NOTICES
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
[Docket No. CRT 85-4-84CD]
1984 Cable Royalty Distribution Proceeding
Tuesday, March 17, 1987
*8408 AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.
ACTION: Notice of final determination.
SUMMARY: The Copyright Royalty Tribunal announces the adoption of its final determination in the proceeding concerning the distribution to certain copyright owners of royalty fees paid by cable systems for secondary transmissions during 1984.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Robert Cassler, General Counsel, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1111 20th Street N.W., Suite 450, Washington, D.C. 20036, (202) 653-5175.
SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION:
Authority
Section 111(d)(3) of the Copyright Act, as amended August 27, 1986, authorized the Copyright Royalty Tribunal to distribute annually royalty fees paid by cable systems to those among the following copyright owners who claim that their works were the subject of secondary transmissions by cable systems during the relevant semiannual period:
(A) Any such owner whose work was included in a secondary transmission made by a cable system of a nonnetwork television program in whole or in part beyond the local service area of the primary transmitter; and
(B) Any such owner whose work was included in a secondary transmission identified in a special statement of account deposited under paragraph (1)(A); and
(C) Any such owner whose work was included in nonnetwork programming consisting of aural signals carried by a cable system in whole or in part beyond the local service area of the primary transmitter of such programs.
This Proceeding
In this proceeding, the Tribunal takes up the distribution of the royalty fees deposited by cable operators for the calendar year 1984. In accordance with past procedure, the Tribunal resolved that the 1984 distribution proceeding would be conducted in two phases. In Phase I, the Tribunal would determine the allocation of cable royalties among various program categories of claimants. The Phase I categories were: Program Suppliers, Sports, Public Broadcasting Service, U.S. Commercial Television, Music, Devotional Programs, Canadian Programs, Noncommercial Radio and Commercial Radio. In Phase II, Tribunal would allocate cable royalties to individual claimants within a program category.
For this 1984 proceeding, there were no controversies in Phase I. All Phase I parties settled based upon the allocations made by the Tribunal in the 1983 cable distribution proceeding. In Phase II, there were three controversies.
Controversy one: The National Broadcasting Company (NBC) is the producer of the television series, "Little House on the Prairie." NBC contracted with Worldvision Enterprises, Inc. (Worldvision) to distribute off-network re-runs of "Little House on the Prairie" to television broadcast stations. The question presented was: Is NBC, the producer, or is Worldvision, the syndicator, entitled to the 1984 cable royalties for "Little House on the Prairie" (The question of the value of "Little House on the Prairie" was stipulated as not in controversy.)
Controversy two: Warner Communications, Inc. (Warner) is a producer and distributor of music videos. Music videos are distributed to either program producers or broadcast stations to be used in music video shows, or individually. The questions presented were: Is Warner entitled to come directly to the Tribunal to advance its claims for the value of its music videos, or is Warner required to seek its share of any cable royalties from the producers or distributors of music video shows in actions on the underlying contract Is the "Night Tracks-Chartbusters" music video show properly classified as part of the 1984 Program Suppliers Phase I category or as part of the 1984 Commercial Television Phase I category (The question of the value of Warner's music videos was stipulated as not in controversy.)
Controversy three: Within the Program Suppliers category, three parties advanced claims which, when combined, exceeded 100% of the category. The Motion Picture Association of America, Inc. (MPAA) claimed 99.3%. Multimedia Entertainment, Inc. (Multimedia) claimed 1.2%. The National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) claimed 0.8%.
Background and Chronology
Seven hundred and fifty (750) individual or joint claims weRe filed with the Tribunal for the 1984 cable royalty fund. On January 30, 1986, the Tribunal published a notice directing claimants to inform the Tribunal by March 3, 1986 whether a controversy existed with regard to the distribution of the 1984 cable copyright royalty fees. 51 FR 3816.
The comments submitted by the claimants generally indicated a desire to wait for the issuance of the Tribunal's determination of the 1983 cable royalty distribution proceeding to ascertain whether a settlement among the parties could be reached. The Tribunal agreed with the claimants, and asked again on May 21, 1986 whether, in light of the Tribunal's 1983 cable distribution determination published April 15, 1986, a controversy existed in the 1984 cable royalty distribution. 51 FR 18646.
