NOTICES
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
[CRT Docket No. 87-1-85JD]
Final Determination of the Distribution of the 1985 Jukebox Royalty Fund
Friday, December 4, 1987
*46324 AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.
ACTION: Notice of final determination.
SUMMARY: The Tribunal announces the adoption of its final determination in the proceeding concerning the distribution to certain copyright owners and performing rights societies of jukebox royalty fees deposited for 1985 performances.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Robert Cassler, General Counsel, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1111 20th Street, NW., Suite 450, Washington, DC 20036.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Authority
17 U.S.C. 116(c)(3) authorizes the Copyright Royalty Tribunal (Tribunal) to distribute annually royalty fees paid by jukebox operators to certain copyright owners and performing rights societies. First, the Tribunal is to assess the claims of, and make appropriate awards to, "every copyright owner not affiliated with a performing rights society." 17 U.S.C. 116(c)(4)(A). Second, the remainder is to be distributed to "the performing rights societies * * * as they shall by agreement stipulate among themselves, or if they fail to agree, the pro rata share to which such performing rights societies prove entitlement." 17 U.S.C. 116(c)(4)(B).
The Claimants and the Controversy
In this proceeding, the Tribunal takes up the distribution of the royalty fees deposited by jukebox operators for the calendar year 1985.
Five parties filed claims in the 1985 proceeding: the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP), Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI), SESAC, Inc. (SESAC), Asociacion de Compositores y Editores de Musica Latinoamericana (ACEMLA), and Italian Book Corporation (IBC).
ASCAP, BMI and SESAC (hereinafter A/B/S) reached an agreement for division of the jukebox royalties among themselves, and decided to prosecute their claims jointly. Justification of Claim, filed November 3, 1986. ACEMLA and IBC (hereinafter ACEMLA/IBC) reached an agreement for division of the jukebox royalties among themselves, and decided to prosecute their claims jointly. Joint Justification Statement of ACEMLA and IBC, dated November 3, 1986.
In their statements of justification of claim, A/B/S jointly claimed 100% of the fund, and ACEMLA/IBC jointly claimed 12% of the fund. Id. In its final pleading in this proceeding, A/B/S claimed that ACEMLA/IBC was entitled to no more than 0.01807% of the fund, and that A/B/S was entitled to the rest, 99.98193%. A/B/S Reply Findings, par. 33. In its final pleading in this proceeding, ACEMLA/IBC claimed 10 to 13% of the fund. ACEMLA/IBC Reply Findings, p. 17.
Procedural Requirements of This Proceeding
As stated above, section 116 of the Copyright Act requires the Tribunal to take up the claims of copyright owners first, and the claims of the performing rights societies second. ASCAP, BMI and SESAC have been defined by Congress as performing rights societies, so no further inquiry into their status is required. 17 U.S.C. 116(e)(3). ACEMLA and IBC were found by the Tribunal in the consolidated 1982/1983 jukebox distribution proceeding not to be performing rights societies. 50 FR 47577 (November 19, 1985), aff'd, ACEMLA v. Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 809 F. 2d 926 (D.C. Cir. 1987). [FN1] ACEMLA relitigated the question in the 1984 proceeding and was found once again not to be a performing rights society for 1984. 51 FR 43455 (December 2, 1986). In this proceeding, ACEMLA and IBC have relitigated their status, claiming that they are performing rights societies, not copyright owners.
FN1 The finding that IBC was not a performing rights society was based upon a stipulation of all parties, not on a full litigation of the facts. See discussion below in the first Conclusions of Law section.
The effect of whether ACEMLA and/or IBC are performing rights societies is procedural. If they are copyright owners, they have the burden of going forward with their evidence as to their entitlement alone. If they are performing rights societies, they and ASCAP, BMI and SESAC must each go forward to prove their entitlements, so long as no settlement among all the performing rights societies exists.
Previous findings by the Tribunal that ACEMLA and IBC were not performing rights societies do not collaterally stop ACEMLA and IBC from relitigating their status in subsequent proceedings, because it is possible that in any calendar year, ACEMLA and/or IBC may become performing rights societies.
Hence, in this proceeding, it was necessary to take evidence as to the status of ACEMLA and IBC, as well as the entitlements to the jukebox funds of the five claimants.
Background and Chronology
On December 9, 1986, the Tribunal published a notice declaring that a controversy existed concerning the distribution of the 1985 jukebox royalty fund, effective December 10, 1986. In the same notice, the Tribunal ordered a partial distribution to ASCAP, BMI and SESAC of 95% of the 1985 jukebox royalty fund upon the condition that in the event the Tribunal determined that ACEMLA/IBC's entitlement exceeded 5%, A/B/S would reimburse ACEMLA/IBC the excess amount plus interest. 51 FR 44331.
By Order, dated January 16, 1987, the Tribunal announced that it would conduct the hearing of the 1985 jukebox distribution proceeding in two phases and directed the parties to file their written direct cases in two segments as follows: the first segment to include, for ACEMLA and IBC, proof of their status under section 116 of the Copyright Act, whether "copyright owner" or "performing rights society," and the second segment to include, for all parties, proofs of their respective entitlement.
The written direct cases were filed April 16, 1987. The Tribunal conducted six days of evidentiary hearings. A/B/S presented its direct case on May 11, 1987. On May 18, 1987, ACEMLA presented its evidence on the issue of the performing rights society status of ACEMLA. On May 19, 1987, IBC presented its evidence on its status, then secondly, its evidence on its entitlement. ACEMLA then presented its evidence on entitlement.
On June 5, 1987, the parties filed their written rebuttal cases. On June 22, 1987, ACEMLA/IBC presented its rebuttal case. Additional direct case testimony from A/B/S was heard that day in response to a request from the Tribunal for additional evidence.
On June 23 and 24, 1987, A/B/S presented its rebuttal case. With the permission of the Tribunal, ACEMLA/IBC was granted leave to file surrebuttal, which was filed June 30, 1987.
By Order, dated July 2, 1987, the record of the proceeding was closed. The parties filed their Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law on July 16, 1987. Reply Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were filed on July 24, 1987.
