
A. Introduction
The GATT/WTO Agreement on Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property (TRIPS), concluded on April 15, 1994 and entered into force on January 1, 1995, is to be implemented by most countries of the world as of January 1, 2000, making the year 2000 an important milestone in international intellectual property (IP) systems.
In spite of criticism that TRIPS
TRIPS is a momentous event in the history of IP protection and a signal breakthrough on the road towards harmonization, internationalization, and globalization of IP systems.
Adrian Otten, Director of IP and Investment, WTO Secretariat, reported last year (20 ARS JURIS 133) that, while the principal challenges remain for the future,
"WTO Members can look back on the first three and a half years of the TRIPS Agreement with some satisfaction. Implementation by developed countries has been broadly satisfactory, although not without its gaps and delays. The TRIPS Council has developed and run-in important mechanisms for monitoring compliance. The dispute settlement mechanism has, in general, worked well and has already yielded positive results in the TRIPS area. A huge amount has been done by developing countries in anticipation of the end of their transition periods. Cooperation with WIPO has been established and is going well."
The implementation of the TRIPS Agreement is indeed officially completed in developed countries, even though disagreements may remain on whether implementation was, in all cases, fully compatible with TRIPS.
The TRIPS Council, together with WIPO, which signed a Cooperation Agreement with WTO in 1995, are monitoring the implementation work around the world. The WTO-WIPO Cooperation Agreement provides for joint work on a computerized database of intellectual property laws and regulations and cooperation on the implementation of TRIPS. The two organizations also agreed to keep "regular contact and exchange non-confidential information" and to treat the other organization's Members in the same way it deals with its own members. And both organizations agreed to cooperation "so as to maximize the usefulness of those activities and ensure their mutually supportive nature."
B. Salient Features of TRIPS
TRIPS sets forth minimum standards to be met by all countries party to the WTO for the according of rights for the protection of IP and for the enforcement of those rights. The underlying obligation for all countries is based on national treatment and most favored nation treatment. The former requires countries to provide to nationals of other countries treatment no less favorable than that accorded its own nationals regarding the protection of IP. The MFN obligation requires that, with some express exceptions, countries accord, "immediately and unconditionally," to the nationals of other countries any advantage, favor, privilege or immunity relating to the protection of IP granted the nationals of another country. "Protection" is defined in a footnote as including "matters affecting the availability, acquisition, scope, maintenance, and enforcement" of IPR's as well as those matters affecting use of IPR's specifically addressed in TRIPS.
As regards copyrights and related rights, countries will be obligated to comply with Articles 1-21 of the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works. Article 6bis of the convention is excepted because it concerns an author's "moral rights," not economic rights that are appropriate for an agreement on trade across national borders. TRIPS requires countries to protect computer programs a "literary works" under the Berne Convention and to protect compilations of data and other material that constitute intellectual creations because of the arrangement of their contents.
Under TRIPS, commercial rental of computer programs and cinematographic works is to be prohibited; however, a country may be excepted from this obligation in the case of cinematographic works provided that such rental has not led to material impairment of the reproduction rights of the copyright owners. The exception to the ban on commercial rental for cinematographic works was negotiated by the U.S. because we have thousands of rental outlets in the U.S. which would have made obtaining an exclusive right very difficult and also because rentals of motion picture videos here have not resulted in any widespread copying.
Under TRIPS, performers must be given the right to prevent the unauthorized recording of their performances and, should such recording occur, to prevent reproduction of that recording. They also must have the right to prevent the unauthorized broadcast of their live performance and any other communication of that performance to the public. Sound recording producers must be given the right to prevent unauthorized reproduction of their sound recordings, directly or indirectly, and to prevent rentals of the sound recordings. These rights of performers and sound recording producers are to extend for 50 years from the date on which a performance or fixation occurred.
