Superior Court of Judicature of New Hampshire.
WILLARD EARL
v.
GEORGE PAGE.
July Term, 1834.
*1 Where a note was
given for a shingle machine, and for the exclusive right to use the same, in a
certain district, under a patent claimed by the plaintiff, it was holden that
there was a failure as to the latter portion of the consideration, the letters
patent being void, by reason of non- compliance with the terms of the statute.
If the inventor of an
article suffers the thing invented to go into public use, or to be publicly
sold for use, before he makes application for a patent, it is an abandonment of
his exclusive right in the invention, and disables him from compliance with the
terms of the statute.
THIS was assumpsit,
founded on a note, made by the defendant, and one Taft, for $46,00 drawn,
payable to the plaintiff or his order, in two years and six months from its
date, with interest.
It was in evidence, that
this note and two others, amounting in all to $140, were given for a shingle mill, and the right to
use the same in the town of Keene; and that enough had been paid upon these
notes to amount to the value of the mill; and it was contended that the letters
patent, granted to Earl for said mill, were void, and that there was no
consideration for any farther sum on these notes.
The patent of said machine
duly authenticated, and issued in December 1822, was produced by the plaintiff.
It was proved that as
early as 1819, the plaintiff had made, and sold some shingle mills agreeing
with his patent; and that in the summer, and fall of 1822, before obtaining
said patent, he had made, and sold several of said machines.
A witness testified that
he had worked for the plaintiff, at the time of making and selling said mills,
and that many were in use previous to obtaining said letters patent; but the
jury found there was no evidence of any mills of this description having been
made prior to the issuing of the letters patent, in favour of the plaintiff,
but such as had been made, either by the plaintiff, or by agents in his
employment.
The case was submitted to
the court, on the facts as above stated, with the agreement, that a default was
to be entered, if in the opinion of the court, the plaintiff was entitled to
judgment, otherwise, the plaintiff was to become nonsuit.
Headnotes
Handerson, for the
plaintiff.
Chamberlain, for
the defendant.
UPHAM J. delivered the
opinion of the court. [FNa1]
FNa1. Parker J. having
been of counsel did not sit.
*2 The decision of
this case depends on the construction given to the statute of the United
States, prescribing the terms and conditions of obtaining letters patent.
The 1st Sec. of the Act of
21st of February 1793, relative to granting letters patent, provides "that
when any person, being a citizen of the United States, shall allege that he has
invented any new, or useful art, machine, manufacture, or composition of
matter, or has made any new improvement in the same, not known, or used, before
his application, it shall be lawful, in such case, for the Secretary of State
to cause letters patent to be issued to the inventor, securing to him the
exclusive privilege of making, using, and vending to others to be used, the
said invention or discovery."
And in a subsequent statute upon this subject, extending the
privileges of letters patent to aliens, passed April 17, 1800, it is provided
that "every patent for inventions obtained pursuant to the act of 1793,
which, it shall afterwards appear, had been known, or used previous to such
application for a patent, shall be void."
The power to grant letters
patent, is given by the Constitution of the United States for the purpose, as
is assigned, "of promoting the progress of science and the useful
arts."
This right, however, to
grant exclusive privileges to the inventor, is confined to "a limited
time," and any attempt to extend this term beyond the time specified
operates as a delay to the benefits, which it was proposed eventually to secure
to the public. It is not in good faith, therefore, for the inventor of an
article to use and vend the same, as a matter of profit, until such time as he
fears others may come into competition with him, and then attempt to debar the
public from the general use of his invention, for a farther term of fourteen
years.
For this reason the
provision in the statute rendering all patents for inventions void, "which
had been previously known or used," has been holden to apply to the
inventor, as well as to others. He is bound to make a ready, and early
application to the government for the privileges it confers, otherwise his
delay in this respect, and the public sale and use of the article of which he is the inventor, is considered a
relinquishment of any claim to an exclusive right.
In Wood v. Timmer,
1 Holt's Nisi Prius Reports, 58, the inventor had suffered the thing invented
to be sold, and to go into public use, for four months, before the grant of his
patent. The court say, the public sale of that which is afterwards made the
subject of a patent, though sold by the inventor only, makes the patent void.
In Pennock &
Sellers v. Dialogue, 1 Peters, 2, it is decided that the first inventor
cannot acquire a good title to a patent if he suffers the thing invented to go
into public use, or to be publicly sold for use, before he makes application
for a patent. Whittemore v. Cutter, 1 Gal. 438; Morris v. Huntingdon,
1 Paine, 348; Thompson v. Haight, U. S. Law Journal, Vol. 1, 563;
2, Kent's Com. 1st Ed. 302; Coke's Inst. 3, 184. The same doctrine is
applicable to the sale of books, prior to taking out a copy right. 2 Kent's
Com. 306 & 311.
*3 The above
authorities must be considered conclusive, unless the facts here are different
from those in the cases cited. The jury here found that the patent was granted
in December 1822, and that as early as 1819, the plaintiff had made, and sold
some shingle mills, agreeing with his patent; and that in the summer,
and fall of 1822, before obtaining said patent, he had made, and sold several
of said machines; and that many were in use previous to the obtaining of said letters patent, or any
evidence of application being made for the same.
Such being the testimony,
there seems to be but little doubt as to the rule of law to be applied. The
evidence of sale and use must be considered as a voluntary abandonment of the
plaintiff's claim, to any exclusive right, and disables him from such
compliance with the statute, as to render valid his letters patent.
The consideration of the
notes given in this case was a shingle mill and the exclusive right to use the
same in the town of Keene. The value of the shingle mill has been paid. There
being a failure, as to the remaining consideration, there is nothing farther
due, and according to the agreement of the parties,
A nonsuit must be
entered.
N.H. 1834.
6 N.H. 477, 26 Am.Dec. 711
END OF DOCUMENT