Findings of Fact
Status of ACEMLA
Previous Findings. The Tribunal took evidence regarding the status, organization and practices of ACEMLA *46325 in the 1982/1983 consolidated proceeding and in the 1984 proceeding. All of the facts of the 1982/1983 jukebox distribution proceeding and the 1984 jukebox distribution proceeding are hereby incorporated by reference into the 1985 jukebox distribution proceeding final determination. 50 FR 47577; 51 FR 43455.
Current Findings--1985 Proceeding. In its relitigation of the Tribunal's determination that ACEMLA was not a performing rights society, ACEMLA attempted in the 1985 proceeding to bolster its previous showings in the following areas:
Agreement with copyright owners and/or performing rights societies. L. Raul Bernard (Bernard), president of ACEMLA, stated that in November, 1986, ACEMLA entered into an agreement with the Sociedad Puertoriquena de Autores, Compositores y Editores de Musica, Inc. (SPACEM), an association of composers in Puerto Rico, to collect and distribute performing rights royalties, retroactive to April 1, 1985. ACEMLA Ex. 1, p. 1; ACEMLA Ex. 25, Att. A. In rebuttal, ASCAP asserted that it had a pre-existing contract with SPACEM for 1985. A/B/S Rebuttal, Testimony of Paul S. Adler, pp. 7-9. Further, BMI asserted that in 1985, it licensed the rights to over 900 songs composed by approximately 60 of the writers who are asserted to belong to SPACEM. A/B/S Ex. 33R; Tr. 446-447.
Bernard stated that in October, 1986, ACEMLA established an office in the Dominican Republic, and that ACEMLA is now the only Dominican Republic organization authorized under law to act as a performing rights society. ACEMLA Direct, Ex. 1, p. 2. Bernard had no documentation to support his assertion of being the only authorized performing rights society in the Dominican Republic. Tr. 129. Bernard made no attempt to relate these assertions of events taking place in 1986-1987 to 1985. ACEMLA Direct, Ex. 1.
ACEMLA submitted contracts between Latin American Music Co., Inc. (LAMCO) and 25 different individual composers entered into between 1970 and 1985 (contracts entered into prior to April, 1981 were with Latin American Music, a sole proprietorship owned by Bernard which was a predecessor company to LAMCO). Typically, these contracts provide that the composer assign to LAMCO "the entire exclusive right to publicly perform" the music assigned. ACEMLA Ex. 24.
ACEMLA also claimed it has agreements with SELEMUSICA, a Venezuelan publisher, through its agreement with Westside Music Publishers, Inc. of New York, with Discofinia, an Argentinian publisher, with PERUMUSICA and Corporacion Musical Latino, Peruvian publishers, and with HONY of Mexico. ACEMLA Direct, Ex. 1, pp. 2-3. Except for three titles, any agreement as to other songs with PERUMUSICA was an oral agreement. Tr. 132. Similarly, the agreement with HONY of Mexico was oral. Tr. 134.
Licensing Activity. On September 29, 1986, ACEMLA entered into a licensing agreement with radio station WNWK, Newark, New Jersey, pursuant to which the radio station acknowledged it broadcasted some musical works under ACEMLA's control between September, 1983 and September, 1986 and agreed to a retroactive license during that three-year period at a rate of $1500 per year. 1984 ACEMLA Ex. 15, p. 1 (excluded from the 1984 record for untimeliness, admitted for first time in the 1985 proceeding).
ACEMLA attempted unsuccessfully to obtain licenses in 1985 from WXTV, Channel 41, Secaucus, New Jersey; WADO, New York, New York; WNJU-TV, Newark, New Jersey; WSKQ, New York, New York; WJIT, New York, New York; KFLR, Phoenix, Arizona; KFLT, Tuscon, Arizona, and KFLQ, Albuquerque, New Mexico; WKDM, Carldstadt, New Jersey; KDOS-FM, Freemont, California; and KGST, Fresno, California. ACEMLA Ex. 3.
Other features. Bernard stated ACEMLA collected in 1986 its first royalties for the public performance of music from radio station WNWK for music broadcast during the years 1983-1986. ACEMLA Ex. 1, p. 4. ACEMLA also claimed that it received, during 1987, payments from the jukebox fund maintained by the U.S. Government as a result of awards made by the Tribunal for jukebox play of ACEMLA's compositions during 1982 and 1983. Id. These awards were made to LAMCO, a music publishing company, not to ACEMLA. 51 FR 43460.
ACEMLA made no distributions during 1985. ACEMLA Ex. 1, pp. 4-5.
Bernard stated that on March 11, 1987, LAMCO, ACEMLA, and Bernard filed a civil action in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey against Command Broadcast Associates, d/b/a WADO Radio, alleging copyright infringement during 1985, as well as other years. ACEMLA Ex. 1, p. 3. Bernard also stated that on April 14, 1987, LAMCO, ACEMLA, and Bernard filed a suit in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey against Infinity Broadcasting Co., Inc., d/b/a WJIT, alleging copyright infringement during 1985 and other years. Id., p. 4.
Staff of ACEMLA. According to Bernard, the staff of ACEMLA has remained the same size as in the period 1982-1984, five employees. Tr. 104. These employees work for Bernard's record company, and music publishing company, as well as in the performing rights area. When asked by the Tribunal whether there are any officers of ACEMLA besides Bernard, whether there are any employees who work specifically for ACEMLA, and how many hours Bernard, his wife, and his employees devote to ACEMLA, Bernard stated either it was privileged information, or answered the questions in the most general way. Tr. 104-114. Bernard was told by the Tribunal that the Tribunal can only make determinations based upon what it is presented. Tr. 105, 114.
Assertion of attributes similar to SESAC. ACEMLA introduced a blank SESAC-publisher form agreement which has clauses which assign to SESAC, in addition to the right to license the performing right in nondramatic musical works, the licensing of dramatic musical works, mechanical rights and synchronization rights. ACEMLA Ex. 15RX. A/B/S concedes that SESAC's activities extend beyond performing rights to include mechanical and synchronization rights. A/B/S Proposed Findings, par. 83.