Broadcasters' rights under TRIPS are provided in alternative form. Broadcasters must have the ability to prevent fixation of broadcasts, reproduction of such fixations, rebroadcast by wireless means and any other communication of their broadcasts to the public, or, if a country does not provide rights to broadcast organizations themselves, it must ensure to the owners of the copyright in the subject matter of the broadcasts the possibility of preventing the activities mentioned. Broadcasters' rights will extend for at least 20 years from the date on which the broadcast occurred.
With respect to trademarks and service marks, TRIPS adds significantly to the protection accorded trademarks under the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property in several ways. First, TRIPS defines trademarks and identifies elements that must be eligible, individually or in combination, for recognition as trademarks and expressly requires that service marks be registrable. Second, a system of publication and cancellation must be available in connection with the registration of trademarks and service marks. Third, protection of well-known marks also is extended to include service marks. In addition, protection of trademarks is required, even where the goods or services are not similar to those used in connection with a registered mark, if the use of a similar mark on those goods or services would indicate a connection with a registered mark and would cause damage to the owner of the registered mark.
The term of registration for a trademark must be at least 7 years and the registration must be renewable indefinitely. Registrations can be cancelled for non-use only after an uninterrupted period of three years of non-use, and, even then, a registration cannot be cancelled if the non-use resulted from conditions that were beyond the trademark owner's control. Conditions like import restrictions and other government requirements for goods and services are expressly identified as conditions justifying non-use. Use in a country by a licensee of the mark's owners precludes a claim of non-use.
Another important provision bars compulsory licensing for trademarks and allows assignment of trademarks with or without the business to which the trademark belongs. Governments are also prohibited from imposing special requirements on the use of trademarks, such as use with local marks or use in a way that detracts from the effectiveness of the mark in distinguishing the goods or services of the owner from those of others.
Regarding geographical indications, defined as an indication that identifies a good originating in the territory of a member, or a region or locality in that territory, where a given quality, reputation or other characteristic of the good is attributable to its geographical origin, TRIPS requires that countries have the legal means for "interested parties" to prevent use of any means in the designation or presentation of a good that indicates or suggests, in a manner that misleads the public, that the good in question comes from a geographical area other than its true place of origin. To prevent confusion when two place names are the same, the provision is applicable even where an indication is literally true, but it implies that the goods come from a different territory. Member countries must also refuse or invalidate the registration of a trademark containing a geographical indication with respect to goods not originating in the territory indicated, where the use of the trademark would mislead the public as to the true place or original of the goods.
There are special provisions in TRIPS dealing with wines and spirits that prohibit even the use of indications in combination with "kind," "type," "style," "Imitation," or similar words. There are exceptions, however, for terms that have become generic and for marks that have been used on the same goods or services in good faith for 10 years prior to the conclusion of the Uruguay Round. The U.S. Bureau of Tobacco, Alcohol and firearms (BATF) does prohibit use of labels that would mislead consumers as to the origin of alcoholic beverages, so the U.S. is ready in compliance in that regard.
TRIPS calls for further negotiations on geographical indications in connection with wines and spirits. The reputation of California regional wines, Kentucky bourbon, Milwaukee beer, etc. is increasing around the world. The U.S. and other countries that produce wines and spirits might profit from taking a second look at this subject to determine if it is appropriate to regard future negotiations offensively, rather than defensively.
In connection with industrial designs, TRIPS requires countries to provide protection for new and original industrial designs, with certain exceptions. Textiles receive particular mention to ensure that the requirements for protection are not so excessive that they effectively deny protection for textile designs, which tend to change frequently. Owners of protected industrial designs are to be able to prevent others from making, selling or importing articles bearing or embodying their designs for a period of at least 10 years.
On patents, TRIPS contains some significant benefits for inventors. First, TRIPS requires that product and process patents be available in all fields of technology. The only permissible exceptions to that broad obligation are for diagnostic, therapeutic and surgical methods for treating humans or animals, and for plants and animals, other than microorganisms, and essentially biological processes for producing plants or animals. Countries not providing patent protection for plant varieties must provide that protection through an effective sui generis system.
