Supreme Court of New Hampshire.
Michael D. BOGOSIAN
v.
Abraham N. FINE.
Argued Nov. 3, 1954.
Decided Jan. 19, 1955.
Headnotes
**191 *341
Petition, for a declaratory judgment, R.L. c. 370, § 20, in which plaintiff sought a determination of his rights under
a bill of sale of part of a clothing business and a sublease of part of a
single retail store in Keene. Four main
issues are in controversy: (1) What was the store area intended to be
demised; (2) whether by selling 'two-piece dresses' plaintiff is in violation
of an agreement not to compete in selling women's 'suits'; (3) how long
plaintiff's unexercised option to purchase defendant's retained coat and suit
subiness continues; (4) whether plaintiff has the right to use the trade name
'Royal' against the defendant's wishes.
After a hearing before a
master, the issues were resolved in favor of the plaintiff.
The master's report was allowed and the defendant's exceptions thereto
were reserved and transferred by Grimes, J.
The facts are stated in the opinion.
Joseph T. Cristiano,
Keene, for plaintiff.
McLane, Carleton, Graf,
Greene & Brown, Manchester, Stanley M. Brown, Manchester, for defendant.
KENISON, Chief Justice.
I. The defendant Fine has operated a ladies'
ready-to-wear garment store on the ground floor at 5 Main Street, Keene, for
about twenty-five years under his trade name of 'The Royal.' He is lessee of the premises. He has also carried on a fur business on
other floors at the same address under the trade name 'Royal Furriers.' In 1950, the defendant decided to sell the
ready-to-wear part of the business and carry on only the fur business. The plaintiff, not having the necessary
capital, purchased part of the business with an option to purchase the
remainder. *342 The purchase and
sale agreement took the form of a bill of sale and a sublease, both dated June
23, 1950. The sublease from the
defendant to the plaintiff demised one-half of the ground floor store known as
the Royal located at 5 Main Street, Keene.
'The one-half of said store, to be occupied by the Lessee, his heirs and
assigns, shall consist of the front one-half
of said store, and each shall have the right to use one-half of the window
space. The Lessor shall have the right
to maintain an office in the rear of said store.' The ground floor store of the defendant consisted of two rooms, a
front room and a back room connected by a ramp.
[1] The master on all the evidence awarded the
plaintiff the entire front room of the store because of the construction placed
upon the lease by the parties themselves following its execution. It appeared that after the lease was executed,
the plaintiff installed the merchandise which he had purchased from the
defendant in racks and fixtures along the entire south wall of **192 the
front store and later gave the defendant permission to use the racks on the
north wall for displaying his merchandise, with the exception of a small
portion of the racks nearest the front of the store. The parties also moved the office in the rear of the front store
against the rear wall, replaced a dressing room located in that space and
constructed a temporary dressing room in a corner of the rear store which was
used by the customers of both parties.
[2][3][4] The practical construction of a contract
adopted by the parties thereto and the course of business followed by them is
evidence of their common understanding of the meaning of their contract and the
result they expected to accomplish thereby.
Horton v. Eagle Indemnity Ins. Company, 86 N.H. 472, 171 A. 322. While a practical construction of a contract
is not binding on strangers, it is binding on the immediate parties. Boston & Maine
Railroad v. Peterborough Railroad, 86 N.H. 217, 224, 166 A. 275; Berke Moore
Company v. Phoenix Bridge Company, 98 N.H. 261, 265, 98 A.2d 150. 'There is no surer way to find out what the
parties meant, than to see what they have done. Self-interest stimulates the mind to activity, and sharpens its
perspicacity. Parties in such cases
often claim more, but rarely less, than they are entitled to. The probabilities are largely in the
direction of the former.' Brooklyn Life
Ins. Co. of New York v. Dutcher, 95 U.S. 269, 273, 24 L.Ed. 410. The practical construction of a contract
adopted by the parties is generally followed in determining its legal
effect. 3 Williston, Contracts (rev.
ed.) § 623; 3 Corbin, Contracts, § 558.
Since the front store is about seventy-five per cent of the total square
footage of the entire ground floor, the defendant *343 claims that the
plaintiff in no event can claim more than fifty per cent of the total area of
the ground floor. The evidence does not
indicate that any such claim was made previously or that the parties divided the
premises by any such formula. Under the
circumstances the extent of the demised area was not so free from ambiguity as
to preclude evidence of the parties' conduct under the lease. The master's findings and rulings as to the
area demised and the rights acquired by the parties under the lease are
supported by the evidence and a reasonable construction of the written
documents of sale and lease. See
Restatement, Contracts, § 235, comment
e.
[5]
II. By the bill of sale the plaintiff
purchased all the ready-to-wear stock at the
Royal 'with the exception of Women's and Misses' coats and suits' and it was
also provided that neither the plaintiff nor the defendant would 'carry any
lines competing' with the other. The
plaintiff had the right to sell dresses but the defendant reserved the right to
sell coats and suits. Sometime in 1951 the plaintiff introduced for sale
two-piece garments consisting of an unlined jacket and skirt to be sold as one
unit. There was considerable conflict
in the evidence as to whether these two-piece garments were properly called
dresses, or suits or coat-dresses or suit-dresses and there was also conflict
in the evidence as to when and how the dispute arose. The master found that the
sale of the garments by the plaintiff did not violate the terms of the bill of
sale since their price range was from $6 to $17.95, while the price range of
defendant's merchandise was from $16.98 to $29.50. This was a permissible conclusion
from the evidence although it was not a compelled one. There was evidence that the defendant
initially approved of the plaintiff's introduction of the sale of the garments
and whether the defendant's final protest occurred in 1951, or in 1952 as found
by the master, did not indicate that the master's conclusions were prejudiced
or inconsistent. Golding-Keene Co. v.
