

Pierce Law Publications & Papers
Credos - Insights - Truisms... on Intellectual Property Rights and Technology Transfer
- The defense of intellectual property rights today is the new frontier as were the human rights yesterday.
- An effective IP system is indispensable to technological development which leads to economic growth and social welfare.
- An IP system should be part of a country's infrastructure from the outset rather than something that one thinks about after reaching a fairly advanced stage of development (Robert Sherwood).
- There are no viable alternatives to the present patent system which is the only system "that is compatible with the system of market economy" (Professor Carlos Fernandez-Novoa).
- There is solid correlation between the quantity of investments that can be attracted and the quality of the patent system (Professor Mansfield).
- Of the four incentives provided by a patent system, namely, to invent, to disclose, to "invent around" and to invest, the incentive to invest is the most important.
- An IP system does benefit nationals, not just foreign corporation; after all there is genius and creativity everywhere but they need nurture.
- A patent and other IP are property and are not and cannot be monopolies (a patent does not take from the public and give to the individual; on the contrary, it takes from the individual and gives to the public).
- "Everything under the sun made by man is patentable" (U.S. Supreme Court in the Chakrabarty decision); hence, there should virtually be no exclusions of subject matter from patentability.
- Subject matter that is viewed as too important to be protected (e.g. pharmaceuticals) is, on the contrary, "too important not to be protected" (Professor Thomas Field).
- Some countries have gold, some have oil - and some have technology and those that have gold and oil do not consider them part of the "common heritage of mankind" and accordingly give them away for free (Naboth Mvere, former Controller of IP, Zimbabwe).
- The duration of a patent should be no shorter than 20 years from filing and preferably 25 years or more or provide for patent term restoration to compensate for regulatory and other delays.
- Lead times for commercializing inventions have become longer in all areas and not just the pharmaceutical area and hence conventional periods of three or four years till lapsing or compulsory licensing and short patent terms are badly out of step with present realities.
- Patents and trade secrets are not mutually exclusive but complementary; they "dovetail" (U.S. Supreme Court in the Bonito Boats decision); thus, the question is not whether to patent or to padlock but rather what to patent and what to keep a trade secret and whether it is best to patent and to padlock, i.e. expoit the overlap.
- "Trade secret law and patent law have coexisted in this country for over one hundred years..... the extension of trade secret protection (even) to clearly patentable inventions does not conflict with the patent policy of disclosure." (U.S. Supreme Court in the Kewanee Oil decision).
- Multiple forms of protection can and should be utilized and integrated by exploiting the overlap between the various IP categories, especially in modern fields of technology; this provides fall-back positions, achieves synergistic effects and thus optimizes exclusivity (Professor Jay Dratler).
- Technology transfers, licensing and investments are ever so much easier to carry out and accomplish via patents and other IPRs as vehicles or bases.
- Importation of technology leads not only to export of products but also to export of adapted, improved technology (reverse technology transfer).
- The days when technology transferors took advantage of transferees (in developing countries) are gone, the realization having taken hold that the only viable license is one that results from a win/win approach and passes the fairness test.
<< Return to Pierce Law Publications & Papers