TRIPS specifies that patent owners must be given the right to prevent others from making, using, offering for sale, selling, or importing products covered by a product patent and from using a process claimed in a patent or using, offering for sale, selling, or importing at least the product obtained directly from use of the process. The right to assign or license rights under the patent is also assured. TRIPS members are permitted to maintain limited exemptions to patent rights so long as those exemptions do not unreasonably conflict with the normal exploitation of the patent by the patent owner, nor prejudice his legitimate interests. This is intended to allow such things as exhaustion within a country after the sale of a patented product and experimental use for purposes of advancing technology.
Of particular importance to patent owners are the restrictions that the TRIPS Agreement places on compulsory licensing. First, countries will no longer be allowed to grant compulsory licenses if a patentee does not manufacture the patented invention in the country. Importation will have to be treated as "working," so, only in circumstances in which a patentee makes no provision for marketing his product in a country, would a compulsory license for "non-working" be consistent with TRIPS. TRIPS also imposes conditions on all compulsory licensing to ensure that voluntary licensing is encouraged, that payment for any compulsory license is fair, that rights under a license are non-exclusive and can be transferred only under limited conditions, and that decisions regarding compulsory licenses are appealable. There are special provisions dealing with government use of patent rights and for use in national emergencies. Finally, dependent patent compulsory licenses may still be granted, but only if 1) the second invention represents an important technical advance over the first patent, and 2) the owner of the first patent receives a cross-license under the second patent. In addition, a dependent patent compulsory license is assignable only with the assignment of the second patent.
With respect to semiconductor chip layout designs, the TRIPS text incorporates and corrects the deficiencies of the Washington Treaty on Intellectual Property in Respect of Integrated circuits. Unlike the Washington Treaty, TRIPS 1) expressly covers articles incorporating protected chips; 2) assures a reasonable royalty to the right-holder after notice in connection with the disposition of stock on hand; 3) extends the term of protection to 10 years (Washington required 8); and 4) prohibits compulsory licensing in connection with semiconductor chip layout designs except as an antitrust remedy or for noncommercial government use.
Regarding trade secrets, the TRIPS Agreement speaks of "undisclosed information," but is referring to what we call trade secrets. The obligations look very much like those in our Uniform Trade Secrets Act. Those who control information that is not generally known or readily ascertainable, that has value because it is not known, and that is the subject of efforts to keep it secret, must be given the ability to prevent others from disclosing, acquiring, or using the information in a matter that is contrary to honest commercial practice.
In addition to providing for the protection of trade secrets, TRIPS also calls for steps to be taken to protect against unfair commercial use of data submitted to government agencies to obtain marketing approval for pharmaceutical and agricultural chemical products containing new chemical entities. In this context, "unfair commercial use" means other parties relying on the data to obtain marketing approval for their own products, where they have made no financial contribution to the original submitter of the data.
Anent enforcement, members shall ensure fair and equitable and not unnecessarily complicated, costly or lengthy enforcement procedures against any act of infringement, including remedies to prevent and deter infringements. There is no obligation to establish a separate judicial system for enforcing IPR's .
Civil and administrative procedures and remedies include: assurance that confidential information will be protected during and after proceedings; authority to discover evidence solely in the hands of another party (refusal to provide evidence may not stand in the way of a decision); conditions under which precautionary measures, such as injunctions, are to be made available; and approaches to damages and other remedies, compelling information regarding other infringers and indemnification of defendants.
There are special requirements related to border measures: members shall enable right holders to lodge a request with customs officials to block the importation of infringing goods; precautions against false charges and delays are provided and members shall provide criminal procedures and penalties (imprisonment and/or fines; also, seizure, forfeiture and destructions) at least in cases of trademark counterfeiting and copyright piracy on a commercial scale, possibly also in other cases of willful, commercial-scale infringement.
