![]() |
|
By Karl F. Jorda
May 10, 1996
Short Hills, NJ - Jefferson Medal Dinner
Mr. President, Distinguished Guests, Ladies and Gentlemen!
Good evening to one and all!
And a very good evening it is, indeed. This Medal would put anybody on "Cloud 9!" I wish I could say it's a dream come true. I have known of the Jefferson Medal for over 30 years and attended a Jefferson Medal Dinner a few years ago, but I would never have dared aspire to it. Now I am a proud recipient of it. What an unexpected surprise it was! How sweet it is!
I am very happy and proud to join the ranks of illustrious prior recipients. As you heard two of them are present here tonight, and I appreciate this greatly. It's very humbling for me to go down the list of prior medalists.
It goes without saying that I owe a great debt of gratitude, first and foremost, to the New Jersey Intellectual Property Law Association for bestowing this great honor on me. Your association is clearly one of the most active and prestigious regional intellectual property law associations in this country and one that is unceasingly dedicated to the improvement of law in the intellectual property field.
In accepting the Jefferson Medal, I hasten to add that I cannot help but accept it on behalf of Franklin Pierce Law Center in the hope that it will bring credit and recognition to Franklin Pierce. But for my affiliation with Franklin Pierce over the last seven glorious years, I am not at all sure, I'd be standing before you tonight. Franklin Pierce makes it possible for me to "labor in the vineyards" of intellectual property rights, not only as a great operational base but, more importantly, also in terms of heartening encouragement, support and approval.
I'm so happy Bob Viles, our President, Dean and "fearless leader," is with us tonight and I can publicly thank him for the opportunities Franklin Pierce has presented to me. Bob believes in letting faculty make their own jobs and do that which they do best. That is leadership par excellence! No wonder he's been a law school dean for 20 years, when the average tenure for a law school dean is a short 3 years.
Happily, at CIBA-GEIGY I had also found a similar propitious climate.
In expressing my gratitude to Franklin Pierce, let me briefly mention that I call it "The Little School That Could." Why? Because it's no small feat for
to have become such a powerhouse in intellectual property education and training as to be ranked consistently among the top five law schools specializing in intellectual property.
Last, but not least, I would like to take just a moment to profusely thank my own family, my bride of 40 years and our four children, for their magnanimous understanding, support and forbearance over all the many years of my professional life. Thanks a million, Alice, Mary, Helen, Bernard and Karl, Jr. Of course it helps if your better half nudges you out the door at the crack of dawn with instructions to go out and "slay the dragon" and "bring home the bacon" -- and tons of it.
George (Hoare) mentioned my international activities and travels, and indeed it has been very challenging and gratifying to "spread the gospel" of intellectual property rights in developing countries and most recently on five trips to all of the Central American countries. I encounter a good deal of skepticism but also much receptivity with my stump speech which I usually deliver in Spanish and in which I espouse certain credos and truisms about the nature and importance of intellectual property systems. Let me mention just a few which I discuss in my talks in greater detail to help clear up misconceptions about intellectual property.
Et cetera, et cetera.
However, let me tell you that our first-to-invent patent system would be a tough sell abroad, so I don't even try.
Now, if I may take another few minutes, with your gracious permission, I would like to go on record and suggest that we consider adopting three modifications to further improve our venerable patent system that has served the country so very well over the past 200+ years.
We saw some radical changes in intellectual property law and practice recently, based on GATT-TRIPS-induced legislation. But some of these I feel will lead to greater complexity and cause more problems than they solve. One has to do with the term or life of a patent; another, with our newly-globalized interference practice. I'll be brief and try not to be too technical.
Why not cut the Gordian knot and legislate a 25-year patent term across the board?
In the good old days a patent expired 17 years after its issuance -- no ifs, ands or buts. Nowadays, patent expiration dates are "all over the countryside". The new patent term is 20 years from the filing date and the greater of 17 years from grant or 20 years from filing for all patents issued or to issue on an application filed before June 8, 1995. And it is 21 years when a provisional application is filed first. But if it's a pharmaceutical case and there was a regulatory pre-market approval delay, or if there were unusual delays in soliciting a patent, it is possible to obtain an extension of up to five years. Very confusing!
