Supreme Court of New Hampshire.
DOW
v.
HARKIN.
March 17, 1893.
Headnotes
*846 Gordon
Woodbury, G. W. Prescott, and O. E. Branch, for plaintiff.
W. A. J. Giles and H. G.
Sargent, for defendant.
*847 CHASE, J.
The defendant, by
accepting the assignment, became bound to perform the agreement set forth in it
to be performed by him, although he did not sign the instrument. Burbank v.
Pillsbury, 48 N. H. 475; Harriman v. Park, 55 N. H. 471; Association v. Gordon,
63 N. H. 505, 506, 3 Atl. 426. His executory agreement was the sole
consideration for the conveyance to him of the patent right. dies, and tools.
By repeatedly declining to perform it, he has rescinded the contract so far as
his acts could accomplish that result. He has, at least, given the plaintiff an option to consummate a
rescission by an acceptance of the offer of rescission necessarily included in
his declination. The plaintiff, by bringing this suit, has manifested his
assent to the proffered rescission. No prior notice was necessary, under the
circumstances. The plaintiff's repeated demands upon the defendant for the
performance of his agreement were sufficient notice that the plaintiff did not
intend to waive his rights. As the plaintiff received nothing from the
defendant, he did not have anything to return before exercising the right of
rescission. Upon the defendant's reconveyance of the property received, the
parties will be in their former positions. Danforth v. Dewey, 3 N. H. 79;
Fuller v. Little, 7 N. H. 535; Luey v. Bundy, 9 N. H. 298; Snow v. Prescott, 12
N. H. 535; Abbot v. Johnson, 32 N. H. 9, 20; Drew v. Claggett, 39 N. H. 431;
Smith v. Hatch, 46 N. H. 146; Chamberlain v. Perkins, 55 N. H. 237; Appleton v.
Insurance Co., 59 N. H. 541, 546; Foster v. Bartlett, 62 N. H. 617. If the
property in the defendant's possession, by virtue of the assignment, were all
chattels like the dies and tools, an action at law for its recovery might be an
adequate remedy. But it is not. A substantial portion of it is a patent
right,--an intangible, incorporeal thing, which cannot be specifically
recovered in an action at law. As the plaintiff has not an adequate remedy at
law, he is entitled to a remedy in equity. Exceptions sustained. Demurrer
overruled.
CLARK, J., did not sit. The others concurred.
N.H. 1893.
29 A. 846, 67 N.H. 383
END OF DOCUMENT