Status of IBC
Italian Book Company was formed in 1910. Tr. 231. Italian Book Company, and other organizations, such as DeMartino Italian Music Corporation, Libria DeMartino, Inc., and ItalAmerica Music Publishers, Inc. merged to form IBC some time between 1968 and 1970. Tr. 231, 248.
IBC has agreements with Italian music publishers in which, in the United States and Canada, IBC is free to assign its songs to other publishers and license all aspects of copyrights for the publishers it represents. Tr. 240. IBC stated it represented two copyright owners directly. Tr. 262. On the basis of these agreements, IBC represented that it has about 25,000 Italian-language songs composed between 1900 and 1972 in its repertory. IBC Ex. 1, p. 1.
Under its agreements with Italian publishers, 10% of all license fees collected is deducted for costs, and the remainder is split equally between IBC and the Italian publisher. Tr. 238-239. The Italian publishers are not members or affiliates of IBC. Tr. 287. Royalties are sent by IBC to the publisher only, not to the composer. Tr. 287-288.
IBC styles itself a "small family business." Tr. 265. It makes no organizational or structural distinctions between its asserted performing rights *46326 society operation and its publishing and subpublishing operation. Tr. 265. IBC has no departments or divisions. Id.
IBC received about $6,000 in license fees from about 10 or 11 radio stations in 1985. Tr. 266-267. IBC did not license the public performance of its music to restaurants, theaters, or concert halls in 1985, except perhaps for one or two instances, in which the fee might have been $50 or $60. Tr. 267- 270. IBC did not distribute any royalties in 1985. IBC Ex. 1, p. 1; Tr. 218.
In the past, IBC has been a publisher member of ASCAP and a publisher affiliate of BMI. Tr. 237. In the view of the owner of IBC, Frank Tudisco, IBC is both a performing rights society and a music publisher. Tr. 248. IBC has listed itself sometimes as a music publisher in Billboard's International Buyers' Guide, and sometimes as a licensing organization. In the 1971-1972 edition, IBC listed itself as a music publisher. A/B/S Ex. 20X; Tr. 259. In the 1982-1986 editions, IBC listed itself as a licensing organization. IBC Ex. 5R. The Billboard publication is published yearly and the information is based upon information solicited from the organizations which appear therein. Id.
During the 1979/1980 jukebox distribution proceeding, IBC represented to the Tribunal that it was a performing rights society, and the Tribunal, considering IBC's status not necessary to the determination of IBC's royalty award, accepted IBC's assertions without further inquiry. 47 FR 18406 (1982). In the appeal taken by ACEMLA of the 1982 jukebox distribution, however, the Court of Appeals found that determining the status of the claimants is necessary to a proper handling of the jukebox fund distribution, and remanded the 1982 jukebox royalty distribution to the Tribunal for further examination by the Tribunal of the status of ACEMLA (and by implication, the status of any future claimants, such as IBC). ACEMLA, Latin American Music and Latin American Music, Inc. v. Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 763 F. 2d 101 (2d Cir. 1985).
In the 1982/1983 consolidated jukebox distribution proceeding, the Tribunal received a stipulation signed by ASCAP, BMI, SESAC, ACEMLA, and IBC, representing that IBC was a copyright owner and not a performing rights society. 50 FR 47577, 47578, 47581. In this proceeding, IBC has not presented any evidence that any structural or organizational changes were made within IBC to account for any change in the representation of its status over the years. IBC Direct Case.
Rebuttal of A/B/S Regarding Status of ACEMLA and IBC
Paul S. Adler (Adler), Director of Membership for ASCAP, testified on behalf of A/B/S to rebut the assertions by ACEMLA and IBC that they are performing rights societies. Reb. Test. of Adler. In Adler's view, the salient features of a performing rights society are: (1) It is an organization separate and independent of any publisher or writer; (2) it represents a diverse range of writers and publishers; (3) it has a staff of a size sufficient to operate in the territory for which it claims to administer rights; (4) it licenses a wide range of users throughout that territory, with sufficient administrative and legal staff to police meaningfully the rights it licenses; (5) it has a well-defined, published royalty distribution system for writers as well as publishers; (6) in the normal course, it pays the writer and publisher groups their royalties directly and separately; and (7) it makes such royalty payments in a regularized manner. Id., pp. 1-2.
In Adler's view, ACEMLA and IBC have no distribution system at all; what they have is a form of publisher-subpublisher arrangement, which includes a provision that the subpublisher will collect performing rights income directly from licensees, rather than obtaining it through a performing rights society. Id., pp. 2-3. The United States subpublisher collects United States royalties, keeps a percentage, and remits payments to the foreign publisher as they may agree. In such an arrangement, the foreign writer has no relationship with the U.S. subpublisher at all; the writer gets paid from the original publisher out of the money the publisher receives. Id., p. 4.
Conclusions of Law
ACEMLA Was Not a Performing Rights Society in 1985. IBC Was Not a Performing Rights Society in 1985
The Tribunal concluded in the 1982/1983 jukebox distribution proceeding, and again in the 1984 jukebox distribution proceeding that ACEMLA was not a performing rights society during those years. The Tribunal found that Mr. Bernard had not taken any structural steps in 1982-1984 to create a performing rights society aside from filing for ACEMLA to be the assumed name of LAMCO. We found in the last proceeding that the structural device of "assumed name" was an insufficient step. We stated,
The law and logic dictate that an assumed name is not a separate entity from its original name. Additionally, here the use of this device establishes a very difficult contradiction. Mr. Bernard claims that LAMCO is a music publisher, and that ACEMLA is a performing rights society, and that they must be considered different. But he also claims that ACEMLA is a corporation by virtue of it being the assumed name of LAMCO, and he asserts that ACEMLA has obtained the rights to represent the music obtained by LAMCO without any transfer documents because ACEMLA and LAMCO are the same. Evidently, sometimes ACEMLA is different than LAMCO and sometimes they are one and the same. 51 FR 43457
We required that one part of finding ACEMLA to be a performing rights society would be a finding that ACEMLA is at least independent enough of copyright owners to have its own organizational papers and structure. In 1985, ACEMLA took no further structural steps to create a performing rights society, and therefore, it fails to meet the first part of the definition of a performing rights society in the Copyright Act, "An association or corporation * * *"
ACEMLA's attempt at bolstering its 1982-1984 showings in the 1985 proceeding were unavailing. ACEMLA claims it has new agreements with SPACEM, Discofinia, PERUMUSICA, Corporacion Musical Latino, HONY and with 25 individual composers. A/B/S attempted to diminish the effect of these additional agreements by asserting that ASCAP had the pertinent agreement with SPACEM for 1985, and that, except for three titles belonging to PERUMUSICA, the agreements with PERUMUSICA and with HONY were oral agreements, and therefore, ineffective under the Copyright Act. It is unnecessary for the Tribunal to rule on these cross-assertions in this instance, because it is the nature of the agreements, not the number of them, that is important to the question of whether ACEMLA is a performing rights society.