Based upon the comments the Tribunal received from its second notice, the Tribunal determined that: (1) There were no controversies as to the distribution of the 1984 basic and 3.75% fund, Phase I; (2) whether there was a controversy as to the 1984 syndex fund, Phase I, would await the outcome of the appeal of the 1983 cable distribution determination; and (3) There existed controversies in one more Phase II program categories. The declaration of the controversies was made effective June 19, 1986. In the same notice, the Tribunal ordered a partial distribution of the 1984 cable royalty fund for June 19, 1986. 51 FR 21587 (June 18, 1986).
On June 24, 1986, the Tribunal ordered those Phase II claimants who had not shown entitlement in previous cable distribution proceedings, and whose claims were unfamiliar to the Tribunal and other parties, to file by August 1, 1986 a brief statement describing the basis for their claims and the facts supporting them. Order, dated June 24, 1986.
Written direct cases were filed by the parties on September 29, 1986. In addition to the three controversies described above, one additional controversy was litigated. In the Music category, Asociation de Compositores y Editores de Musica Latinoamerica (ACEMLA) claimed 5%, and the American Society of Composers, Authors, and Publishers (ASCAP), Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI), and SESAC, Inc. jointly claimed 100%.
Presentation of the Phase II parties' direct cases began on October 21, 1986 and concluded on November 7, 1986 after eight (8) days of hearings. The Phase II written rebuttal cases were filed November 18, 1986. The hearing of the rebuttal cases commenced on December 2, 1986 and concluded on December 10, 1986 after five (5) days of hearings.
On December 22, 1986, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit upheld the Tribunal's decision in the 1983 cable distribution proceeding in all respects. National Association of Broadcasters v. Copyright Royalty Tribunal, Nos. 86-4042, 86-4056, 86-4066 (2d Cir. Dec. 22, 1986). Consequently, no controversy as *8409 to the syndex portion of the 1984 fund, Phase I, was invoked by any party.
The record in the 1984 cable distribution proceeding was closed January 7, 1987.
On January 15, 1987, ACEMLA filed a letter with the Tribunal withdrawing its Phase II claim. The controversy in the Music category which was heard by the Tribunal was rendered moot by ACEMLA's withdrawal.
The parties filed Phase II Proposed Findings of Facts and Conclusions of Law on January 16, 1987. Reply Proposed Findings of Facts and Conclusions of Law were filed on January 27, 1987.
Controversy One: NBC and Worldvision
Findings of Fact
"Little House On The Prairie" ("Little House") is a television series based on several children's books by Laura Ingalls Wilder. Tr. 832. NBC produced 182 episodes of the series which aired in prime-time on the NBC television network from 1974 to 1983. Stipulation, dated November 5, 1986; Tr. 764. The production costs of each episode approached one million dollars, and were paid solely by NBC. Tr. 765. NBC filed for and received a certificate of copyright registration for each episode of "Little House." Stipulation, dated November 5, 1986.
On March 1, 1979, NBC and Worldvision entered into a written agreement for the domestic off-network television distribution of all NBC-produced episodes of "Little House" up to and including the 1980-1981 broadcast season. NBC Ex. 2. On December 1, 1982, NBC and Worldvision entered into another agreement which covered all "Little House" episodes produced for broadcast subsequent to the 1980-1981 broadcast season. NBC Ex. 3. In all material respects, except for the indentity of the episodes covered by each, the 1979 and the 1982 agreements are the same. Tr. 814, 1659-60.
The Contract Terms. The pertinent features of the two NBC-Worldvision contracts are as follows:
NBC transferred and granted to Worldvision "full and exclusive domestic distribution and profit participation rights . . . to the 'Little House on the Prairie' television series" for thirty-five (35) years from the date of first availability. NBC Ex. 2, pp. 1-3; NBC Ex. 3, pp. 1-4.
The rights granted to Worldvision extended "solely to exhibition over conventional free television on other than a national network prime-time basis." NBC Ex. 2, p. 3; NBC Ex. 3, p. 4.
Conversely, the contracts granted no rights to Worldvision, and placed no restriction on NBC "regarding any means of distribution of exhibition other than by conventional free television broadcasts." NBC Ex. 2, pp. 9-10; NBC Ex. 3, p. 12.
