Copyright Royalty Tribunal

NOTICES
 
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
 
[CRT Docket No. 91-1-89SCD]
 
1989 Satellite Carrier Royalty Distribution Proceeding
 
Friday, May 3, 1991
 
AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.

 ACTION: Notice of declaratory ruling.

 SUMMARY: The Program Suppliers requested the Tribunal to declare whether copyright owners of network programs are entitled to share in the satellite carrier copyright royalty fund. The Tribunal has determined that network program owners are entitled to share in the satellite carrier royalty fund, based on the unambiguous reading of section 119 of the Copyright Act.

 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Robert Cassler, General Counsel, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1825 Connecticut Avenue NW., suite 918, Washigton, DC 20009 (202-673-5400).

 SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: On December 28, 1990, the Program Suppliers, a group of approximately 100 producers and/or syndicators of televisions series, specials and movies, filed a motion with the Tribunal seeking a ruling that copyright owners of network programs are not entitled to share in the satellite carrier royalty fees.

 The Tribunal published notice of Program Suppliers' motion in the Federal Register and requested comments by February 25 and reply comments by March 11.56 FR 2757 (January 24, 1991).

 The Tribunal received direct comments from ABC, CBS and NBC (the Networks), the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP), Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI), Major League Baseball (MLB), the National Basketball Association (NBA), the National Hockey League (NHL), the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), the Public Broadcasting Service (PBS), SESAC, Inc. (SESAC) and the U.S. Commercial Television Broadcast Claimant Group (Broadcast Claimants).

 The Tribunal received reply comments from ASCAP, BMI, the Broadcast Claimants, the Networks, and the Program Suppliers.

 Background

  In 1988, Congress created a new compulsory copyright license, the *20415 satellite carrier license, which permitted satellite carriers to retransmit broadcast signals to home satellite dish owners, so long as the carriers paid a royalty to the Copyright Office for eventual distribution to the proper copyright owners by the Copyright Royalty Tribunal. The royalty rate set by Congress in section 119 of the Copyright Act was 12 cents per signal per subscriber per month for superstations (independent stations) and 3 cents per signal per subscriber per month for network stations.

 Section 119 went into effect in 1989, and copyright owners filed their first claims in July 1990. Program Suppliers asked the Tribunal to declare whether copyright owners of network programs are entitled to share in the satellite carrier royalty fund as a threshold question before distributing the first fund collected under section 119.

 Much of section 119 is modeled directly on section 111, the section establishing the cable compulsory license. However, section 111(d)(3) states that cable royalties shall be distributed to those copyright owners who own works "included in a secondary transmission made by a cable system of a nonnetwork television program", while section 119(b)(3) states that satellite carrier royalties shall be distributed "to those copyright owners whose works were included in a secondary transmission for private home viewing made by a satellite carrier." No exclusion of net work programs is mentioned in section 119(b)(3).

 Program Suppliers' Argument

  The Program Suppliers believe that the network program owners are not entitled to share in the satellite royalty fund. The Program Suppliers are supported in their contention by ASCAP, BMI, the Broadcast Claimants, and SESAC.

 The Program Suppliers argue that section 119 is ambiguous, because there exists, according to the Program Suppliers, a conflict between the language of section 119(b)(3) which does not exclude network programs owners from receiving royalties, and section 119(b)(1) which establishes the royalty rate.

 As mentioned above, the royalty rate is 12 cents for superstations (independent stations) and 3 cents for network stations. The Program Suppliers argue that this four-to-one ratio is modeled directly after section 111 which states that independent stations are paid for on the basis of one distant signal, while network stations are paid for on the basis of one-quarter distant signal.

 The reason for this four-to-one ratio, according to the Program Suppliers, is that Congress did not intend to compensate network programs in cable nor in satellite carrier, because copyright owners of network programs are already compensated for nationwide coverage by the networks.

 The Program Suppliers find support for this in two statements in the House Energy and Commerce Committee's Report on the Satellite Home Viewer Act of 1988. First, the Committee stated that the setting of the rate for network stations at one-fourth the rate for superstations was because, " 'the viewing of non-network programs on network stations is considered to approximate 25 percent.' " H.R. Rep. No. 887 (II), 100th Cong. 2d Sess. 22-23. Second, the Committee went on to say,

 The copyright owners of * * * non-network programs would be entitled to receive compensation * * * . Owners of copyright in network programs would not be entitled to compensation for such retransmissions, since those coyright owners are compensated for national distribution by the networks when the programming is acquired. Id.

 The Broadcast Claimants in their comments states that the networks had disavowed any interest in additional compensation for reaching unserved areas of the nation in testimony before the House Judiciary Committee.

 ASCAP states that a finding that network program owners are entitled to participate would lead to an illogical conclusion-that a one-hour program on a network station would be compensated at one-fourth the rate as the same one-hour program on a superstation.

 Network Copyright Owners' Argument

  The Networks, (ABC, CBS and NBC) and Major League Baseball (supported by the NBA, NCAA, and NHL) identified themselves as copyright owners of network programs, and argued that the Tribunal should declare that they are entitled to share in satellite carrier royalties.