Regarding the nature of these agreements, these agreements are with LAMCO, the music publisher. In the case of the 25 individual composers, the Tribunal adopted ACEMLA/IBC's proposed findings verbatim, "ACEMLA submitted contracts between LAMCO and 25 different composers entered into between 1970 and 1985. Typically, these contracts provide that the composer assign to LAMCO 'the entire exclusive right to publicly perform' the music assigned." ACEMLA/IBC Proposed Findings, par. 7. These individual composers are neither members nor affiliates of ACEMLA; they have entered into a contract with a music publisher in which the public performing right has been assigned. As to the other contracts, in earlier proceedings, Mr. Bernard *46327 testified that the performing rights obtained by various contracts with Latin American Music, LAMCO, or International Music Co. were assigned to ACEMLA, but there was no documentation to support this. Mr. Bernard explained that any agreement with LAMCO would act automatically as an authorization to ACEMLA, because ACEMLA is an assumed name of LAMCO.
This is an insufficient explanation. Prospective members or affiliates of ACEMLA must have the cognition that they are becoming members or affiliates of a society, and, in addition, oral assignment of rights is ineffective under the Copyright Act. 17 U.S.C. 204(a). ACEMLA has done nothing in 1985 to improve upon this deficiency.
ACEMLA's assertion that it has established an office in the Dominican Republic and that it is now the only Dominican Republic organization authorized under law to act as a performing rights society is undocumented, and if true, pertains to events occurring in 1986-1987 and no attempt to show the relevance to 1985 was made. Additionally, the opinion of the Dominican Republic, although useful information for the Tribunal, is not binding on the Tribunal.
ACEMLA also points to licensing activity and to enforcement activity to show that it has the attributes of ASCAP, BMI and SESAC. It entered into an agreement on September 29, 1986 with WNWK, Newark, New Jersey, to pay ACEMLA a license for use of ACEMLA's music between September, 1983 and September, 1986. It stated it instituted two suits in 1987 alleging infringement by WADO and WJIT during 1985 and other years. A/B/S argue against the relation back nature of this evidence, pointing out that the license agreement occurred in 1986 and the infringement actions occurred in 1987. Again, it is not necessary for the Tribunal to resolve these arguments, because it is not the number of licenses ACEMLA succeeds in obtaining or the number of infringement suits it initiates, but whether ACEMLA obtained these licenses and instituted these suits as a music publisher or subpublisher, or as a performing rights society.
At the close of the oral testimony, the Tribunal instructed the claimants to file their opinions as to the difference between copyright owners and performing rights societies. In the 1982/1983 consolidated jukebox distribution proceeding, the Tribunal stated its opinion that a music publisher is not a performing rights society by the mere fact that it may license music, or that it may enforce its copyright. We stated,
A copyright owner, before he or she assigns the rights in the copyright to someone else, may enforce the performing rights. So may a music publishing company after it has been assigned the rights from a copyright owner, and so may a U.S. subpublisher. In fact, Congress recognized this by among other things establishing the first category of copyright owners to collect royalties for performing rights on jukeboxes and then the second category of performing rights society. Mr. Bernard's view of the law would make every individual copyright owner or music publisher a performing rights society. 50 FR 47581
ACEMLA/IBC answered the Tribunal's request by proffering this definition, "any association or corporation which controls enough music to command long-term licenses from users desiring such licenses for legitimate economic reasons and which distributes the revenues from those licenses to others is a Performing Rights Society." ACEMLA/IBC Proposed Findings, par. 55. The Tribunal disagrees with this definition. Among other things it seems to place its emphasis on the size of the music catalogue, and the value of that catalogue sufficient to command long-term licenses, thereby introducing a question of "bigness" that the Tribunal has rejected. 50 FR 47581. It also places emphasis on distribution of revenues. The Tribunal agrees that this is important, but by its own definition, ACEMLA would fail to meet the test, because it has not yet made a distribution to any individual or entity with which it has an association. Finally, it is a definition which could be met by a music publisher as well as a performing rights society, and hence, misses the distinction the Tribunal believes Congress intended.
The Tribunal agrees with the points made by Mr. Adler, witness for A/B/S, that the difference between a performing rights society and a music publisher or subpublisher is that a performing rights society is an organization separate and independent of any publisher or writer, that it has a well-defined, published royalty distribution system for writers as well as publishers, that in the normal course, it pays the writers and publishers groups their royalties directly and separately and it makes such royalty payments in a regularized manner. In a publisher-subpublisher relationship, the subpublisher in the United States will collect the pertinent royalties directly from the licensees, keep a percentage, and remit payment back to the foreign publisher as they may agree. The writer gets paid from the original publisher out of the money the publisher receives.
A/B/S also urged upon the Tribunal that the difference between a subpublisher and a performing rights society is one of size. Although not necessarily stating that a purported society must have the size of ASCAP, BMI or SESAC, A/B/S does argue that a purported society should have a staff of a size sufficient to operate in the territory for which it claims to administer rights, and to police meaningfully the rights it licenses. The Tribunal has rejected the argument of "bigness," but it has been concerned with whether ACEMLA has the resources to function at all. It has at most five employees. These five employees are shared with the record company and the music publishing company, and Mr. Bernard declined to answer the Tribunal's questions as to how these employees are used, or how much time they devote to ACEMLA matters. The Tribunal stated at that time that without the cooperation of the witness, an adverse conclusion would most likely result. Here, in view of the entire record, we believe an adverse conclusion is warranted, and that is, that ACEMLA does not have sufficient employees to function as a performing rights society.
