Superior Court of Judicature of New Hampshire.
BENJAMIN W. CASE
v.
SAMUEL MOREY.
November Term, 1818.
*1 A circumstantial
variance between a patent and the description of it in an assignment, does not
indicate fraud or prevent the right from passing.
A court cannot pronounce a
patent void, without evidence, that the principles of it had before been
"known and used" in the manner described in the patent; nor can the
patent be pronounced worthless without evidence of experiments, which have
proved unsuccessful.
Where the title to a
patent passes, the consideration money, if paid, cannot be recovered back,
unless the contract has been rescinded or was accompanied with fraud, or with
an express warranty--not fulfilled.
THIS was an action of
assumpsit in two counts; one for 700 dollars money loaned, and the other for so
much money had and received.
At the trial here upon the
general issue, May term 1818, it appeared in evidence,
that the defendant in consideration of 700 dollars paid him by the plaintiff,
October 12. 1811, conveyed to him a certain interest in a patent that Morey
had invented, which interest was to commence after Morey had received
10,000 dollars profits from the sales of the patent.
Morey also assigned
to the plaintiff the immediate right to use said patent in the state of New-York
on the payment of 5000 dollars--and he covenanted, that if within one year the
plaintiff should become dissatisfied with any part of this agreement, he might
rescind the whole, and receive back the 700 dollars.
In this assignment the
patent was described to be "for the invention of a new power for
mechanical purposes, obtained by means of the odds in the pressure of a column
of rarefied air within a chimney or tube extended to a convenient height, and
that of an equal column of atmospherick air."
The specification, that
accompanied the patent itself, corresponded with the above description, except
that the patent was called an "invention," or improvement, "to
consist in the application to mechanical uses of the difference of power given
to a column of rarefied or hot air within a tube or chimney extended to as
great a height as may be convenient, and that of an equal column of surrounding
atmosphere."
No evidence was offered,
that the plaintiff, till after the expiration of the year, had elected to rescind
the contract: and when he did make a proposal to Morey on that subject,
it appeared that, though Morey declined repaying the money, yet he expressed a willingness to convey
to the plaintiff, for a relinquishment of his interest in this patent, seven
hundred dollars' worth of other patents which Morey had invented. Nor
was any evidence offered to shew, that this patent was without value: but the
plaintiff contended, that such must be the inference from the specification
alone; that the variance also between that and the agreement must be fatal; and
that from them both the court must be satisfied the patent was not an original
invention.
*2 But a verdict
was returned for the defendant, subject to be set aside, if, on further
consideration, it was thought the action could be sustained upon the above
testimony.
Headnotes
Britton and Mason
counsel for the plaintiff.
Wilcox and J.
Smith for the defendant.
WOODBURY, J. delivered the
opinion of the court.
When money has been paid
under a contract, it cannot, as a general principle, be recovered back, unless
the contract has been rescinded, or was tainted with fraud, or was accompanied
with a warranty that has not been fulfilled, or was, in its origin, without
consideration [FN(1)].
FN(1). 4 Bos. &
Pul. 260. nte.
In this case the attempt
to rescind the contract was not seasonable; and no evidence of fraud was
offered, unless it results from the variance between the description of the
patent in the specification and in the assignment. But that variance is only
nominal; for though in one instrument it is described as the
""discovery of a new power," and, in the others, as an
"application of the difference of power;" yet from the whole of each
instrument it is manifest, that the patentee intended to represent, that he had
discovered a new application of an old principle.
The language used to
express this idea may not have been the most appropriate; but the plaintiff
could not have been misled: for on adverting to the nature and operation of the
patent, as well as to the description, he could not but know, that a new
application of an old principle was the substance of the whole patent and the
sole subject matter of his purchase.
For the same reasons this
circumstantial variance did not prevent the title to the patent from passing to
the plaintiff by means of the assignment.--Of course no warranty has been
broken by the defendant unless he himself was destitute of a title in
consequence of the principles of the patent having been before
"""known or used." The patent would then be
void by the act of congress of April 17th,
1800.
That rarefied air was
before "known," need not have been proved: but that the difference of
weight between that and atmospherick air had ever been considered sufficient to
turn machinery for "mechanical purposes," and had been
"used" for that end in the mode described by this patent, is a fact
which the jury would not be warranted in finding without evidence.
*3 As Morey,
then, for aught that has been shewn, possessed a valid title to the patent, and
transferred a right in it to the plaintiff, it is very questionable on the
remaining point, however worthless the patent may prove to be, whether the
money paid for it can be said to have been paid without any consideration.
The defendant did not
enter into a warranty, that the same power, which turns a smoke-jack, should,
when applied in a particular manner, move machinery the most complicated and
extensive, and supersede the use of water falls, steam and canals, though from
the evidence it would seem that this may have been anticipated.--Without
reasoning a priori, should experiment, the only infallible test of the
utility of new inventions, disappoint these sanguine hopes, the misfortune will
certainly be as great to the defendant as to the plaintiff, for his expenses in
procuring and perfecting his patent have been far from inconsiderable. But no
evidence was offered, that the patent had in fact proved worthless.
The plaintiff would seem to have received for his money all which
the defendant stipulated--a certain interest in the patent right.--On this
testimony it would not be competent for a jury to say that the consideration
had failed--and
Judgment must be
entered on the verdict.
N.H. 1818.
1 N.H. 347
END OF DOCUMENT