Fidelity Phoenix Fire Insurance Company, 96 N.H. 64, 70, 69 A.2d 856, 12
A.L.R.2d 591. This case will not
illuminate the twilight area between suits and dresses but it does resolve the
issue of competition between the parties in favor of the plaintiff as
determined by the master.
[6][7] III.
In addition to the merchandise and business sold by the defendant to the
plaintiff, the bill of sale provided that **193 the plaintiff 'shall
have the right to purchase the coat and suit business above reserved by A. N.
Fine at the invoice price upon giving A. N. Fine seven (7) days notice * * *'
at an increased monthly *344 rental.
The sublease, which runs for a period of nine years until October 1,
1959, was executed on the same day as the bill of sale. Both these documents were part of the same
transaction and are to be construed together.
Hill v. Huntress, 43 N.H. 480.
The right of plaintiff to purchase the retained coat and suit business
of the defendant created an option which was supported by a valuable
consideration. Barclay v. Dublin Lake
Club, 89 N.H. 87, 192 A. 620. Neither the bill of sale nor the sublease fixed
the time within which the option expired 'and this being the case, it is to be
presumed that the parties intended it should not expire until after the lapse
of a reasonable time.' New England Box Co. v. Prentiss, 75 N.H. 246, 247, 72 A.
826; 5 Williston, Contracts (Rev. ed.), §
1441. See Kann v. Wausau
Abrasives Co., 81 N.H. 535, 129 A. 374.
[8] In determining that a reasonable time within
which the plaintiff could exercise his option was the unexpired term of the
lease itself, there were several factors which make the master's finding a
reasonable one. The plaintiff was inexperienced, without sufficient
capital to purchase the coat and suit business, and required considerable time
in his new venture to be able to exercise the option. These factors were known to the defendant. Other provisions in the contracts indicate
that no fixed time limit was intended by the parties. The bill of sale provides that the defendant agrees 'not to sell
said coat and suit business to any third party without first obtaining the
written permission' of the plaintiff.
Paragraph 3 of the bill of sale gave the plaintiff the right to purchase
the store fixtures 'at any time that he and A. N. Fine may agree upon a fair
price for said fixtures.' Without
passing on the definiteness of this particular provision, it clearly indicates
that the option need not be exercised by June 1, 1952, as contended by the
defendant.
IV. The issue as to the use of the trade name
'Royal' by the plaintiff is more difficult.
The master's findings are as follows:
'Since the execution of
the lease and bill of sale, the plaintiff, at the defendant's insistence, has
conducted his retail business under the name of 'Royal Ready to Wear'. To permit the defendant now to prevent the
plaintiff from continuing to use that trade-name and to use it himself would be
most inequitable. The Master finds that
the plaintiff has the right to operate his business under the name of 'Royal
Ready to Wear', even though the defendant may, at some time have used that name
and, since the bill of sale was given, has registered it as his own.'
*345 [9][10] It
is to be noted that neither the sublease nor the bill of sale give the plaintiff
any rights with respect to the use of the trade name 'The Royal' or 'Royal
Ready-to-Wear.' The only reference to
'Royal' is that used for descriptive reference to the defendant and the
defendant's store name to establish the location of the premises in the
lease. The plaintiff acquired no right
to the use of the name from either the bill of sale or the sublease. It is not disputed that the defendant has a
property right in the name which is valuable and upon which he has spent
considerable money in its development and registration. R.L. c. 186, § 10; R.L. c. 207-A, as inserted by Laws 1949, c. 219. Although the defendant permitted and
encouraged the use of the trade name for the purposes of advertising and sales,
this did not convert a revocable license into an irrevocable grant or raise an
estoppel against the defendant. Conway
Nat. Bank v. Pease, 76 N.H. 319, 82 A. 1068.
[11] The
record shows that much confusion in the public mind and in the mind of creditors
has resulted from joint use of the trade name, 'The Royal' and 'Royal
Ready-to-Wear.' This has affected
credit ratings, good will and business reputation. The defendant could properly revoke the permission to use the
trade name which he originally allowed.
Batchelder v. Hibbard, **194 58 N.H. 269. The plaintiff did not buy the trade name and
is not entitled to continue to use it to the damage of the defendant and to the
confusion of the public. Nardini's Restaurant
& Co. v. Sterling Restaurant Co., 93
N.H. 364, 42 A.2d 325; Purcell v. Summers, 4 Cir., 145 F.2d 979; Restatement,
Torts, § § 717, 730.
The decree is affirmed in
all respects except as it relates to use of trade names wherein the defendant
is entitled to a decree in his favor.
Decree affirmed in part
and reversed in part.
All concurred except
DUNCAN, J., who was in doubt as to part I.
N.H. 1955
111 A.2d 190, 99 N.H. 340
END OF DOCUMENT