Pierce Law Publications & Papers

The Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT)Experience with the PCT in Industry

by Prof. Karl F. Jorda

ASIPI Administrative Council Meeting
Isla de Margarita, October 24, 1996



I. Introduction

Unquestionably, the PCT is sweeping the globe - except for Latin America. According to Dr. Arpad Bogsch, Director General, World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), the three most important reasons for the rapid growth of the PCT are the following:

(1)"...the PCT system is a good system. It is user-friendly: it is reasonably costed and its use is legally safe, because its use is relatively simple and its procedural deadlines are realistic.

...

(2)...the awareness of its usefulness of potential applicants has been constantly increasing as has the skill of patent counsels, patent agents and patent lawyers in handling international applications.

...

(3)...so many talented individuals, believing in the system's usefulness and having the right mixture of bold inspiration and down-to-earth realism, have devoted their intelligence, stamina and dynamism to finding the best methods of using, and the best ways for constantly improving, the system."

(Arpad Bogsch, "Summary History of the Patent Cooperation Treaty(1966-1995)", INDUSTRIAL PROPERTY & COPYRIGHT, November 1995, pp.412, 418-419.)

After considerable initial scepticism and reluctance, more and more US companies have become believers in and users of the PCT. For instance, in 1995 almost one-half of all PCT applications originated in the US, that is 16,588 out of 38,906.

Until a few years ago, the level of errors emanating from the PCT Branch of the US Patent & Trademark Office (PTO) was such that applicants were forced, at a minimum, to endure an unnecessary burden to discover and correct errors, and, at a maximum, to face the potential loss of intellectual property rights internationally. Additionally, in comparison to interpretation by the European Patent Office (EPO) and WIPO, the PCT Branch frequently took a very strict and overly narrow interpretation of PCT rules. This put the US applicant and practitioner at a disadvantage in comparison with applicants and practitioners in other countries and potentially led to loss of international intellectual property rights. Also early on some important countries to file in were not yet PCT members. But all these startup problems are now a thing of the past.

The PCT, with its fast growing membership - 87 at last count, has become an important tool for foreign filing and a global patent strategy. In fact, for some companies it is becoming the vehicle of choice or even the exclusive vehicle for obtaining patent coverage abroad. This trend is now accelerating due to the rapidly changing environment in the US and in other countries brought about by trade agreements, in particular GATT-TRIPS and its requirements. Clearly, the PCT is also a means to more readily adapt to and live with change in the international patent landscape, in addition to offering numerous other tactical and strategic advantages.

II. The PCT Procedure

The PCT, as per abbreviated excerpts from a WIPO Handbook, entitled "Basic Seminar on the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT), Franklin Pierce Law Center, Concord, N.H., April 19-20, 1996," p.276-278, provides a procedure whereby an applicant in one of the 87 PCT countries can file a patent application and obtain a filing date in one or more PCT countries by filing a single application in applicant's home country and in applicant's home language.

The procedures under the PCT are administered by WIPO in Geneva and are executed by the PCT International Bureau (IB) of WIPO and the patent offices of some PCT countries acting in the capacity of a Receiving Office (RO), an International Searching Authority (ISA), and an International Preliminary Examining Authority (IPEA).

Once filed, an international (PCT) application begins a two-step process consisting of an International Phase followed by a National or Regional Phase. The National/Regional Phase is conducted in the individual national/regional patent offices and, for the most part, follows procedures similar to direct filings. The International Phase consists of two parts, the second of which is optional. During the first part (usually called Chapter I after the section of the Treaty where it is set forth), an application undergoes a formal examination by the RO and is transmitted to an ISA for a prior art search and report, and to the IB for publication and distribution to the patent offices of the PCT countries designated in the Request (application). Following issuance of the International Search Report (ISR), the PCT provides an applicant a period of time in which claim amendments may be submitted to the IB.

The timing of all events occurring during the International Phase is based on the earliest priority date of an application. If an application is first filed under the PCT (filed without any priority claim under the provisions of the Paris Convention), the "earliest priority date" is the international (PCT) filing date. If a PCT application is filed claiming priority under the provisions of the Paris Convention, this date is the earliest priority date claimed in the application. For applications first filed under the PCT, the ISR issues approximately nine months after filing; for PCT Paris Convention filings, the report issues about sixteen months after the earliest priority date. Regardless of whether an international application is the first-filed application or is filed under the Paris Convention, the application and its search report will be published about eighteen months after the earliest priority date.

Under Chapter I procedures, the PCT affords an applicant twenty months from the earliest priority date to evaluate the claimed invention, consider the prior art in the search report, and make a decision whether to invest the money required to enter the national or regional patent offices, and, if necessary, obtain translations. This is an additional eight months beyond the twelve-month limit available under the Paris Convention alone.