C. Dispute Settlements
TRIPS also has provisions for "dispute prevention and settlement." For the sake of transparency, members shall publish all relevant laws, regulations, decisions and rulings as well as agreements with other members, furnish these to Council for TRIPS for review and to other members upon request and disputes themselves shall be settled as per Articles XXII and XXIII of GATT 1994. The Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes will apply to all consultations and dispute settlements in the WTO and to all of the agreements under the WTO umbrella.
Time limits are set to ensure that the procedures are not delayed. Parties cannot block adoption of Panel reports by the Dispute Settlement body, which also is made up of all Members of the WTO. A Standing Appellate Body, made up of 7 recognized authorities on law, international trade, and the subject matter of the agreements and who are not associated with any government, will review appeals on issues of law covered in a panel's report and any legal interpretation developed by a panel. The Appellate Body can uphold, modify or reverse the legal findings and conclusions of the Panel. The Appellate Body's report will be adopted by the Dispute Settlement Body unless all of the Members of the Dispute Settlement Body agree not to adopt the report. Thus, the offending country can no longer block the report.
Thus, there are no special arrangements for resolution of intellectual property disputes within the TRIPS Agreement itself. Instead, disputes are to be handled under the general WTO dispute resolution mechanism. This means that after exhaustion of efforts at voluntary settlement, panels are created to hear the parties and make decisions.
Under the old GATT rules, states could block requests for panels and could often dodge a negative decision. Under the WTO rules, creation of a panel can be blocked only once for a short period of time. Once a panel reaches its decision, the result is hard to avoid, again in contrast to the former GATT procedures. Thus, enforcement of WTO rules has teeth. To date, U.S. has been the leading user of the dispute resolution mechanism, obtaining favorable results in the greater number of cases. The U.S. has also lost a few cases.
According to Allen Dixon of London, WTO members have requested consultations under the WTO dispute settlement mechanisms in 13 disputes involving TRIPS. He lists them in chronological order as follows:
1. U.S. v. Japan - Measures Concerning Sound Recordings - Issue: protection as of 1/1/46, not 1/1/71 - Outcome: "mutually agreed solution".
2. U.S. v. Portugal - Patent Protection under the Industrial Property Act - Issue: protection for 20 years not 15 - Outcome: mutually agreed solution.
3. U.S. v. India - Patent Protection for Pharmaceutical and Agricultural Products - Issue: "mailbox" system - Outcome: Panel Appellate Body ruled for U.S. (India was to conform by 4/19/99.)
4. EC v. India - Patent Protection for Pharmaceutical and Agricultural Chemical Products - Issue and Outcome: as in U.S. case.
5. U.S. v. Pakistan - Patent Protection for Pharmaceutical and Agricultural Products - Issue as in India case - Outcome: mutually agreed solution.
6. EC, Japan & U.S. v. Indonesia - Certain Measures Affecting the Automobile Industry - Issue: discrimination against foreign-owned trademarks - Outcome: Panel ruled against U.S.
7. U.S. v. Ireland/EC - Measures Affecting the Grant of Copyright and Neighboring Rights - Issue: deficiencies in copyright laws - Outcome: pending (Ireland rewriting copyright law.).
8. U.S. v. Sweden - Measures Affecting the Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights - Issue: failure to allow searches - Outcome: mutually agreed solution.
9. U.S. v. Denmark - Measures Affecting the Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights - Issue: as in Swedish case - Outcome: in consultation.
10. EC v. Canada - Patent Protection of Pharmaceutical Products - Issue: deficiencies in patent law - Outcome: Panel set up.
11. U.S. v. Greece/EC - Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights for Motion Pictures and TV Programs - Issue: copyright violations - Outcome: in consultation.
12. Canada v. EC - Patent Protection for Pharmaceutical and Agricultural Products - Issue: patent term extension - Outcome: pending.
13. EC v. U.S. - Section 1105 of the U.S. Copyright Act - Issue: free performance in public places - Outcome: in consultation.
