Pierce Law Publications & Papers

Intellectual Property Management

by Prof. Karl F. Jorda

IP Lectures
Beijing, August 3-4, 1999

A. Importance of IP to a Company

This is a "golden age" for IP. IP is the life blood of a company. More than ever companies are built around patented technology. "Innovate or perish" is the motto. Patent filings and issuances are skyrocketing, so much so that there is talk of a patent "revolution", "explosion", "frenzy". The courts are pro-IP as is legislation; even the Antitrust Division of the U.S. Justice Department is pro-IP. Courts read the riot act to infringers. Billion dollar damages have been awarded. Treble damages, once rare, are now the order of the day. Injunctions are not stayed during appeals.

"Everything under the sun made by man" is patentable according to our Supreme Court. As of last year, formerly unpatentable business methods and computer programs (algorithms) are now also patentable.

Royalties obtained for licensing IP have reached the billion dollar mark for companies such as IBM, TI. Hence, IP rights are most valuable corporate assets, crown jewels. In this regard, Donald Fites, Chairman and CEO of Caterpillar, made the following illustrative statement:

Achieving Caterpillar's goal of providing quality products and services requires more than superior engineering skills. It also requires the protection provided by patents. Without this protection our competitors would soon duplicate our inventions, and the features that differentiate Caterpillar machines worldwide would no longer be unique. Our return on research and development would quickly be eroded, and our mission of producing above-average returns for our stockholders would become increasingly difficult.

Caterpillar's continued growth and prosperity depend not only on our ability to protect our own inventions, but also on our ability to avoid infringing upon the patent rights of others. With courts regularly awarding damages in the millions of dollars, one case of patent infringement could have a significant impact on our ability to compete effectively in the marketplace. As Caterpillar employees, we all share the responsibility of ensuring that this doesn't happen.

B. Organization of IP Department

There is no ideal IP department structure. Corporate IP Departments, regardless of size, will always differ from one another in certain organization respects, reflecting the unique business structure, tradition and philosophy of the respective corporate entities. However, for the most part there are similarities, based on the nature of the work, the role, the function of the IP department.

First of all, as regards the reporting relationship within the company hierarchy, the IP department, in the vast majority of companies, reports to the General Counsel, parallel to the legal and tax departments or as part of the legal department.

Secondly, there is the question of centralization versus decentralization. Depending on the size and structure of a company and the number and locations of subsidiaries, divisions or other operating units with R&D operations, there may be greater or lesser (de) centralization. Modish trends and the swinging pendulum also play a role. There are pros and cons for both setups. Inasmuch as the amount of service a corporate unit gets from a headquarter department is proportional to the geographic distance, decentralization is preferable. On the other hand, decentralization can lead to isolation of patent attorneys/agents in outlying locations as well as loss of control, communication problems and greater need for resources. Of course, there can be partial decentralization or so-called liaison persons can be employed in outlying R&D units.

Thirdly, anent departmental hierarchy a typical arrangement will comprise a number of patent attorneys/agents reporting to a division counsel or senior attorney, who in turn reports to the chief patent counsel, who invariable is a corporate vice president nowadays in light of the transcending importance of IP to the corporation which puts the IP department center-stage. Thus, an IP department may have sections aligned with operating units, where each attorney/agent handles the entire spectrum of IP work from processing invention disclosures and preparing, filing and prosecuting U.S. and foreign patent applications to getting involved in appeals, interferences, litigation and licensing of cases on his/her docket. In earlier times there was often a functional division of labor, i.e. specialized and separate sections for foreign prosecution, interferences, litigation, licensing. It is more motivational, however, for the members of the IP department to be responsible for all IP matters pertaining to their assigned business unit. The trademark function, however, is usually a separate unit.

IP departments will be guided by operational manuals incorporating corporate IP strategies, policies and procedures and are equipped to perform necessary training of junior people and give orientation lectures to R&D staffs to create and maintain patent consciousness and keep them abreast of changes in patent law and practice.

As it is not possible for an IP department to be expert in all technical fields and all practice areas, e.g. opinion work and litigation, or cope with fluctuating workloads (headcount limitations), external support may have to be enlisted, i.e. work may have to be farmed out to outside law firms. For quality control purposes, assignments handled by in-house attorneys/agents may be reviewed by outside attorneys. Farming out may also provide salutary exposure of in-house people to private practitioners.

Participation in the activities of IP associations is also important for professional development.

