Patents and Monopolies
Prof. Karl F. Jorda
Reasons why a patent per se is not a monopoly:
- A monopoly is something in the public domain that the government takes from the public and gives to a person (like in the famous British case of the playing cards). An invention is something that did not exist before and was not in the public domain. It is something novel, that upon publication via the grant of the patent enriches the public domain with the knowledge of the invention, and upon expiration of the patent, enters into the public domain, free to be used by anyone.
- According to our patent legislation, a patent is "personal property", like any other personal property (35 U.S.C. § 261).
- And according to the 1995 DOJ/FTC Antitrust Guidelines, patents are "comparable to any other form of property," are not "presumed to create market power" and licensing patents is "generally pro-competitive." This marks a 180-degree turn in their policy.
- A patent does not grant the positive right to make, use and sell the patented invention but merely the negative right to prevent others from making, using and selling such an invention.
- The patent right or property is too severely restricted in terms of duration and scope and the patent misuse law, to be considered a monopoly.
- There are almost always alternatives available to the public - prior art alternatives, alternatives that are obvious and hence not patentable and alternatives provided by improvement inventions.
- If anything, patents intensify competition; they can lead to many improvement patents as competitors are motivated to
"invent around."
Better terminology for "patent monopoly": patent property, patent grant, patent right, exclusivity. Also to be avoided: "legal monopoly," "limited monopoly," "temporary monopoly" or "desirable monopoly."