From the above dispute-resolution cases, Dixon gleans the following generally positive trends, inter alia:
In light of these disputes and trends, Dixon draws the following preliminary conclusion:
"During its short existence to date, the TRIPs Agreement and the disputes under it have helped both to establish procedures for a wide variety of future cases and to resolve some deeply entrenched problems in a few national enforcement regimes - in many cases through informal consultations." (Allen N. Dixon, "Trips Case Law Developments in the WTO: A Review and Analysis", Fordham University School of Law, 7th Annual Conference on International IP Law & Policy, 4/8-9/99)
There are indications and reports, however, that little or nothing is being done in some countries to become TRIPS-compliant. One confidential report has it, for example, that in a big Latin American country "no pending bill dealing with IP seeks to achieve TRIPS compliance (and) no one is seriously considering legislative adjustments, even though a few officials are aware of non-compliance." Hence, it should come as no surprise that developed countries will very likely challenge developing countries' nonexistent or insufficient implementation of TRIPS. In fact, "U.S. officials have already announced their intention to bring formal complaints to the WTO against countries that fail to meet this deadline (January 1, 2000)." (13 BNA 197, 6/99). And USTR ambassador Charlene Barshefsky was quoted as saying:
"In December 1999, the USTR will conduct a special out-of-cycle review to assess the progress made by developing countries. The United States will announce at the conclusion of this review in early January the actions it will take where WTO members have failed to implement their obligations, including the possible initiation of dispute settlement cases". (6 MIP June 1999)
Given this backdrop, former U.S. Commissioner for Patents and Trademarks Bruce Lehman commented at WIPO's Policy Advisory Commission meeting last April that "WIPO's responsibility (now) is to make TRIPs and its legal and commercial principles relevant and positive for the developing country world." (BNA, id.)
D. Assessments and Implications of TRIPS
An overwhelming amount of literature has been generated in recent years by academics and commentators, interpreting TRIPS and assessing its economic and social implications, in general, and for the developing countries, in particular. Comments range from very positive to quite negative.
On the plus side, according to Bob Sherwood TRIPS is a "blueprint for effective defense of intellectual property rights" (37 IDEA 491, 537 (1997)) and according to former Commissioner of Patents and Trademarks, Gerald Mossinghoff, TRIPS "clearly set the stage for the next steps in effective multinational patent protection." (38 IDEA 529, 539 (1998)). In fact, he predicts that with the "landmark" TRIPS Agreement in place, we will have a World Patent System "sooner rather than later." (38 IDEA 529, 561 (1998)).
Interesting commentaries regarding TRIPS can also be found in an article, authored by Professors Rochelle Cooper Dreyfuss and Andreas Lowenfeld and entitled "Two Achievements of the Uruguay Round: Putting TRIPS and Dispute Settlement Together" (37 VA J. Int'l L 275 (1997)):
"There were two major breakthroughs in the Uruguay Round. The one that seems to have been the most surprising to the participants was agreement on a strict and binding system of dispute settlement and enforcement.
.....
The second significant achievement concerned intellectual property, previously the province of bilateral and multilateral agreements that generally lacked enforcement provisions.
.....
As salutary as these developments are, they raise important questions and 'special difficulties".
These tensions have to do with a perceived disconnect between GATT/WTO (trade law) and TRIPS (IPRs) in terms of obligations, vocabulary, etc. "Success will depend on how well the GATT/WTO system addresses the differences between the intellectual property and trade matters." (Id. at 281)
J.H. Reichman's assessment in his article "Enforcing the Enforcement Procedures of the TRIPS Agreement" (37 VA J Int'l L 335, 339 (1997)), is also interesting:
"Taken together, the enforcement and dispute-settlement provisions of the TRIPS Agreement put teeth into the pre-existing intellectual property conventions, which relegated the issue of effective implementation of agreed minimum standards to a purely theoretical possibility of litigation before the International Court of Justice. In the long term, one may well hope that these provisions will further the goal of adapting the international intellectual property system to the challenges of an integrated world market."