ACEMLA has three final arguments: (1) That because SESAC, like ACEMLA, also carries out the licensing of mechanical rights and synchronization rights, therefore the Tribunal's insistence on a structural differentiation between the performing rights society functions of ACEMLA and the music publishing functions of ACEMLA is either arbitrary or must be applied equally to SESAC; (2) that the Tribunal's findings that ACEMLA is not a performing rights society unduly inhibits emerging organizations such as ACEMLA from entering the performing rights society business as a competitor to the oligopolies of ASCAP, BMI and SESAC, and that as a federal government agency, the Tribunal is obligated to conduct its proceedings in a manner to enhance competition, rather than raise artificial barriers to entry; (3) that section 116 has created two classes of claimants with dramatically different and unequal burdens of proceeding, and that these classifications violate the equal protection requirements of the U.S. Constitution.
Regarding ACEMLA's reference to SESAC's activities, while SESAC may at times carry on some functions of a music publisher, it was recognized by Congress as a performing rights society, and the record indicates that it chiefly collects the performing rights royalties on behalf of its many affiliates. On the other hand, LAMCO is a music publishing company--the owner of *46328 copyrights--which has endeavored to start a performing rights society, ACEMLA. It wants to achieve this by transferring from LAMCO to ACEMLA the license to collect performing rights royalties, yet without ACEMLA constituting a different entity, the "transfer" is a fiction. ACEMLA must be more than another name for LAMCO. It must essentially be a performing rights society.
The seeming equality between ACEMLA and SESAC which ACEMLA believes was shown by the blank SESAC contract form was not shown at all. There are times when businesses will perform functions outside of their essential area of interest. For example, grocery stores will carry over-the-counter drugs, and conversely, a drug store will sell milk and bread. In any factual situation which is not entirely clear-cut, what the reviewing agency must resolve is the essential nature of the entities before it. Here, we have resolved that ACEMLA is essentially a music publisher and SESAC is essentially a performing rights society, and that finding is undisturbed by any activities in which SESAC may engage outside of the performing rights area.
ACEMLA's argument that the Tribunal has antitrust responsibilities fails for lack of a foundation. The Tribunal has no regulatory powers in the music industry, except to set four copyright royalty rates. The Tribunal does not grant performing rights society status nor does it deny it. It does not have the jurisdiction. What the Tribunal does is it makes a finding as a predicate to an adjudication of royalty claims whether a claimant is a copyright owner or a performing rights society, but the Tribunal's opinion of the status of a claimant has only one effect--that of determining the burden of going forward with the evidence within a Section 116 royalty distribution proceeding. The Tribunal's opinion has no legal effect upon the music industry.
Indeed, the Tribunal believes the obverse, that ACEMLA has urged upon the Tribunal a regulatory function it does not have, so that, if ACEMLA does obtain a finding that it is a performing rights society for the purpose of a Section 116 proceeding, that finding will be used within the music industry by ACEMLA for purposes the Tribunal did not intend. Already, we note that ACEMLA filed in its written direct case that it received royalties from the Tribunal as a performing rights society. This is untrue. LAMCO, a music publisher, was the recipient of 1982/1983 jukebox royalties, and the Tribunal admonishes ACEMLA for such lack of candor in its pleadings.
Finally, the Tribunal believes that the categorization between copyright owners and performing rights societies which Congress established has a rational basis, and is therefore constitutional.
For most of the above-mentioned reasons, the Tribunal also concludes that IBC was not a performing rights society in 1985. IBC is essentially a music subpublisher for several Italian publishers abroad. It has a longer history than ACEMLA, and it has 10 or 11 radio station licenses, and some minor licenses for the public performance of music at restaurants, theaters and concert halls. However, it has taken no structural steps to create a performing rights society apart from its functions as a music subpublisher. It has no members or affiliates. It has no distribution system. It made no distributions in 1985. It pays the Italian publishers based upon its contract with them. It does not pay the writer directly, and if the writer does not get paid, the writer's recourse is to the Italian publisher, not IBC.
IBC was described by the Tribunal as a performing rights society in the 1979/1980 jukebox distribution final determination, but this was made upon the representation of IBC without inquiry by the Tribunal. When the Tribunal was instructed by the Court of Appeals that the status of a claimant is a necessary predicate to determining the burden of going forward with the evidence, the Tribunal first took up the status of IBC in the 1982/1983 consolidated jukebox proceeding, and in that proceeding, IBC signed a stipulation that stated that it was a copyright owner, not a performing rights society.
ACEMLA/IBC argue that a signed stipulation does not bind parties in subsequent proceedings, citing Red Lake Band v. U.S., 607 F. 2d 930 (U.S. Ct. of Cl. 1979). A look at the facts underlying Red Lake Band shows that Red Lake Band does not stand for such a broad proposition. In Red Lake Band, a stipulation signed as a co-defendant by Red Lake Band in 1935 as to the value of certain land was deemed not to bind Red Lake Band when it became a plaintiff decades later for the value of the same land. It was found that the stipulation was not necessary to the determination of the 1935 case, and that it was not anticipated at the time of the stipulation that U.S. law would change making it possible for Red Lake Band to sue for an amount greater than the value of the stipulation. Hence, the court was led to a finding that Red Lake Band did not have the necessary intent for its stipulation to bind it in future proceedings.
Strict application of collateral estoppel, based on IBC's stipulation, would mean that the Tribunal would look only at the years 1984 and 1985 to determine whether any circumstances had changed to indicate that IBC had become a performing rights society. The Tribunal has chosen not to apply collateral estoppel, but to take up an analysis of IBC from its inception. We do note, however, that the stipulation is part of a pattern of inconsistency in which IBC sometimes represents itself as a performing rights society to the industry and to the Tribunal, and sometimes it does not. The Tribunal considers all such self-representations as irrelevant, and has determined that IBC is a music subpublisher, not a performing rights society, based upon the substance of IBC's operations.
Effect of the Tribunal's First Conclusion
The Tribunal has concluded that ACEMLA and IBC were copyright owners in 1985. The next step is to consider the value of the music ACEMLA and IBC control. After Tribunal consideration of ACEMLA and IBC, the Tribunal's task is complete because the three performing rights societies are in agreement.