The negotiations were conducted in the context of an FCC regulation which states that no television network shall "sell, license, or distribute television programs to television station licensees within the United States for non-network television exhibition or otherwise engage in the business commonly known as 'syndication' within the United States; . . . or reserve any option or right to share in revenues or profits in connection with such domestic . . . sale, license, or distribution." 47 CFR 73.658(j). Consequently, the NBC-Worldvision contracts departed from the customary domestic syndication agreements in which the distributor sells the program product on behalf of the producer, collects the money, takes its distribution fee--a percentage of collections--and remits the balance to the producer. Tr. 929-30, 1038. The NBC-Worldvision agreements were an outright sale based upon a flat price for each episode. Worldvision Ex. 1, p. 3. The actual sale price was not placed into evidence by stipulation of the parties to protect the secrecy of the negotiations, but it was acknowledged that the price was in the millions of dollars. Tr. 981.
The contracts provided for additional payments to NBC in the event that Worldvision's gross collections achieved certain plateaus. Tr. 977-978. At each of five plateaus, $60 million, $70 million, $80 million, $90 million, and $100 million, Worldvision would pay to NBC $5 million. Tr. 979-980. Beyond $100 million in gross collections, Worldvision owed NBC no further payments. Tr. 981-982.
There was no clause in either agreement addressing the status of cable retransmissions under the contracts, or the proper disposition of the cable copyright royalties which the Copyright Royalty Tribunal distributes. NBC Exs. 2, 3.
The rights and obligations of the parties to the agreements are to be determined in accordance with the laws of the state of California. NBC Ex. 2, p. 23; NBC Ex. 3, p. 31.
Testimony as to the intent of the parties. The agreements were negotiated by David Freedman for NBC, and by Neil Delman for Worldvision. Tr. 821, 896-98, 927. The written agreements were drafted by NBC. Tr. 937, 1646. In the negotiations, there were no discussions of the Copywright Royalty Tribunal, or what should happen under the contracts to the royalties distributed by the Tribunal. Tr. 1021.
Susan Beckett, Senior Attorney in NBC's New York law department in 1979, testified that she was part of an Ad Hoc Committee formed by NBC to explore emerging markets and new technologies, and that in the course of the ad Hoc Committee activities, she was asked to review the draft 1979 NBC-Worldvision agreement to assure that NBC's rights to "Little House" were protected with respect to the developing videodisc, videocassette, pay and cable television markets. NBC Direct Testimony of Susan Beckett, pp. 1-2. Ms. Beckett conveyed NBC's concerns about protecting NBC's rights to Bernard Gold, an NBC attorney who was involved in drafting the substantive provisions of the 1979 agreement. Id.
Mr. Beckett stated that the reason the cable retransmission royalties were not specifically excluded when drafting the contracts was that "markets are ever changing, and if one were to attempt to draft a grant of rights provision that specifically stated everything that was being held back, one would probably run a big risk of leaving something out. What we did instead was simply make a very small, very specific grant of rights provision, and limit this very specifically to conventional free television." Tr. 780.
Mr. Delman, Chief Operating Officer of Worldvision, testified that it was his understanding when he was negotiating with Mr. Freedman, that Worldvision was purchasing from NBC all monies. from whatever source, including cable retransmission royalties, which Worldvision received as a consequence of licensing "Little House" to conventional free television. Tr. 895, 928, 1022.
Actions of the parties subsequent to the agreements. The series, "Little House," first became available for off-network distribution on September 15, 1981. Tr. 826; NBC Ex. 2, p.3.
Worldvision's activities under the contracts has been to license commerical television broadcast stations for the exhibition of "Little House." NBC does not allege that Worldvision has negotiated directly with any cable system. Tr. 776-777.
Subsequent to the agreements, Worldvision had not filed any certificate of copyright registration with the Copyright Office for any episode of "Little House." Tr. 1043.
Worldvision was the sole claimant before the Tribunal for cable royalties for "Little House" for calendar years 1981 and 1982. Worldvision merged its claim with the claim of the settled group *8410 of program suppliers represented by MPAA, and derived its awards for 1981 and 1982 from the award made to MPAA. Worldvision Ex. 1, p. 3; Tr. 851, 1632.