To further increase the time for decision making and to obtain the additional benefit of an examination on the merits, for most PCT countries applicants can avail themselves of the optional procedures under Chapter II of the PCT. Provided an applicant files a Demand for International Preliminary Examination with a competent IPEA within nineteen months of the earliest priority date, the time to enter the National/Regional Phase is extended from twenty months to thirty months after the earliest priority date. This additional ten months allows time for the IPEA to examine the application and to issue a Written Opinion regarding the novelty, unobviousness and utility of the claimed invention. In the Written Opinion, the IPEA examiner may also comment on other matters believed to require amendment. Following receipt of the written Opinion, an applicant is

given the opportunity to respond to the IPEA examiner's opinion with arguments, data and/or amendments. Additionally, an applicant is entitled to an interview with the examiner. Under the PCT, however, no response to a Written Opinion is required.

At some time before about twenty-eight months from the earliest priority date, the IPEA examiner makes a final review of the application, including any arguments and/or amendments submitted in response to the Written Opinion, and issues an International Preliminary Examination Report (IPER). This advisory report is forwarded to the applicant and to the patent office of each of the PCT countries elected at the time of filing the Demand. An applicant, now having both the ISR and the IPER, is faced with the decision if and where to enter the National/Regional Phase. The National/Regional Phase entry must be made on or before the thirty-month anniversary of the priority filing.

III. Advantages & Benefits

The major advantages and benefits of filing under the PCT lie in the procedures and options available during the International Phase. But prosecution in the subsequent National Phase can also be considerably simpler and cheaper.

First and foremost, via the PCT route, it is possible to gain more time, up to an additional eighteen months, to evaluate the technical merit and commercial potential of a given invention and, make more rational foreign filing decisions and this comes with significant savings in filing fees and translation costs.

In the experience of The Procter & Gamble Company (P&G), a well-known US multi-national manufacturer and marketer of a wide variety of consumer, medical and industrial products, this additional decision making time results in a total application drop rate of as much as 20% as well as a 30% drop rate in PCT-designated country filings at national phase entry (WIPO Handbook, supra at 289.)

According to a P&G spokesman the rationale for changing from a direct national/regional practice to PCT practice was as follows:

"New developments keep coming from the global research and development groups at an increasing rate. Often there are more promising developments than can be properly evaluated in the time afforded by the Paris Convention. P&G needed more time to assess the costs versus the benefits of obtaining patent protection for each of the new developments. Additionally, in an atmosphere of expanding geographic interests and variable international monetary conditions, it is advantageous to delay patenting expenditures (translations, filing costs, etc.) to allow more informed decisions regarding the allocation of intellectual-property-protection funds. In brief, we needed to keep the maximum number of options open for as long as possible to allow the final national patent filing decisions to be made in light of the maximum scientific and business information.

...

All in all, for P&G, the additional expense of lodging an application under the PCT appeared more than justified by the flexibility available under the PCT."

(Franklin Pierce Law Center PCT Handbook, p.279, 280 WIPO Handbook, supra at p.279, 280.)

No doubt this reasoning applies equally also to other corporations.

What's more, the PCT offers so much flexibility that, in the case of technologies with short life cycles, it is possible to obtain an earlier international search and patent grant by filing a PCT application ab initio rather than towards the end of the Paris Convention priority year.

In addition and in comparison to the prior direct national/regional practice, the procedures for all PCT countries are now greatly standardized.

Still more advantages and benefits can be realized as can be seen from the following chapter.

IV. Strategies of US Corporations

A. Designation of PCT Countries

Typically, a US corporation will designate all PCT countries, if it plans to file for patents in eight or more PCT countries, with regional offices counting as one, because no additional designation fees beyond the first eleven country designations are payable. Countries that are members of the EPO are designated through the EPO only. Inasmuch as all European Union (EU) countries are now members of the PCT and the EPO, the PCT is an excellent way for obtaining patents for all of the EU. If individual EPO countries are designated in addition to the EPO, voluminous but unnecessary correspondence to and from the individual EU patent offices is the result.

In light of rapid changes on the economic scene and in intellectual property systems and growth of international markets around the globe, on the one hand, and the passage of time since the first or initial filing, on the other hand, obtaining patent protection by entering the National Phase in additional (or different) PCT countries may be indicated and, hence, keeping all options open by designation of all PCT countries is good practice.

If filing in three to seven countries is contemplated, PCT filing is undertaken designating these countries. This does not present the option to expand the country list of the national phase, but offers all other advantages that PCT filing has to offer, in particular additional decision-making time.

It goes without saying that if only one or two foreign countries are eyed for patent protection, direct national applications are filed in the interest of cost savings.

B. Choice of ISA and IPEA

While the initial tendency on the part of US companies was to have the USPTO do the international search and international preliminary examination, it was soon realized that it would be more advantageous to have only the EPO do it or do it on top of the USPTO.

