plane, is × W, where W represents the weight of the body. If, therefore, we can conceive that as the velocity of the body increases in rolling down the plane, the pressure or effect of gravity of the body downwards (which is equal to its weight W,) is counteracted or diminished, it must follow that all the succeeding impulses after the first are continually diminished, and hence it is obvious that the motion thus produced would not be uniformly accelerated. It is proper to observe that in assigning the weight of the body, the limitation is here understood, that the effect of gravity is the same at all heights from the earth's centre. Was this not the case it might be " advantageous" to inquire, supposing the plane to extend to the utmost verge of the sphere of the earth's gravitation, and the body equal in weight to the moon, for instance, to commence its motion at this point, whether the pressure of this body on the plane as it approached the earth, would be nothing, or less than nothing; for it follows that if a rapid motion counteracts the effect of uniform gravity, every increment in the variable gravity must have its corresponding counteracting influence. this In considering the question with respect to the force of the descending body on the plane, in a practical point of view, it may appear plausible, that, although the force pressing the plane be constant throughout every portion of its length, according to theory, yet the effect of this pressure on the plane will not be the same. This paradoxical position may be illustrated in the following manner.
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents, with remarks
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 5 (1830), p. 57 · View the page
This pressure has for its value the expression g. cos. E, where g is the entire force of gravity, and E the angle of elevation of the plane; or we may use this form, pressure = gravity x base of plane length of plane Were the body fired from a gun, in the direction of the plane, as supposed in our former remarks, it must be clear, upon the principles which we have admitted, that gravity would still tend to draw the body down from its rectilinear course, with a force which must remain unaffected. As the whole force of gravity during the time of descent is invariable, so certainly must that part of it be which is counteracted by the plane. On the relation between Rolling and Dragging Friction. Read before the Franklin Institute, at the Monthly Meeting, October 22, 1829.
Remarks. By WALTER R. JOHNSON, Professor of Mechanics and
About this record
- Patentee
- the Journal of the Franklin Institute, Journal
- Date
- the Name and Date index of patents, Jim Shaw's X-patent list
- Invention
- the Name and Date index of patents
- Listed in
- the Name and Date index of patents, Jim Shaw's X-patent list, the Journal of the Franklin Institute, Burke's List of Patents (1847)
- The patentee's full name comes from the Franklin Institute's journal.
- in_burke