For Calendar year 1983, both Worldvision and NBC filed claims for "Little House." Worldvision Ex. 1, p. 3; NBC Ex. 8. NBC did not pursue its claim other than filing, and it did not invoke a controversy against Worldvision. Again, in 1983, Worldvision received royalties for "Little House" through MPAA according to its pre-arranged settlement. Worldvision Ex. 1, P. 3.
For calendar year 1984, NBC has invoked a controversy against Worldvision, but has stipulated that the amount of royalties which Worldvision would receive through MPAA for "Little House" is acceptable to NBC should the Tribunal conclude the controversy in NBC's favor, and therefore, the question of the value of "Little House" is not in controversy. NBC Direct, Introduction, p-p. 3, 10
Worldvision is required to furnish NBC a statement of gross receipts in regard to licensing of "Little House" every six months. NBC Ex. 2, p. 15; NBC Ex. 3, p. 21. Worldvision has included the cable retransmission royalties it has received from the Tribunal in its gross receipts statement to NBC. Tr. 956-57.
Positions of the Parties
NBC
It is NBC's position that NBC is the creator and producer of "Little House," that it is the copyright owner of the entire series, and that it incurred the entire risk with respect to the sums put up for the production of the "Little House" episodes. NBC argues that the legislative history of Section 111 demonstrates that Congress intended to require cable operators to compensate the creators of the programs for the use of those programs. Consequently, in any distribution controversy, it is the creator of the programs who should be favored. NBC cites the Tribunal's 1983 cable determination in which the Tribunal allocated 95.5% of the syndicated exclusivity surcharge royalties to the program suppliers--as against the broadcasters--in support of its position.
NBC would concede that the creator of a program could sell or assign any one of the bundle of rights encompassed by the copyright to another entity, thereby establishing that entity as the proper recipient of cable copyright royalties, but in order for that result to occur, NBC argues that the transfer or assignment must be 1) specific, unambiguous, and clearly intended, and 2) it must be a transfer of the pertinent right. Otherwise, the right to collect cable copyright royalties is retained by the copyright owner.
NBC argues first, that the contracts granted Worldvision the right to distribute to television broadcast stations only, and therefore, NBC retained all other rights, including the right to sell to cable systems. NBC asserts that the compulsory license by which cable systems obtain the right to show "Little House" on distant broadcast signals is a government substitute for the right to sell to cable systems. NBC asserts further that even if one were to find the contract clause granting the distribution right ambiguous, that it is incumbent on the transferee to show the clear transfer, not upon the transferor to show the retention, so that any ambiguity must be resolved in favor of the copyright owner.
NBC argues, second, that the relevant exclusive right for cable royalty distribution is the performance right, and that no where in the contracts is there language showing a conveyance of a public performance right on cable television. NBC asserts that it gave Worldvision a distribution right, and that distribution rights and performance rights are separate and distinct.
Finally, NBC argues that to the extent any ambiguities exist in the contract, it has presented testimony which it believes demonstrate the intent of NBC to retain the right to cable copyright royalties.
Worldvision
It is Worldvision's position that its entitlement to the 1984 cable copyright royalties derives clearly from its contractual agreements and that the contracts are not ambiguous. Worldvision states that under the agreements, it has the exclusive right to distribute "Little House" to free, commercial television, and the right to retain 100% of the profits therefrom after payment of expenses and specific NBC fees. Worldvision argues that there can be no cable retransmission giving rise to compulsory license royalty payments without a primary transmission via a television broadcast station, and therefore cable retransmission royalties legitimately constitute monies derived from distribution to free, commecial television.
Worldvision argues, in addition, that NBC is prohibited by the FCC rules either from engaging directly in syndicating to television broadcast stations, or in participating in the profits from such syndication, so that NBC could not by itself engage in the conduct necessary to give rise to cable royalties, or collect them from some one else. The effect of the FCC syndication rule, Worldvision claims, is to divest NBC of any claim to cable retransmission royalties.
Worldvision believes that the legislative history of Section 111 supports the syndicator as against the producer. Worldvision notes that the general interest in compensating the creators of the program was further identified in the House Report as the ability of the copyright owner to exploit the work in the distant market. The harm to the ability to exploit the work relates directly to Worldvision's activities, not to NBC's. NBC has already received its compensation from Worldvision, and the risk for profit or loss relevant to off-network syndication transferred from NBC to Worldvision with the signing of the agreements.