It was the intent of Congress and it is the policy of the Tribunal to encourage settlements in royalty distribution proceedings. Accordingly, 17 U.S.C. 116(c)(2) states, in part, "* * * for purposes of this subsection any claimants may agree among themselves as to the proportionate division of compulsory licensing fees among them, may lump their claims together and file them jointly or as a single claim, or may designate a common agent to receive payment on their behalf." ACEMLA and IBC have filed a joint claim. Therefore, the Tribunal will consider the sum value of their catalogues only, and will not make any subdetermination of the contribution of ACEMLA's catalogue or IBC's catalogue to the total award. We believe that to do otherwise would tend to negate the settlement between ACEMLA and IBC, and work against Congress' intent and Tribunal policy.
Regarding our consideration of ACEMLA's and IBC's claim, we reiterate our belief expressed in the last proceeding that the status of the claimants, whether copyright owners or performing rights society, does not affect the valuation of their claim. ACEMLA/IBC has argued strenuously that the effect of being the only claimant under the "spotlight" is to place ACEMLA/IBC *46329 at a great disadvantage. We disagree. The Tribunal makes every effort to valuate the claim in the context of the entire universe of musical works under consideration, regardless of whose burden it is to put forward the evidence. Further, we doubt the very existence of either a procedural or pyschological disadvantage of being the only claimant under consideration. We note that in a similar situation in the 1982 cable royalty distribution proceeding where the Devotional Claimants was the only non-settling party and thus had its claim considered alone, the Devotional Claimants had its award increased from 0.35% to 1%. 49 FR 37653.
Findings of Fact
ACEMLA's Proof of Entitlement
In the 1984 jukebox distribution proceeding, the Tribunal awarded ACEMLA, as the assumed name of LAMCO, 0.06% of the jukebox fund. 51 FR 43455. ACEMLA has incorporated by reference the record evidence supporting that award and earlier awards, and a recitation of that evidence is not repeated herein. Supplement to Direct Case of ACEMLA. ACEMLA's entitlement showing in 1985, building upon earlier showings, is as follows:
Demographics. In March, 1985, there were 16.9 million persons of Spanish origin in the United States, representing an increase of 2.3 million persons over the 1980 Census figure of 14.6 million. ACEMLA Ex. 4. According to Broadcasting Cablecasting Yearbook 1986, there were 207 Spanish-language radio stations in the United States in 1985, 59 in Texas, 46 in California, and 36 in Puerto Rico. ACEMLA Ex. 5, pp. 1-2.
Additions to ACEMLA catalogue. In November, 1986, ACEMLA entered into an agreement with SPACEM, an association of composers in Puerto Rico, to collect and distribute performing rights royalties for it, retroactive to April 1, 1985. ACEMLA Ex. 1, p. 1. ACEMLA signed up certain additional individual composers in 1985, and in 1986, ACEMLA entered into agreements with six Dominican Republic composers who authorized ACEMLA to collect performing rights royalties for the year 1985. Id., p. 2.
In rebuttal, ASCAP asserted that SPACEM had a pre-existing agreement with ASCAP for 1985. Reb. Test. of Adler, pp. 7-9. Robert L. Ahrold (Ahrold), testifying for BMI, stated that under the ASCAP/SPACEM agreement, U.S. publishers who may not have been members of ASCAP may have acquired rights to individual songs written by SPACEM writers. Accordingly, BMI publisher affiliates have acquired the rights to over 900 works by approximately 60 SPACEM writers. A/B/S Ex. 33R; Tr. 446-447.
Monitoring of public performances of ACEMLA works. ACEMLA undertook a limited monitoring of three New York City radio stations in 1985 to determine which titles in its repertory were being broadcast. Radio station WADO was monitored on 14 days, WJIT was monitored on 10 days, and WSKQ was monitored on 5 days. In total, 138 different ACEMLA-controlled songs (including 5 based upon ACEMLA's agreement with SPACEM) were played during this limited monitoring. ACEMLA Ex. 6. ACEMLA's monitoring was not conducted on any scientific basis. The recordings were not made continuously, and so do not show the frequency of performance of ACEMLA-claimed songs in relation to other songs. Tr. 343. The three New York stations do not constitute a representative sample of all Spanish-language radio stations. Tr. 344.
Hit Songs Charts. ACEMLA analyzed 19 of 52 weekly Billboard Top Latin Album charts published in 1985, and found that 47 songs in its repertory appeared on 32 of the albums listed. This included 13 songs by virtue of the contract with SPACEM. ACEMLA Ex. 7.
Daily newspapers Noticias El Mundo and Vocero, published in New York City, published lists of the most popular Spanish-language records from time to time in 1985, and 18 ACEMLA-controlled songs were included in these lists. ACEMLA Ex. 8.
A bi-weekly magazine, Guia Radial Del Show, published hit songs charts during 1985, based upon information furnished by a Puerto Rican record store, and various ACEMLA-controlled songs appeared regularly on those lists. ACEMLA Ex. 9.
In rebuttal, Robert L. Ahrold, Vice President for Corporate Relations for BMI, testified that popularity on long-playing albums, such as those listed on Billboard's Latin Album charts, does not translate to popularity as 45 rpm singles, suitable for jukebox play. Reb. Test. of Ahrold, pp. 5-7. Ahrold worked in 1985 as Vice President for Communications for RCA/Ariola. RCA/Ariola produced 130 Spanish-language albums in 1985. RCA/Ariola produced very few 45 rpm records for either promotional or commercial use. The emphasis was almost entirely on the long-playing format in 1985, and Ahrold believes this practice is true for the Latin music industry in general. Id.
Again, in rebuttal, Emilio Garcia, Manager of the International Department for The Harry Fox Agency, Inc., testified as an expert in the Latin music industry. Reb. Test. of Emilio Garcia. Based upon his experience, Garcia testified that 45 rpm records in the Latin music industry were insignificant in 1985. Virtually the entire run of Spanish-language 45's are pressed for promotional purposes, and sent to radio stations as promotional copies. Consequently, there are almost no Spanish-language 45's for commercial sale and possible play in jukeboxes. Id., p. 5.
