NOTICES
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
[CRT Docket No. 89-5-CRA]
Adjustment of the Syndicated Exclusivity Surcharge
Wednesday, January 10, 1990
AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.
ACTION: Notice of commencement of proceedings.
SUMMARY: The Tribunal has received petitions from the Community Antenna Television Association and the National Cable Television Association requesting the Tribunal to eliminate the syndicated exclusivity surcharge on the cable royalty rates paid by cable systems. The Tribunal finds that petitioners have a significant interest in the royalty rates and gives notice of commencement of proceedings on the question of the syndicated exclusivity surcharge only, and not on any other issues raised by the petitions. The Tribunal requests comments on whether this proceeding should be decided by written pleadings, or whether any material questions of fact exist that would necessitate an oral hearing. Further, the Tribunal requests all those who intend to participate in this hearing, but who do not file the above requested comments, to file a Notice of Intent to Participate.
DATES: Comments concerning written or oral proceeding are due February 8, 1990. Notices of Intent to Participate are due February 8, 1990. Those who file comments do not have to file a Notice of Intent to Participate.
ADDRESS: An original and five copies of the comments should be addressed to: *894 Chairman, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1111 20th Street NW., Suite 450, Washington, DC 20036.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Robert Cassler, General Counsel, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1111 20th Street NW., Suite 450, Washington, DC 20036 (202) 653-5175.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
On May 26, 1989, the Community Antenna Television Association (CATA), a trade association which represents cable television owners and operators in the United States, filed a petition with the Copyright Royalty Tribunal to eliminate the syndicated exclusivity surcharge which some cable operators pay in addition to their basic royalty rate.
The reason given by CATA was that since the Tribunal instituted the syndicated exclusivity surcharge to adjust for the loss of blackout protection for copyright owners that occurred when the FCC deleted its syndicated program exclusivity protection rules, there is no longer any need for the surcharge now that the FCC has reinstituted those rules.
On June 15, 1989, the National Cable Television Association, Inc. (NCTA), a trade association which represents cable television owners and operators in the United States, filed a similar petition with the Tribunal. However, in addition to requesting the elimination of the syndicated exclusivity surcharge, NCTA also requested that there be a downward adjustment of the basic rate paid by cable systems grossing more than $292,000 per half year and of the 3.75 percent rate for reasons also stemming from the FCC's action in reinstating its syndicated program exclusivity protection rules.
NCTA also asked the Tribunal to establish a bifurcated proceeding. The first part of the proceeding would be a consideration only of the elimination of the syndicated exclusivity surcharge. The second part of the proceeding would be the consideration of the reduction of the basic and 3.75 percent rates. NCTA reasoned that bifurcating the proceeding would allow for an earlier disposition on the question of the syndicated exclusivity surcharge before undertaking the potentially more complex task of quantifying the impact of the new FCC rules on the 3.75 percent rate and the basic rates.
On September 15, 1989, the Tribunal, after having read and considered the comments filed August 1 and September 6 on CATA's and NCTA's petitions, determined that the best disposition of the issues raised by the petitions precluded an immediate consideration of the petitions, and requested that CATA and NCTA refile their motions after January 1, 1990. 54 FR 38266.
On November 17, 1989, the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the FCC's new rules. United Video, Inc. v. Federal Communications Commission, No. 88- 1514 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 17, 1989).
On January 2, 1990, CATA and NCTA refiled their petitions with the Tribunal, asking for the same relief that they asked for in their original petitions.
Discussion
The Tribunal has determined from the petitions, the comments filed August 1, 1989 and September 6, 1989, and from the record established by previous proceedings, that CATA and NCTA have a significant interest in the cable copyright royalty rates, and accordingly have standing to petition the Tribunal for a rate adjustment.
The concern of the Tribunal is for the proper scheduling and disposition of these petitions. Facing the Tribunal during 1990 are several potential adjustments to the cable rates. First, there are the adjustments which CATA and NCTA argue are justified because of the FCC's rule changes. Second, there is the inflation adjustment to the statutory rates for which the Tribunal may be petitioned. Third, there is the general review of the 3.75 percent rate for which the Tribunal may also be petitioned.
Concerns for scheduling compel the Tribunal to agree with NCTA that a step-by-step approach to all these issues is the best way to proceed. To consider all of these adjustments as one cable adjustment in one proceeding would be too unwieldy and unfair to the parties, and might force scheduling due to the one-year statutory limit on Tribunal proceedings which would be contrary to the ends of justice.
In 1985, the Tribunal bifurcated the cable rate adjustments. During the spring of 1985, the Tribunal was petitioned to adjust the statutory rates for inflation, and that rulemaking proceeding was concluded in time for the first semiannual payments to be made by cable operators for 1985. Expressly reserved for another proceeding was any general review of the syndicated exclusivity surcharge and the 3.75 percent rate. One petition by Turner Broadcasting System was filed during the summer of 1985, and general rate review petitions were filed by several more parties in December, 1985. All of these petitions were subsequently withdrawn in 1986.
Accordingly, the Tribunal has determined to commence a rate adjustment proceeding on the sole question of whether the syndicated exclusivity surcharge should be eliminated in light of the actions taken by the FCC to reinstate its syndicated program exclusivity protection rules. Expressly reserved for another separately docketed proceeding is whether any adjustment to the basic statutory rates and the 3.75 percent rate should be made in light of the FCC's actions.
CATA and NCTA both argue that the syndicated exclusivity surcharge should be eliminated as a matter of law and policy--that the reason supporting the imposition of the syndicated exclusivity surcharge, the FCC's action in 1980, no longer exists due to the reversal by the FCC of that action in 1988.
Consequently, the initial question facing the Tribunal is whether this proceeding should be a "paper" proceeding, or whether any material questions of fact exist which would necessitate an oral hearing. The Tribunal is aware that section 804 proceedings do not have to be oral proceedings. In the past the Tribunal has adjusted royalty rates by informal rulemaking, such as the 1985 cable rate inflation adjustment and the 1987 mechanical royalty rate adjustment, and the Tribunal has distributed royalties based solely on written pleadings, such as the 1981 jukebox royalty distribution.
The Tribunal requests comments on the question of whether this proceeding should be decided by written pleadings, or whether any material questions of fact exist which would necessitate an oral hearing. Comments are due February 8, 1990. The Tribunal is also interested is ascertaining all parties who are interested in participating in this proceeding. For those who file comments by February 8, 1990 on the above question, no further action will be necessary. The Tribunal will consider these comments as the party's expression of intent to participate. However, for those who do not comment, but wish to participate, the Tribunal requests those parties to file a Notice of Intent to Participate by February 8, 1990.
Dated: January 4, 1990.
J.C. Argetsinger,
Chairman.
[FR Doc. 90-492 Filed 1-9-90; 8:45 am]
Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.