Worldvision finally argues that should the agreements be considered ambiguous, various rules of contract construction operate in Worldvision's favor. First it is asserted, that, under California law, when, during negotiations, the precise point of contention is not discussed, parol evidence of the intent of the parties is not relevant or permissible. Second, Worldvision argues that California law requires that any ambiguity be resolved against the party who prepared the written documents in this case, NBC. Third, the conduct of NBC subsequent to the agreements, in which it failed to initiate any action to recoup the cable royalties for several years indicates, in Worldvision's view, the conclusion that NBC is now engaged in a belated after-the-fact effort to improve the terms of the contracts.
MPAA, Multimedia, and NAB
MPAA expressed no opinion regarding the NBC-Worldvision controversy. Multimedia and NAB supported NBC, for essentially the same reasons stated by NBC.
Conclusions of law
The 1984 cable copyright royalties for "Little House On The Prairie" should be distributed to Worldvision.
The question before the Tribunal is: as between the producer and the syndicator of a program, who should receive the cable copyright royalties Our analysis of this is based on three general premises: (1) The legislative history of Section 111 of the Copyright Act demonstrates that Congress intended to redress the harm incurred by the syndicators of television programming due to distant signal importation by cable systems; (2) The Tribunal has a responsibility to *8411 ascertain that the party claiming to be the copyright owner of a program, when challenged, is in fact, the actual copyright owner; but that (3) The Tribunal is not the proper forum for the resolution of contract disputes.
Intent of Section 111. Both NBC and Worldvision have cited pertinent sections of the legislative history of Section 111 of the Copyright Act to support different and opposing contentions regarding the intent of Congress. NBC believes that Congress intended to reward the creators of television programs as against all other parties; Worldvision believes Congress intended to reward the syndicators of programs as against all other parties.
"Little House" represents one example of the production, distribution and use of an intellectual property in the television market. "Little House" began as a series of books, which was made into a television series by NBC, distributed by Worldvision after its network run to television stations, and retransmitted by cable systems to the systems' subscribers. Thus the distribution chain of "Little House" can be summarized: Author--Network producer--Off-network distributor--television exhibitor--cable exhibitor.
It is our understanding of the legislative history that when Congress spoke of imposing upon cable systems an obligation to compensate the creators of television programming, it was speaking in terms of the owners of the programming (author-network producer-off-network distributor) versus the users of the programming (television exhibitor-cable exhibitor). [FN1] Conversely, we do not believe that Congress, by using the word "creator" was intending to indicate a preference among or between the owners of the programming.
FN1 For example, Congress stated, "[i] in general, the committee believes that cable systems are commercial enterprises whose basic retransmission operations are based on the carriage of copyrighted program material and that copyright royalties should be paid by cable operators to the creators of such programs. H.R. Rep. No. 94-1476, 94th Congress, 2d Sess., 89 (1976).
Where we do see a preference indicated by Congress, is in passages in the legislative history where the particular harm being redressed is identified:
The retransmission of distant non-network programing by cable systems causes damage to the copyright owner by distributing the program to an area beyond which it has been licensed. Such retransmission adversely affects the ability of the copyright owner to exploit the work in the distant market." H.R. Rep. No. 94-1476, 94th Cong., 2d Sess. 89 (1976).
Those who were the syndicators of television programs were the ones most directly harmed by the distant signal importation by cable systems without compensation because they could not orderly control the marketing of their product.
The Tribunal has consistently understood this to be the essential reason for Section 111 and has, twice, citing legislative history, determined to award royalties to the suppliers of programs as against the television exhibitors of programs. 1978 Cable Royalty Distribution Proceeding, 45 FR 63026 (1980); 1983 Cable Royalty Distribution Proceeding, 51 FR 12792 (1986).
This current proceeding is the first proceeding where a controversy between the producer and the syndicator of a television product has been presented. Consequently, we state that the Tribunal identifies the exclusive syndicator of off-network programming, among all those parties in the chain of production and distribution, as the party to whom the Tribunal has in the past and will consistently in the future distribute Section 111 royalties.
