Copyright Royalty Tribunal

NOTICES
 
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
 
[CRT Docket No. 87-1-85JD]
 
Declaration of Controversy and Partial Distribution of Jukebox Royalty Fees
 
Tuesday, December 9, 1986
 

 *44331 In accordance with 17 U.S.C. 116(c)(3), the Copyright Royalty Tribunal (Tribunal) declares the existence of a controversy, effective December 10, 1986, concerning the distribution of royalty fees paid for 1985 performances of certain musical works by means of coin-operated phonorecord players (jukeboxes).

 The Tribunal has been informed by ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC, Inc. (A/B/S) that they have joined in a voluntary agreement conerning the distribution of 1985 jukebox fees, and together they claim they are entitled to 100% of the fund. the Tribunal has also been informed that ACEMLA and Italian Book Company (IBC) have joined in a voluntary agreement, and together they claim they are entitled to 12% of the fund.

 Motion to Strike. A motion was filed by A/B/S to strike IBC's justification of claim to 1985 jukebox royalties and to deny their participation in the 1985 jukebox distribution proceeding. The basis for A/B/S' motion is that on October 30, 1986, IBC informed the Tribunal that it has reached a settlement with ACEMLA and that it has therefore withdrawn its claim to 1985 jukebox royalties. Subsequent to that letter, IBC filed a justification of claim with ACEMLA. A/B/S argues that the withdrawal was unequivocal, and IBC may not now re-enter the proceeding.

 IBC replied to A/B/S' motion on November 20, 1986 stating that the October 30 letter should be modified to indicate that while IBC would not participate in the proceeding individually, it would participate as a joint claimant with ACEMLA. ACEMLA joined with IBC in opposing A/B/S' motion to strike. A/B/S replied to ACEMLA's and IBC's opposition stating that a claim is the essential predicate to any entitlement to the fund, and that IBC had clearly withdrawn its claim.

 The Tribunal denies A/B/S' motion. The Tribunal accepts IBC's modification to its October 30 letter.

 Motion for Immediate Partial Distribution. On November 5, 1986, A/B/S moved for distribution of 95% of the 1985 jukebox fund. A/B/S argues that although from the asserted claims it appears that 12% of the fund is in controversy, the Tribunal should distribute 95% of the jukebox fund, noting that the Tribunal has previously said, "the maximum claims advanced by claimants (do) not determine the amount in controversy for partial distribution purposes." 48 FR 54680 (December 6, 1983). ACEMLA and IBC opposed the motion, and A/B/S replied to the opposition.

 The Tribunal grants A/B/S' motion and will make a distribution of 95% of the jukebox fund on December 18, 1986. [FN1] The Tribunal observed last year that wildly inflated claims could frustrate a partial distribution, but chose last year to retain 10% of the 1984 jukebox fund pending review of ACEMLA's claim. Now in three successive distributions, ACEMLA's allocation has been 0.15, 0.15%, and 0.06% of the fund, and IBC's stipulated award has been smaller than ACEMLA's allocations.

   FN1 A/B/S has stipulated that should the Tribunal grant its motion, and should the Tribunal eventually find that it has distributed more than A/B/S' final allocation, A/B/S will return to the Tribunal the excess amount plus the interest the excess amount would have accrued had it remained in the fund.

 It is the Tribunal's judgment that given the previous records, ACEMLA's and IBC's combined claims could not reasonably be viewed to exceed 5% of the 1985 jukebox fund, absent a strong showing of changed circumstances or improved evidence. However, if there were such changed circumstances or improved evidence from 1984 to 1985, it was incumbent upon ACEMLA and IBC to show the basis of it in their justifications of claim.

 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Robert Cassler, General Counsel, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1100 20th Street, NW., Washington, DC 20036 (202)653-5175.

  Dated: December 4, 1986.

 J. C. Argetsinger,

 Chairman.

 [FR Doc. 86-27662 Filed 12-8-86; 8:45 am]


Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.