Significant assessments and proposals were advanced by Robert Sherwood in a report commissioned by WIPO in 1995 regarding macro-economic benefits and costs to developing countries in implementing the TRIPS Agreement (See 37 IDEA 491 (1997)).
According to Sherwood "(d)eveloping countries can expect benefits of many kinds as they fully implement the TRIPS Agreement" (Id. at 491). He discusses in great detail the factors that contribute to macro-economic cost/benefit analysis of the implications of TRIPS for developing countries in terms of innovation, price levels, technology acquisitions, human skills, private investment in research, science in agriculture, industrial base, private risk capital and university technology and then concludes
"On balance, it appears that the impact of the TRIPS Agreement on most developing countries is likely to be slightly negative in the short run (one to two years) and increasingly favorable as local firms and individuals begin to realize the potential benefits for their activities. Public education education will play a role in the speed with which the benefits are realized."
And for some in-between commentary: Jayashree Watal in his article "The TRIPS Agreement and Developing Countries - Strong, Weak or Balanced Protection?" (J of World Int. Prop. 281, 282 (1998)) has this to say: The views of some legal experts "...range from interpreting TRIPS as an agreement which ushers in an era of strong intellectual property protection in developing countries to a treaty so full of loopholes as to provide a number of escape hatches to developing countries."
Nonetheless, he concludes that
"As more work is done on the economic implications of TRIPS for developing countries, it may become clear that is is unambiguously in the interests of such countries to interpret TRIPS at the highest levels of protection of IPRs in order to achieve higher levels of domestic innovation, and attract foreign investment or the latest technologies." (Id. at 307)
Incidentally, Watal takes issue with the characterization of TRIPS as setting merely minimum standards by asserting that
"...for developing countries it represents a major change from not only the pre-existing international law on the subject but also from their pre-existing national laws. In this sense, TRIPS represents very high, if not the maximum, standards for intellectual property protection for these countries." (Id. at 282)
While most of the commentaries are optimistic and positive, a few negative and pessimistic voices have also been heard. For example, according to Marci Hamilton TRIPS is "imperialistic, outdated and over-protective", as it "attempts to remake international copyright law in the image of Western copyright law." (29 Vanderbilt J Transnatl L 613-614 (1996)) Also noteworthy in this connection is the "Rapid Patent" proposal, recently floated within AIPPI circles in the belief that developing countries can't possibly live up to TRIPS standards. Under this proposal patent applications
would be filed, published and kept pending for 20 years when they go abandoned, unless patentability examinations had been requested by someone during pendency. (The ultimate deferred examination system.)
E. Conclusion
The real TRIPS will soon emerge, with heightened tensions and increased potential for complaints and disputes very likely. Given this scenario, Reichman's exhortation is quite apropos. Reichman concludes his above-mentioned article "with a plea for patient and cooperative forms of persuasion rather than costly and confrontational forms of international litigation", stressing "three core principles that all those who want the TRIPS Agreement to succeed should bear in mind." They are:
"First, if the developed countries push too hard and too fast, the developing countries and the least-developed countries will find ways to push back....(they) will look to the safeguards embodied in ... the TRIPS Agreement.
.....
The second core principle is that any victorious dispute-settlement proceeding may, at least in the short-and medium-terms, constitute something of a setback to friendly relations between states in the field of intellectual property law.
.....
The third core principle is that compensation has now become the key to the further development of international intellectual property protection in the trade-law environment. It follows that states desiring a higher level of protection or enforcement than that afforded by the existing minimum standards cannot substitute complaints about the domestic legal systems of less protectionist countries for further rounds of negotiated compensatory trade concessions of interest to those countries." (Reichman, supra at 356)
This conclusion by Reichman is a fitting conclusion for any piece on TRIPS implementation.
Karl F. Jorda
David Rines Professor of Intellectual Property Law
Franklin Pierce Law Center, Concord, NH, USA
<< Return to Pierce Law Publications & Papers