C. Role of IP Department and Its Main Work

1. Role within Corporation - Purpose or Mission

a) Patent Support for R& D activities

b) Patent support for marketing activities

c) Trademark support for marketing activities

d) Copyright support for our publications

2. Major Activities

a) Evaluation of inventive ideas re

b) Preparation and filing of patent applications on domestic inventions

c) Prosecution of patent applications of domestic (and foreign origin)

including

d) Appeals and Interferences

e) Infringement and Validity Studies (Due Diligence)

f) Assistance in Patent Licensing and Litigation and Foreign Patent Filing and Prosecution

g) Other Activities:

h) Filing and prosecution of trademark applications, including

i) Copyrights

3. Major Objectives

a) Prioritize and streamline patent and trademark procurement practice by e.g., (1) filing fewer patent applications, especially on marginal inventions and inventions which can be maintained as trade secrets, (2) abandoning more pending cases where interest is sagging and/or the going gets tough, (3) streamlining internal procedures to simplify and improve operations, etc.

b) Prepare, finalize or update, as the case may be, various corporate and departmental policies, procedures, forms and manuals such as Corporate Patent Policy, Trade Secret Policy, Invention Agreement, Operations Manual, Due Diligence Procedure.

c) Formalize and improve the due diligence process, especially as regards assessments of patent infringement and patent validity as well as patent litigation risks and litigation costs.

d) Build in-house patent litigation, patent interference and patent licensing capability and expertise so as to reduce dependence on outside patent counsel.

e) Determine optimal, computer and word-processing systems for the Department and replace present (outdated) systems. See Attachment I for another illustrative corporate IP Management Program.

D. Harvesting Inventions - Discovering Discoveries

E. Ownership of Inventions

1. R& D Funded by a Corporation

General Rule: employee owns invention as ownership follows inventorship.

But if the employee

then the employer owns the invention; hence, the employee must assign the patent rights, if any, to the employer, who will record them in the U.S. Patent & Trademark office.

N.B. even if none of the above conditions apply and the employee owns inventions, without obligation to assign his/her rights to the employer, the employer may have shoprights (implied non-exclusive non-transferable license), if employee used company time, resources, know-how.

2. R&D Funded by the Government

If R&D is carried out by the government in federal laboratories, the government likewise has the rights to any inventions made (U.S. v. Dubilier, US Supreme Court, 1930). But the government licenses the federally owned IP very freely, even on an exclusive basis, under the Stevenson-Wydler Technology Innovation Act of 1980 and the Federal Technology Act of 1986, which were enacted to facilitate technology transfer from federal laboratories. Under the latter act, each federal agency has the authority to permit any of its government-owned, government-operated federal laboratories and its Government-owned, contractor-operated laboratories to (1) enter into cooperative research and development agreements (CRDAs) with third parties and (2) negotiate licensing agreements.

If R&D is carried out in universities, research institutes and (small) business corporations and funded by the government, in whole or in part, these entities can elect to retain title under the Bayh-Dole Act of 1980. However, they are subject to the government's so-called "march-in rights."

March-in rights may be exercised if (1) the agency determines that commercialization of the invention is not being effectively pursued; (2) the license is necessary to satisfy health or safety needs; (3) the patent holder has not met the public use requirements specified by federal regulations; or (4) the patent holder has failed to agree that products incorporating the patented invention will be manufactured substantially within the United States.

F. Corporate Counsel's Role in Litigation

1. Inasmuch as getting a patent and getting an enforceable patent are two different things, corporate counsel must optimize obtaining patents which will be found valid, enforceable and infringed when involved in patent infringement litigation. The following steps, among others, are important to take:

2. It is important for corporate counsel to be directly engaged in the following litigation matters:

(a) Making the initial evaluation of the factors giving rise to the litigation.

(b) Choosing trial counsel for the litigation and setting up the financial arrangements under which trial counsel will be operating.

(c) Working with trial counsel to produce a thorough, going-in evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of the case before the final decision is made on whether to litigation.

(d) Presenting the trial counsel's evaluation of the cases to corporate management so that it is considered in conjunction with the commercial aspects of the matter in deciding whether litigation will be really cost effective.

(e) As the litigation proceeds into and through the discovery phase,

(f) Providing interim reports to corporate management as the case proceeds, particularly as to newly discovered facts which may impact the outcome and thereby make settlement more or less attractive before trial is reached.

(g) Attending the trial and helping trial counsel at trial, particularly in relationships with corporate witnesses, and with any pre-trial or post trial briefs.

(h) In conjunction with trial counsel, analyzing the outcome of the trial, i.e., the judge's decision or jury verdict and its relation to the actual evidence presented, to decide on post trial actions such as motions, and whether to appeal or settle.

(i) Participating in the appellate process particularly by reviewing and making inputs to the appellate brief(s).

(j) Usually handling a lot of other miscellaneous tasks throughout the litigation whenever an interface between trial counsel and the corporation is involved.

3. As patent infringement litigation can be horrendously expensive, it is particularly essential for corporate counsel to minimize costs. In-house counsel must exercise control over the handling of the litigation by trial counsel by getting personally involved in

Karl F. Jorda
David Rines Professor of Intellectual Property Law
Franklin Pierce Law Center, Concord, NH, USA

<< Return to Pierce Law Publications & Papers