 The Networks and Major League Baseball argue first that section 119(b)(3) is unambiguous, and therefore, no resort to legislative history is justified.

 The Networks further argue that the very reason the Satellite Home Viewer Act was passed was in response to a court decision that a satellite carrier was not eligible under section 111 for a compulsory license to retransmit a network broadcast signal, a suit in which NBC was a plaintiff. BMI's reply to this argument is that Congress responded to this case in ways other than giving remuneration to the networks, namely, restricting retransmissions to areas unserved by the networks and instructing the FCC to investigate the possibility of syndicated exclusivity protection.

 The Networks next argue that copyright owners of network programs are not already fully compensated, because satellite carrier transmissions are intended only for "white areas," those area that cannot receive a network signal by ordinary antenna. The homes receiving such transmissions have been, up to now, outside of the nationwide coverage for which the copyright owner was compensated.

 The Networks and Major League Baseball disagree with the Program Suppliers that the disparity in the rates between superstations and network stations was intended to exclude network copyright owners from sharing in the fund. It was intended, they argue, to maintain comparability between the level of payments satellite carriers pay with the level of payments cable systems pay. Whether this would lead to illogical distributions is possible, but not relevant, because that's a decision Congress made. In the cable license, there exists other disparities, because the pay-in does not correlate by statute to the pay-out.

 The Networks point to specific language in the House Judiciary Committee report that in their view recognizes their entitlement, "the [Satellite Home Viewer Act] takes affirmative steps to treat similarly the measure of copyright protection accorded to television programming distributed by national television networks and nonnetwork programming distributed by independent television stations." H.R. Rep. No. 887 (I), 14-15.

 Finally, the Networks deny that they disavowed their interest in compensation before Congress, having limited their remarks to free marketplace arrangements only, and not to a statutory license that Congress might pass.

 Major League Baseball argues that resort to the legislative history is improper, but if the Tribunal does look at the legislative history, the Tribunal should follow the language of the House Judiciary Committee's Report which has jurisdiction over copyright, and not the House Energy and Commerce Committee's Report. The Judiciary Committee's Report, MLB points out, states that those entitled to share in the satellite carrier fund are those copyright owners identified in section 119(b)(3).

 *20416 Discussion

  Section 119 instructs the Tribunal to distribute satellite carrier royalties to those copyright owners whose works were retransmitted by satellite carriers to home dish owners. It is Tribunal's belief that section 119 is clear and unambiguous. Supporting this view is that section 111, by contrast, very clearly instructs the Tribunal to distribute cable royalties to copyright owners of nonnetwork programs only. As Major League Baseball has noted, the Supreme Court has held that " 'where Congress includes particular language in one section of a statute but omits it in another section of the same Act, it is generally presumed that Congress acts intentionally and purposely in the disparate inclusion or exclusion.' " Russello v. United States, 464 U.S. 16, 23 (1983) (quoting United States v. Wong Kim Bo, 472 F. 2d 720, 722 (5th Cir. 1972).

 The Program Suppliers have argued that an ambiguity is created by the language in section 119(b)(1) establishing the different rates for superstations and network stations. But the language of 119(b)(1) is not in and of itself conflicting with 119(b)(3), and the Tribunal believes that sections of a statute should be read as harmonious whenever such a reading is justified. As the Networks and Major League Baseball have pointed out, the disparity in rates can be attributed to the desire of Congress to establish the same payment level for satellite carrier as for cable, thereby avoiding unfair interindustry competition. Similarly, the policy underlying the disparity in rates for cable, that network programs have already been compensated for nationwide coverage, does not apply for satellite carriers, because they are retransmitting network signals to "white areas" only.

 Having concluded that no ambiguity appears in the statute, should the Tribunal nonetheless take notice of the plain and clear language of the House Energy and Commerce Committee Report which states that network program owners shall not be eligible for satellite carrier royalty fees

 The Supreme Court recently held, "The best evidence of [the] purpose is the statutory text adopted by both Houses of Congress and submitted to the President. Where that contains a phrase that is unambiguous--that has a clearly accepted meaning in both legislative and judicial practice--we do not permit it to be expanded or contracted by the statements of individual legislators or committees during the course of the enactment process." West Virginia University Hospitals, Inc. v. Casey, No. 89-994, Slip op. at 15 (decided March 19, 1991).

 Similarly, as cited by Major League Baseball, the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled, "[E]ven if the pertinent passage from the House Report is seen as speaking with complete clarity, the fact remains that committee reports are now law." American Civil Liberties Union v. FCC, 823 F. 2d 1554 (DC Cir. 1987). Accordingly, the Tribunal interprets Section 119 as clear on its face, and declares that copyright owners of network programs are entitled to participate and prove their entitlement in the distribution of the satellite carrier royalty fund.

 Dated: April 30, 1991.

 Mario F. Aguero,

 Chairman.

 [FR Doc. 91-10534 Filed 5-2-91; 8:45 am]


Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.