We believe this ruling assures an orderly marketplace because the above-described intent of Section 111 has been the general industry understanding since the creation of the Tribunal. We also believe that equitably, as well, the royalties should go to Worldvision, because Worldvision reimbursed NBC entirely for their interest in off-network syndication and whatever harm that might result from the successful exploitation of "Little House" in the off-network syndication market due to cable distant signal importation became entirely Worldvision's to bear.
This ruling does not foreclose the syndicator from remitting the cable copyright royalties up or down the chain of production and distribution pursuant to private contractual arrangement. A syndicator is free to promise royalties to the producer of the program or to the television exhibitor of the program as the parties to the contract see fit.
Ascertainment that the party is the actual copyright owner. The authority of the Tribunal under Section 111 is to distribute cable copyright royalties to copyright owners whose works were subject to secondary transmissions by cable systems. 17 U.S.C. 111(d)(3). Accordingly, the Tribunal may not award royalties to persons who are not copyright owners, and the Court of Appeals has indicated that the Tribunal's task includes examination of good-faith challenges to copyright ownership. National Association of Broadcasters v. Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 772 F. 2d 922, 937 (D.C. Cir. 1985), cert. denied, 106 S. Ct. 1245 (1986).
NBC claims that it is the copyright owner of "Little House" and that the agreements it entered into with Worldvision did not convey to Worldvision the relevant copyright for the purpose of receiving cable copyright royalties.
Regarding NBC's challenge, we conclude the following: Worldvision is the exclusive domestic off-network distributor to television broadcast stations of the television series, "Little House" pursuant to the grant from NBC in the two NBC-Worldvision agreements. The cable retransmissions of "Little House" occurred directly from the actions of Worldvision in licensing television stations. Although NBC claims no performing right was conveyed, it of necessity must have been conveyed because that is what Worldvision licensed the television broadcast stations to do, i.e., to perform "Little House," and that was the basis for the multimillion dollar compensation to NBC. Although Worldvision has not registered any copyright in "Little House," registration is not a prerequisite to collect cable copyright royalties, and the failure to register is not evidence that a copyright was not conveyed. Consequently, we find Worldvision is the proper party to claim royalties for "Little House."
Tribunal is not the proper forum for contract disputes. Both parties have stipulated that Worldvision is the exclusive syndicator to television stations of "Little House" which gave rise to the cable retransmission royalties in controversy. Beyond assuring ourselves of this point, the Tribunal has chosen not to delve any further into the contractual arrangements between NBC and Worldvision.
As a matter of policy, the Tribunal does not consider that it is the proper forum for the resolution of contract disputes. The Tribunal's experience and expertise lies in distribution determinations and ratesetting. The Tribunal does not see its task as requiring it to analyze and construe private contracts, governed as they are by state law.
Consequently, we simply hold that the Tribunal has determined that Worldvision, as the syndicator of "Little House," is the proper distributee of the 1984 cable copyright royalties. We specifically decline to rule on questions of the meaning of contract terms or the intent of the parties. We leave to private litigation whether the proper construction of the two NBC-Worldvision agreements imposes any *8412 obligation on Worldvision to remit royalties to NBC, or whether the actual terms used in the contracts fail to convey to Worldvision the pertinent copyright for cable royalty distribution. We also decline to reach Worldvision's contention that FCC rules prohibit NBC from collecting cable copyright royalties; our decision has been rendered on other grounds.
Controversy Two: Warner Communications, Inc.
Findings of Fact
The claimant. A joint claim for 1984 cable copyright royalties was fined by Warner Communications, Inc., Elektra/Asylum/Nonesuch Records, Atlantic Recording Corporation, Warner Bros. Records, Inc., and Geffen Records (collectively, Warner, or the Warner record companies.) Claim No. 346, filed July 25, 1985.
Atlantic Recording Corporation and Warner Bros. Records, Inc. are each wholly-owned subsidiaries of Warner Communications, Inc. Elektra/Asylum/Nonesuch Records is a separate division of Warner Communications, Inc. Geffen Records is a joint venture in which one of the co-venturers in Warner Bros. Records, Inc. Warner Direct Testimony of David Altschul, p. 3.
