Copyright Royalty Tribunal

NOTICES
 
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
 
[Docket No. 89-2-87CD]
 
1987 Cable Royalty Distribution Proceeding
 
Monday, April 24, 1989
 
*16386 AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.

 ACTION: Notice of Phase I settlement; notice of partial distribution.

 SUMMARY: The Tribunal announces that the Phase I claimants to the 1987 cable royalty distribution proceeding have reached a settlement, and that a partial distribution of the 1987 cable copyright royalty fund can be made.

 DATES: The distribution of cable copyright royalties will take place on April 27, 1989.

 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:Robert Cassler, General Counsel, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1111 20th Street NW., Suite 450, Washington, DC, (202) 653- 5175.

 SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: On March 30, 1989, the Tribunal published in the Federal Register a notice *16387 declaring that controversies existed in both Phase I and Phase II of the 1987 cable royalty distribution proceeding, effective April 3, 1989. 54 FR 13101. In the same notice, the Tribunal asked the parties for comments on how much of the 1987 cable royalty fund could be distributed. The comments were due April 14, 1989.

 On April 14, 1989, the Tribunal received notice from the Phase I claimants that all Phase I controversies had been resolved, and that the parties had agreed to a Phase I allocation of cable royalties on the same basis as the allocations made for the 1983-1986 funds. The Tribunal adopts the settlement of the Phase I claimants and declares that Phase I of the 1987 cable royalty distribution proceeding is concluded. The procedural dates for Phase II will be set by the Tribunal in an order to be issued to the Phase II parties at a later date.

 Concerning a distribution of the 1987 fund, since there was a full agreement regarding Phase I, the only remaining question is how much should be retained by the Tribunal to satisfy any Phase II controversies. The Phase II claimants in the Noncommercial Television and the Music categories state that although there may be Phase II hearings necessary to resolve their controversies, full distributions can be made in those categories, with all the parties within those categories stating their willingness to reimburse each other as may be required. In the Program Suppliers category, MPAA, NAB and Multimedia suggested a total distribution based upon the same mechanism as last year's. Accordingly, the Tribunal will make the Phase II Program Supplier distribution based upon the 1983 percentages. All three parties have represented that they will undertake any reimbursement that may be necessary to reflect the ultimate award.

 Accordingly, the Tribunal will make 100% distributions according to the recommendations of these parties in the Noncommercial Television, Music and Program Suppliers categories as well as all other categories which have no Phase II controversies.

 Concerning the Devotional Claimants category, however, there was disagreement among the commenters. Those Devotional Claimants that had received in prior years some portion of the Devotional Claimants' allocation--the Christian Broadcasting Network, Inc., Old Time Gospel Hour, The Inspirational Network, NAB, and Multimedia--recommended that there be a 100% distribution of Devotional Claimants' royalties to an escrow fund, or if the Tribunal felt there should be some withholding to account for the new claimants, it should be no more than 5%. The new claimants wanted the Tribunal to withhold more. In Touch Ministries, Oral Roberts Evangelistic Association and First Century Broadcast, Inc. requested that the Tribunal withhold 25%, and Christian Television Network requested that the Tribunal withhold 45%.

 In a situation where there are new claimants for whom the Tribunal has no prior experience, determining how much to distribute can be problematic. On the one hand, the Tribunal needs to retain sufficient funds to satisfy all controversies. On the other hand, the Tribunal has a mandate to make as rapid a distribution of the funds as feasible, and the Tribunal has stated several times in the past that the mere assertion of a percentage claim by a claimant does not define the extent of the controversy. Otherwise, a claimant could frustrate a valid distribution by merely interposing a large percentage.

 The Tribunal has determined in this case that it will distribute 80% of the Devotional Claimants royalties to those claimants who have previously shown entitlement, while retaining 20% to satisfy the claims of the new claimants. It is emphasized that this decision is not in any sense a determination by the Tribunal of the ultimate award the Tribunal expects to make in the Devotional Claimants category. Further, should the final awards to the new claimants exceed 20%, reimbursement from the other Devotional Claimants shall be the amount owed plus the interest that would have accrued had the royalties remained with the Copyright Office.

 Accordingly, an 80% distribution of the Devotional Claimants category, and a 100% distribution of all other Phase I categories is ordered for April 27, 1989.

 J. C. Argetsinger,

 Acting Chairman.

  Dated: April 18, 1989.

 [FR Doc. 89-9723 Filed 4-21-89; 8:45 am]


Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.