Garcia also testified that record store song charts are not a reliable basis for determining play of Spanish-language music on jukeboxes. In Garcia's view, record store song charts are promotional devices, listing not necessarily those songs which are selling, but those songs which a particular store publishing the chart wants to sell. Id., p. 7. Garcia believes that record store charts do not have any significance beyond the immediate community for which they are produced and distributed. Id. Garcia believes this is especially true for this proceeding, given the great diversity of musical interests and tastes within the Spanish-speaking communities of the United States. Garcia believes that ACEMLA Ex. 9 demonstrates nothing beyond what the songs the store in question, Music City, may be selling or wanting to sell in Carolina, Puerto Rico. Id., p. 9. Garcia also denies Bernard's assertion that Puerto Rico is a distribution center for Spanish-language 45 rpm records. According to Garcia, there are two pressing plants in Puerto Rico and they press product for small local labels only. They have no accounts from the mainland. Id., p. 10.
Also, in rebuttal, A/B/S asserts that charts relating to Puerto Rico are not relevant to this proceeding, because there were no licensed jukeboxes in Puerto Rico in 1985. A/B/S Ex. 22X.
A/B/S Radio Survey, and Dispute of Title Ownership. As in prior years, A/B/S performed a radio survey of ACEMLA-controlled works. Reb. Test. of Adler; Reb. Test. of Ahrold. In this proceeding, A/B/S performed a survey of the songs listed by ACEMLA in the 1982-1984 proceeding, and the songs listed for the first time in the 1985 proceeding. Reb. Test. of Ahrold, p. 3. Prior to aggregating the survey results for each song, A/B/S deleted from the list 62 songs which A/B/S believed were in the combined repertories of A/B/S. A/B/S Ex. 24R; Reb. Test. of Adler, p. 11; Reb. Test. of Ahrold, p. 3.
ACEMLA sought and received leave to file rebuttal to show that those 62 songs which A/B/S believes are in the A/B/S catalogues, are, in fact, in *46330 ACEMLA's catalogue. Tr. 447-448; ACEMLA Ex. 25.
In ACEMLA Exhibit 25, ACEMLA offered no statement in regard to 14 of the 62 songs. In regard to "La Revancha," ACEMLA acknowledged that the rights to it had been released back to the author who may have licensed the rights to someone else in 1985. In regard to four other songs, "La Guagua," "La Piragua," "Navidad Negra," and "San Fernando," ACEMLA relied on the personal assurances that these songs are in ACEMLA's catalogue. ACEMLA's claim to another 19 titles is based on its agreement with SPACEM, an agreement A/B/S disputes is valid. ACEMLA Ex. 25.
The Tribunal requested of A/B/S the radio survey results including the 62 contested songs, and excluding the 62 contested songs. Tr. 483. Excluding the 62 contested songs, according to ASCAP's methodology, if ACEMLA had been an ASCAP member in 1985, it would have earned for 396 songs, 2,370 radio credits out of a total of 13,235,103 earned by all ASCAP members, yielding a percentage of 0.01791%. Reb. Test. of Adler, pp. 12-13. Including the 62 contested songs, the percentage is 0.03277%. A/B/S Proposed Findings, par. 110, fn. 35. This compares with a result reached by ASCAP in the 1984 jukebox proceeding of 0.02065%. 1984 Reb. Test. of Adler. pp. 12-15.
BMI conducted a similar radio survey, using the same parameters as ASCAP did in its study. BMI determined that if ACEMLA had been a BMI affiliate in 1985, their musical works would have accounted for 0.001383% of BMI's distribution for all similar U.S. radio performances. Reb. Test. of Ahrold, p. 5. Including the 62 contested songs, the percentage is 0.00453%. A/B/S Proposed Findings, par. 110, fn. 36. This compares with BMI's survey results for 1984 which yielded 0.001850%. 1984 Reb. Test. of Alan Smith, pp. 4-6.
IBC Proofs of Entitlement
IBC received cash awards from the Tribunal of $1000 and $800 in the 1979 and 1980 jukebox distribution proceedings, respectively. 47 FR 18406. These are the only proceedings in which IBC litigated its claim and which have precedential value. IBC incorporated by reference the evidence underlying the awards of the 1979 and 1980 proceeding. Supplement to Direct Case of IBC.
IBC has about 25,000 Italian-language songs composed between 1900 and 1972 in its repertory. IBC Ex. 1, p. 1. Mr. Frank Tudisco, owner of IBC, stated that there are thousands of Italian pizza parlors in the United States which play the older Italian songs on jukeboxes. Tr. 296. In the old pizza parlors, whenever the records are changed in the jukeboxes, according to Tudisco, four or five of the old Italian records stay in the jukeboxes. Tr. 311.
IBC Exhibit 1 included photocopies of a few record jackets from Italian-language 45 rpm records which purport to list other 45 rpm records available for sale. IBC indicated on these record jackets 62 songs which it claims. IBC Ex. 1, Attachment. IBC could offer no underlying documentation to identify the sources and dates of publication of the record jackets. Tr. 304.
In rebuttal, ASCAP performed a radio survey of IBC works. First, ASCAP asserts that 7 of the 62 IBC-claimed songs are actually in the A/B/S repertories. A/B/S Ex. 27R; Reb. Test. of Adler, p. 10. Eliminating those works from its consideration, but including 400 songs which IBC previously provided to ASCAP as representing its most significant songs, ASCAP states that it found that only one IBC-claimed song had any performances in its radio survey in 1985. The credits IBC would have earned for that song would have been 20.854, or 0.00016% of the total radio credits earned by ASCAP works. Reb. Test. of Adler, p. 15.
Conclusions of Law--ACEMLA's and IBC's Entitlements
It is the Tribunal's conclusion that ACEMLA and IBC, collectively, have shown entitlement to 0.12% of the 1985 jukebox royalty fund.
The Tribunal's analysis proceeds from the levels of entitlement previously shown by ACEMLA and IBC. ACEMLA was awarded 0.06% of the 1984 jukebox royalty fund. The last time IBC litigated its award, 1979 and 1980, it was awarded $1000 and $800 for those two proceedings, which translates to 0.74% and 0.65% of the 1979 and 1980 funds, respectively. Based upon previously established entitlements only, the collective award for ACEMLA and IBC would be in the range of 0.125% to 0.135%.