The principal business of the Warner record companies is the production and distribution of records. Since the early 1980's, Warner has become involved in the production and distribution of music videos for exhibition on television broadcast stations. Id., p. 4. In addition to the above-named companies, Warner Bros. Records, Inc. has also produced and distributed music videos under the name of Sire Records. Atlantic Recording Corporation has done the same under the name Atco Records. Id., p. 3.
The principal purpose of music videos has been to promote the recording artists and the sale of records. Id., p. 8. According to the "CVC Video Reports," a trade publication reporting on the music video business, Warner videos accounted, on average, for approximately one-quarter of the top music videos aired during 1984 by the broadcast and cable services surveyed. Id., p. 5.
Nature of music video production. In nearly all instances in the music industry, the contract between the recording artist and the record company authorizes the record company to arrange the production of music videos which involve that artist. All rights in the music video vest with the recording company. Id., p. 6.
Unless it has in-house capability, the record company commissions independent production companies to produce the videos. Id. The relationship between the record company and the producer of a music video is one of commissioning a "work made for hire." The costs of the music video is borne by the record company, and the copyright ownership in the music video is retained by the record company. Id., pp. 6-7. Warner Bros. Records has generally paid between $25,000 and $150,000 to produce each music video, with an average cost in the range of $60,000 to $75,000. Id., p. 6.
Music videos have an average running time of three to five minutes. Id., p. 5. Warner's claim before the Tribunal is that a music video is a short ''audiovisual work" or "motion picture" as these terms are used in the Copyright Act, and that it owns the copyright in the non-music audiovisual portions of the music video. Warner does not claim any interest in the copyright to the musical composition contained in the music video. Id., p. 5, p. 7.
Means of distribution. In 1984, Warner licensed its music videos to over 100 different producers of music video shows carried over broadcast stations and/or cable systems. Id., p. 7.
In some instances, Warner granted licenses directly to the television stations, which produce music video shows, or use the videos individually as fillers between programs. Id., p. 8; Tr. 131.
In other cases, the licenses were granted to independent productions companies. These companies produce music video shows, using Warner videos and videos from other record companies, which are then distributed to and broadcast over one or more television stations. Id., p. 8; Tr. 196.
Warner does not produce or distribute its own music video shows. Tr. 196. Warner believes that the consumer is not interested in just seeing Warner videos, but want a variety of all the successful and popular videos available at the time. Id.
In 1984, Warner granted licenses for non-network broadcast use of the music videos to the producers/distributors and to the television stations without charge, in order to achieve its principal business purpose of promoting record sales. Warner Direct, Testimony of David Atlschul, p. 8. The licenses Warner granted to the producers/distributors and to the television stations were non-exclusive licenses, i.e., Warner retained the right to license the use of the same music video to anyone else in any market in chose. Id., p. 9; Tr. 135. The means of distribution that Warner uses are standard practice in the industry. Tr. 136.
Seven specific music video shows. Warner identified seven specific music video shows to which it limits its 1984 cable royalty claim, and based upon which it seeks a ruling from the Tribunal on its entitlement to come directly before the Tribunal. Warner Ex. 3; Tr. 94. However, by agreement, the value of Warner's claims is not at issue in this proceeding. Warner/MPAA/NAB Stipulation, dated Dec. 5, 1986.
The common feature of these seven shows is that these shows consist almost exclusively of music videos, and are characterized in the industry as "wall-to-wall" music video, shows. Warner Direct, Testimony of David Altschul, p. 10. The other elements of these programs which are not music videos, but which are contributions of the program producers are: the introductory and closing graphics, the voice-overs to introduce the music videos, and the breaks to commercials. Tr. 139, 144-146. One exception to this description among the seven programs is "America Rock/Hit City" which has some interview sequences with the musical artists. Consequently, music videos constitute approximately 80 percent of the running time of "America Rock/Hit City." Tr. 140.
Individually, the pertinent features of the seven shows are as follows:
"Night Tracks" was produced by Lynch-Billar Productions solely for airing on WTBS, Atlanta, every Friday and Saturday night in 1984. Warner Ex. 3; Tr. 200. Warner dealt with and supplied Lynch-Billar Productions only. Warner did not deal with WTBS. Tr. 201. During approximately the first half of 1984, "Night Tracks" was broadcast six hours per night, from midnight to 6:00 a.m. Midway through the year, an additional hour was added from 11:00 p.m. until midnight. This segment of "Night Tracks" was referred to as "Chartbusters," and it aired the "top 10" music videos of the week. Warner Ex. 3. WTBS claims for "Night Tracks/Chartbusters" in the 1984 cable distribution proceeding. Tr. 414-417.