Indeed, a significant advantage of the PCT to US applicants is the ability to have search and examination reports from two patent offices prior to entering the National Phase. This could be achieved, for example, by filing a regular US application, one year later filing a PCT case requesting that the EPO perform the search, and requesting that the EPO also do the preliminary examination when filing the Demand under Chapter II of the PCT. Using this procedure, applicants more than likely would have the results of an examination in the parent US application, as well as the results of the preliminary examination procedure conducted in the EPO, all prior

to the time necessary to enter the National Phase around the world. It is for this reason that many US applicants choose the EPO for the search and preliminary examination.

And otherwise there are many advantages to choosing the EPO to do the search and examination. First of all, it is well-known that EPO searches are more thorough. Furthermore, the EPO has stated that a positive IPER will lead to an early grant of a European patent. That is so because the same EPO Examiner, who did the International Preliminary Examination, will be assigned the case and almost automatically and immediately allow it. Also, the EPO search procedure and classification system is preferred by many, because in certain technologies a broader class of subject matter can be maintained in one application without additional unity-of-invention concerns and restriction requirements and attendant additional invention fees.

In this connection I might or should say a word about the so-called "Super PCT" or as it is now called the "Supplementary International Search System". As originally proposed by Dr. Arpad Bogsch in a PCT Meeting in March of 1992, the "Super PCT" would involve searches and preliminary examinations by the EPO, USPTO and JP, i.e. all three, and issuance of a combined report.

This proposal has been scaled back to a procedure where an

"applicant could request a supplementary international search instead of, or in addition to, filing a demand for international preliminary examination, and benefit from the proposed postponement of the time limit for entering the national phase from 20 to 30 months from the priority date, even if a demand for international preliminary examination was not filed. The proposed supplementary international search system would result in two search reports established by different International Searching Authorities, which would be more likely to be exhaustive with respect to the cited prior art."

(INDUSTRIAL PROPERTY AND COPYRIGHT - JULY/AUGUST 1996, p. 241)

 

 

This "supplementary international search proposal is not being pursued at this stage due to a number of questions raised by some of the major Patent Offices which act as International Searching and Preliminary Examining Authorities under the PCT."

(Personal communication by Philip Thomas, Director, PCT Legal Division, October 2, 1996)

However, this proposal, which is indeed very interesting because U.S. industry has already anticipated it and, in effect, is already practicing it, as pointed out above, is still alive and the International Bureau plans "to study possible alternatives (and) to continue seeking the views of users..." (INDUSTRIAL PROPERTY AND COPYRIGHT, ibidem).

C. Docketing

In light of the differences in PCT practice to national procedures and the strict enforcement of the formal rules of the PCT, careful docketing and a reliable docketing procedure is very important. But once such a procedure is established and routinely adhered to, using the PCT presents no more pitfalls and risks than direct national filing.

Key to a fail-safe docketing procedure is an internal tracking system to monitor and follow-up on critical events in the PCT process, such as, tracking receipts of

a) the application by the IB,

b) the ISR,

c) the Demand by the IPEA

d) IB's notification to the elected offices that Chapter II provisions apply and

e) return-receipts sent with every PCT submission.

In addition, during Chapter II processing, the receipt of the IPER, due by the end of the twenty-ninth month is tracked and the response due date for Written Opinions is docketed.

The most important docketing functions are to be sure that the application is received in the RO prior to the end of the Paris Convention year, that it has at least the minimum requirements entitling it to a serial number and date, that a serial number and date are granted (and that the designations are correct as set forth), and that the application enters the National Phase at the twentieth month or in the case of Chapter II, that the Preliminary Examination be requested by the end of the 19th month, and that the National Phase be entered at the thirtieth month.

D. Written Opinions

Anent Written Opinions, there is no requirement, as stated above, to respond but inasmuch as substantive issues raised in an IPER have to be addressed during the National/Regional phase in the patent offices of all elected countries, a response is the better practice. A response, and possibly also a second response, can traverse rejections or other negative findings and/or amend the application while still in the International Phase to obtain a favorable IPER and thus save time and effort later on during prosecution in the National/Regional phase.

V. Conclusion

The PCT, which is constantly being improved and refined by WIPO, for which WIPO is to be highly commended, provides an excellent vehicle for more uniform worldwide patent prosecution. Hence, much greater use of it can be expected. And soon the PCT will be the norm for international patent practice - if it is not already.

As a last point let me repeat the recommendation which I made to the Indonesians in 1990 when I served as consultant to the Indonesian Directorate General of Trademarks, Copyrights and Patents in the matter of establishing a patent operation under their first patent law:

"Indonesia should join the PCT as soon as possible. PCT filing takes the pressure off inasmuch as preliminary examination is carried out elsewhere and examination can wait for 18 months, or 30 months in case of priority, and until search and preliminary examination reports are received which are automatically provided.... The PCT is of special usefulness for developing countries as they frequently do not have access to sufficient documentation to enable an adequate search to be carried out."

This recommendation is equally applicable to Latin American countries, which do not have adequate search capabilities, that is, requisite data bases and trained personnel.

Karl F. Jorda

David Rines Professor of Intellectual Property Law

Franklin Pierce Law Center

10/24/96

<< Return to Pierce Law Publications & Papers