Controversial bills are now pending in Congress, which, if passed, would make matters worse, in my view, as they provide for
However, going to 25 years would solve all that and simplify our system. And doing this across the board in all cases, whatever the technology, would be justified also because lead times for commercializing inventions have become longer in all industries and not just in the pharmaceutical field (e.g. in electronics and aerospace, it's 5-15 years; in the machine tools and automotive industries, 10-20 years; and in the field of energy, 15-20, as per Ronald Barks).
Interestingly, the copyright-based industries and the copyright bars in Europe and in this country have no problem establishing now a copyright term measured by the author's life plus 70, that is, lengthening it by 20 years.
As regards simplifying interference practice, there is a way to keep our first-to-invent system and our interference system, while embracing the first-to-file scheme. An interference, of course, is a rather arcane and complex proceeding in the Patent & Trademark Office (PTO) to determine who among two or more independent rival inventors made the invention first and is entitled to the patent, inasmuch as only one patent can issue on any given invention.
The recent change in our Patent code that admits evidence of inventive activity from NAFTA and WTO countries and thus globalizes interference practice, may turn out to be unworkable. Yet, there is an ideal compromise or solution, one which former Commissioner of Patents and Trademarks Gerald J. Mossinghoff proposed at an ABA-IP Section Meeting in San Francisco on July 7, 1982. Unfortunately, it fell into oblivion. Under our proposal, Mossinghoff said,
"We would retain the present first-to-invent system of priority. But we would change the procedure so that a patent will be issued to the first person to file an application, and it would be up to the second person filing an application on the same invention to trigger an interference with the patentee."
In fact, in 1980, when I still was at CIBA-GEIGY Corporation and interferences were "coming out of our ears" (we had 45 at the time), I drew a similar conclusion in an Annual Interference Report to Management:
"There ought to be a better way to handle interferences and yet reconcile the conflicting policy considerations that have surfaced whenever elimination of interferences is suggested. Our first-to-invent system has degenerated into a monstrous atavistic interference practice. The resolution, the reconciliation: no interferences between pending applications; the PTO invariably issues the senior party's patent even if the filing date difference is but a day; the junior party then has to provoke the interference if it can."
Actually such a modification would not be very radical because the PTO already does not declare interferences between pending applications when the filing dates are more than three (or six) months apart in the case of simple (or complex) inventions but rather issues the earlier-filed application. However, such a change would have approximated closely a first-to-file system by eliminating interferences between pending applications and thus further reducing the number of interferences. This would also have simplified and improved our patent system, while retaining the first-to-invent design with its fairness principle. We could have had the best of both worlds! What a missed opportunity! Hopefully, the PTO's Senior Administrative Patent Judge Fred McKelvey, who is now trying to resuscitate the Mossinghoff proposal, will have better luck.
One final suggestion and that has to do with whether something should be done to provide protection in the "twilight zone of subpatentable inventions".
Should we not also have, as do most industrialized nations -- in some for over 100 years -- a petty patent or a utility model or a short-term patent, as it is called in Ireland, which established such a system recently, with the European Union to follow shortly? The norm is becoming a ten-year term with a six-month pendency and a superficial examination. Unobviousness would not be required; a lower level of invention ("not clearly obvious") would suffice. Such second-tier protection may be desirable, given the strict patentability requirements, the long pendency and the high cost of conventional patents. In other words, petty or short-term patent protection would provide coverage for a large area of innovations which fall between design and utility patents, cannot be protected by trade secrets and for which present utility patents are out of reach because of high patentability standards and/or excessive costs.
I am not in favor of change for the sake of change but I agree with former Secretary of State Bob McNamara's statement that "you don't improve things, unless you change things" as well as with Commissioner Bruce Lehman's admonition that we can't have a "frozen-in-time, one size-fits-all patent system."
Let me conclude by congratulating all of you for having the good fortune to live in the Golden Age for intellectual property. Jefferson would be very happy and proud if he could see now what his system has accomplished inasmuch as he believed already in his day that "the issue of patents for new discoveries has given a spring to invention beyond (his) conception." In closing, let me also commend the New Jersey Intellectual Property Law Association and its leadership on the great job you are doing in the "vineyards of intellectual property rights" and let me express again a million thanks to you for the coveted Jefferson Medal.
My chosen profession and my adoptive country have been very, very good to me and I hope that my deeds and efforts will pay back at least a small share of the great debt of gratitude which I owe them.
Thank you very much!
Karl F. Jorda
David Rines Professor of Intellectual Property Law Franklin Pierce Law Center
Concord, N.H.
5.10.96