It does not appear to the Tribunal that ACEMLA and IBC have proved their entitlement in the 1985 proceeding to the levels previously proved, and a slight downward adjustment to 0.12% is warranted.
Regarding ACEMLA's proofs, there was some indication that perhaps in 1985 ACEMLA had published more of its works, and more of its works were being performed, generally. Agreements which were only entered into during 1982- 1984 presumably were in fuller operation in 1985, and 45 rpm records which were pressed in 1982-1985 could have gained greater circulation in 1985 as ACEMLA's publishing efforts might have begun to pay off. The most persuasive evidence regarding this is the monitoring of three New York stations which shows that ACEMLA's works were beginning to be played over the air in 1985. Higher credit to ACEMLA's contribution to the collective award to ACEMLA and IBC might therefore be justified.
However, certain criticism of ACEMLA's proofs must be noted, and that criticism comes mainly in the lack of nexus between the assertions of ACEMLA and any desired conclusion that ACEMLA may want the Tribunal to reach. The demographic evidence, for example, which ACEMLA has offered in each year's proceedings has no demonstrable nexus to ACEMLA's entitlement. It is presumed that ACEMLA offered evidence of an increase in Spanish-language persons in the United States from 1980 to 1985 to demonstrate a greater audience for its works, but these demographic figures in no way lead the Tribunal to understand what percentage of Spanish-language music in the United States ACEMLA controls. In fact, ACEMLA's other proffered demographic evidence, that there are 207 Spanish-language format radio stations in the United States is damaging to ACEMLA's case, rather than helpful. ACEMLA has obtained only one license from 207 radio stations, and that license is for only $1500 a year, indicating to us that the station is paying ACEMLA only for a fraction of the music it uses. Clearly, this statistic reveals that the vast majority of Spanish-language music in the United States is not under ACEMLA's control.
The lack of nexus in the rest of ACEMLA's proofs is also evident. Although we have credited the works monitored by ACEMLA on three New York stations, it has not given us a statistically usable measure to relate that evidence to ACEMLA's percentage entitlement.
We are particularly concerned by the credible evidence given by Latin music experts, that generally, in the Latin music industry, 45 rpm records play little or no role. If that were true, then the album charts and the radio play would have little connection to jukebox play. What is key, however, to the testimony of the Latin music experts is that they were speaking only for the general industry practice, and not to ACEMLA's practices in particular. We are not inclined, therefore, to discredit ACEMLA's evidence on that basis. However, we would require in future proceedings that ACEMLA explain to the Tribunal more of its operations--which songs have been recorded on 45 *46331 rpm records, how many were released, how have they been distributed, and where.
Regarding the ASCAP and BMI radio surveys, they indicate a general continuity of some radio play of ACEMLA works. Any fluctuation in the actual percentages from 1984 were not considered great enough to change our analysis of ACEMLA's entitlement. We do note that there were a number of disputes regarding the right of ACEMLA to represent several works, and the right of ACEMLA to represent the SPACEM writers. Within the context of the ASCAP and BMI radio surveys, the results of those surveys with or without the 62 contested songs were well within the mathematical range of possible error the Tribunal had previously built into the award to ACEMLA in 1984, so that no resolution of those disputes was necessary. We also believe that we did not need to weigh the effect of SPACEM writers as purported contractors of ACEMLA to conclude this year's entitlement. However, we are disturbed by the number of contested works, and contested contracts. We stated in the 1984 cable royalty distribution final determination that the Tribunal is not the appropriate forum for contract dispute resolution. 52 FR 8411. This proceeding shows clearly the reason for this. ACEMLA asserts that it has signed SPACEM, and ASCAP asserts that SPACEM had a pre-existing agreement with ASCAP. A proper handling of this issue would take an amount of time equal perhaps to an entire jukebox distribution proceeding, and we do not believe it was intended for the Tribunal to so devote its resources. We urge the parties to settle or stipulate these matters as best they can prior to or during the proceeding, or take the matter to court. In the event that these efforts fail, and that the matter is considered material to the Tribunal's deliberations, the Tribunal may have to assign these works to one claimant or another for the purposes only of a Section 116 proceeding on far less than the best evidence.
Regarding IBC's proofs, the Tribunal has been given almost no evidence from which to derive its conclusions. General statements about the size of the IBC catalogue, its long-time value in Italian neighborhoods, and an undocumented list of 62 songs are not sufficient. The Tribunal needs more hard facts about the nature of IBC's operations, similar to the questions we asked about ACEMLA--how many IBC Italian-language 45 rpm singles have been produced, released, sold, and where.
The value which the Tribunal has given IBC's claim is based almost solely on the previous records of 1979 and 1980. However, we state that this is the last proceeding in which the records of 1979 and 1980 will carry much weight, absent new evidence. IBC must demonstrate anew the marketplace value of its works, and a nexus must be shown with jukebox play. For example, our own review of the previous records shows a number of movie titles on which IBC relied, and it is not clear to us whether those movie titles were released as 45 rpm singles, and whether they have enduring value. This admonition to maintain an updated record is consistent with our conclusion in regard to NAB in the 1984 cable distribution proceeding, wherein we stated that the marketplace value of NAB's works would have to be updated from the 1979 proceeding. 51 FR 8419-20.
Our last admonition to ACEMLA and IBC is that the pattern of their witnesses to be reluctant to give precise answers, and to engage in "puffery," will result in adverse conclusions drawn by the Tribunal. As we stated last year, it is not our task to sort out a poorly constructed record.
Allocations
Accordingly, the Tribunal awards 0.12% of the 1985 jukebox royalty fund to ACEMLA as the assumed name of Latin American Music Co, Inc., and to Italian Book Corporation, collectively. The remainder of the fund is awarded to ASCAP, BMI and SESAC, Inc., collectively.
J.C. Argetsinger,
Chairman.
Dated: November 30, 1987.
[FR Doc. 87-27911 Filed 12-3-87; 8:45 am]
Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.