Superior Court of Judicature of New Hampshire.
N. T. DAVIS
v.
J. BELL & a.
July Term, 1837.
*1 An inventor, in
order to entitle himself to a patent, must give a true description of his
invention, or improvement, in his specification; and if his specification
states as his invention more than is new, the patent is void.
THIS was an action of
assumpsit upon the following contract.
"For value received,
we promise N. T. Davis, to pay him one hundred and fifty dollars by Sept. 1,
1833, with interest after April, 1833, at our store in Haverhill, on condition
that said Davis' conveyance to us of Shove & Hunt's patent right shall
approve itself as good in all respects as said Davis' covenants, in his deed of
conveyance of this date, have represented it.
December 27, 1832."
J. & J. BELL."
The cause was tried at May term, 1837, upon the general issue,
when it was admitted that the defendants made the contract, and that the
consideration on which their promise was founded was a conveyance to them of the
right of making, constructing, using, and vending, the improvement in the art
of tanning and manufacturing leather, for which letters patent were granted to
Shove & Hunt, bearing date the 13th May, 1828.
In the deed by which the
right was conveyed by the plaintiff to the defendants, was a covenant that the
improvement was an original invention of Shove & Hunt, for which they were
entitled to letters patent.
It appeared that the
specification of the improvement filed by Shove & Hunt in the patent office
of the United States, was as follows:
"Specification of
the improvement in tanning and manufacturing hides into leather, discovered by
Ebenezer Shove and Thomas Hunt.
This improvement consists
in a process of working off the hair with greater facility and with more safety
than in any other mode of sweating, and at the same time with less reduction
and relaxation of the fibres of the hides. For this purpose, hang or suspend
the hides singly by one edge in a tight place, vat, or pit, prepared for the
purpose, occasionally changing them edge for edge, after a day or two. A small
opening or vacancy should be left in each end of the place, vat, or pit, that
the air may circulate to carry off the warm, rarified air. When there are
indications of too much heat, care must be taken
to drench the hides with cold water. The manner of hanging or suspending the
hides, as above mentioned, prevents them from pressing upon each other, and
thereby the sweating process is conveniently carried on more regularly and
uniformly, and without the necessity of applying any heat, so that it may be
denominated the cold sweating process.
EBENEZER SHOVE.
THOMAS HUNT."
It further appeared, that
a mode of taking the hair from hides by sweating, had been known in England
long before the said discovery by Shove & Hunt, which English mode is
described in Rees' Encyclopedia, as follows:
*2 "When the
horns, &c. have been removed, the raw hides are laid in a heap for two or
three days, and are then suspended on poles in a close room, called a smoke
house, which is heated somewhat above the common temperature by a smouldering
fire. This occasions incipient putrefaction, which loosens the epidermis, and
renders the hair and other extraneous matter easy of separation from the true
skin. This is effected by extending the hide on a wooden horse, or beam, of a
conical form, and scraping it with a large two handled knife, called a fleshing
knife."--Rees' Cyclopedia; article, "Tanning."
On the part of the
defendants it was insisted, that the improvement described in the specification
was not a new invention, or at least it was not all new; and that if any part
of it was a new discovery it was not described in the specification in such clear and exact terms as
to distinguish it from what was before known; and as the specification seeks to
cover more than is new and useful, the letters patent were void.
But a verdict was taken
for the plaintiff, subject to the opinion of the court upon the foregoing case.
Headnotes
Rogers, for the
plaintiff.
Bell, for the
defendants.
RICHARDSON, C. J.,
delivered the opinion of the court.
The invention of the
patentees in this case is stated in the specification to be an improvement in
tanning and manufacturing hides into leather, which consists in a process of
working off the hair with greater facility and with more safety than in any
other mode of sweating. This process is thus described in the specification:
"Hang or suspend the
hides singly by one edge, in a tight place vat, or pit, prepared for the
purpose, occasionally changing them edge for edge, after a day or two. A small
opening, or vacancy, should be left in each end of the place, vat, or pit. When
there are indications of too much heat, care must be taken to drench the hides with cold water."
Now all this is stated in
the specification to be the invention of the patentees.
But it is very certain
that a process of taking hair from hides, by hanging them in a close room, was
well known in England long before this patent was granted. And a close room may
very well be understood to be "a place," within the meaning of the
specification in this case. The only things that are new in the process of
these patentees are the hanging of the hides by the edge, occasionally changing
them edge for edge, the holes in the end of the place, for carrying off the
warm air, and the drenching the hides with cold water. For aught that appears,
these may be new things in the process. But the hanging of the hides in a tight
place for the purpose of taking off the hair, is certainly not a new discovery.
*3 This specification
is then broader than the invention; and the patent covers matter for which the
patentees were not entitled to the protection of a patent.
The third section of the
statute of the United States, passed on the 21st February, 1793, under which
this patent was granted, provides that every inventor, before he can receive a
patent, shall deliver a written description of his invention, and of the manner
of using or process of compounding the same, in such full, clear, and exact
terms, as to distinguish the same from all other
things before known.
An inventor, in order to
entitle himself to a patent, must give in his specification a true description
of his invention, or improvement, and state clearly and accurately what he
claims as his invention; and if there be any ambiguity in any material part of
the description, the patent is void. 6 B. & C. 169, Bloxam
vs. Elsce; 3 C. & P. 611, Felton vs. Greaves; 1
Ryan & Moody 1, Savory vs. Price; 2 Barnewall &
Adolphus 370, Hullet vs. Hague; 1 D. & E. 602, Turner
vs. Winter.
And it is well settled,
that the specification must state what is new and what is old, in such a manner
that it may clearly appear what is claimed as a new discovery or invention; and
if it seeks to cover more than is new, the patent is void. 1 Starkie's N. P.
C. 199, MacFarlane vs. Price; 2 H. Bl. 488; 8 D.
& E. 95, Hornblower vs. Boulton; 1 Mason 182, Lowell
vs. Trevis; 1 Gallison 438, Woodcock vs. Parker; 2 Gallison
51, Odiorne vs. Winkley; 2 Mason 112, Moody vs. Fisk;
3 Merivale's R. 622, Hill vs. Thompson; 3 B. & B.
5, Campion vs. Benyon.
The patent in this case
is, then, void; and by the express terms of the contract on which this action
is founded, the plaintiff is not entitled to the money he seeks to recover. We
are, therefore, of opinion that the verdict be set aside, and
A new trial granted.
8 N.H. 500, 31 Am.Dec. 202
END OF DOCUMENT