"Top 40 Videos" is produced by Hunt-Jaffe Productions. It is a weekly 30 minute show, which was syndicated to five television stations in 1984 by Columbia Pictures Television (CPT). "Top 40 Videos" is claimed by CPT in the 1984 cable royalty distribution proceeding. Warner Ex. 3; Tr. 484-5, 703.
"New York Hot Tracks" is a weekly 90 minute show produced by WABC-TV in New York, and syndicated by Golden West Television Productions (Golden West). Golden West claims "New York *8413 Hot Tracks" in the 1984 cable royalty distribution proceeding. Warner Ex. 3; Letter from Golden West Television Productions, dated November 14, 1986.
"Great Record Album Collection," "Houghton & Wirth," and "Gavin & Lott" are weekly shows of varying duration produced by the Music Magazine Foundation and syndicated to more than 50 television broadcast stations. Warner Ex. 3. Neither the producer nor the syndicator has filed a claim for these programs in the 1984 cable royalty distribution proceeding. Tr. 478, 711.
"America Rocks/Hit City" is a weekly show of varying lengths produced by Monument Productions, Inc., and syndicated to approximately 25 television broadcast stations. Warner Ex. 3. Neither the producer nor the syndicator has filed a claim for these programs in the 1984 cable royalty distribution proceeding. Tr. 487, 711.
MPAA Practices. MPAA represents a settled group of 86 program supplies. After receiving its overall allocation from the Tribunal in each cable distribution proceeding, MPAA makes an internal distribution of cable royalties to its settled group of 86 program suppliers based upon its own distribution formula. MPAA Direct, Exs. 1, 2.
Pursuant to its function of making its own internal distributions, MPAA categorizes television programs as to whether MPAA believes, on the basis of the Tribunal precedent, that they are within the program suppliers category or some other category. If MPAA makes a determination that a program is properly within the program suppliers category, it will make an internal distribution of royalties based upon that program. MPAA Direct, Testimony of Marsha Kessler, pp. 2-8; Tr. 413-416.
Warner asserts that there are certain program suppliers within MPAA's group who distribute their products in ways similar to Warner's distribution of music videos, and who receive internal distributions from MPAA. Warner, therefore, asserts, these internal MPAA practices are a basis for recognizing Warner's entitlement to receive royalties. Warner Proposed Findings, paras. 29-30. These similar cases are as follows:
Short-length cartoons--Sometimes, short-length cartoons are supplied to local broadcasters from diferent syndications. The local broadcasters compile the various cartoons into a local show, such as "Funtime," broadcast over WTBS-TV. Tr. 428-429, 493-495. In such cases, MPAA categorizes such programs as syndicated programs. and distributes a portion of the royalties it has received from the Tribunal directly to the copyright owners of the short-length cartoons. Tr. 403-404, 703. MPAA does not deny internal distributions to cartoon copyright owners on the basis that these shows were locally produced. Id.
"PM Magazine"--Group W Productions supplies the syndicated portions of "PM Magazine" to television stations in various markets, and in each market, the local station packages the syndicated elements together with local talent and local seqments. Tr. 450-455. MPAA categorizes "PM Magazine" as syndicated programs and makes internal distributions to Group W Productions based upon "PM Magazine." Id.
Locally hosted movie programs--sometimes, packages of movies within the same genre are compiled by local stations, and are locally hosted with segments produced by the television stations, such as "Elvira." MPAA categorizes "Elvira" as a syndicated program and internal distributions according to the ownership of the actual movies shown. Tr. 407, 518-519.
MPAA witness Marsha Kessler testified that MPAA classifies short-length cartoons which appear in station-produced shows as syndicated because cartoons are not distributed individually, but as a package of 100 or more cartoons, and that these packages are listed in the BIB book as a syndicated product available for purchase. Tr. 408, 421. In addition, national rating publications, ROSP for the Nielsen Company, and SPA for the Arbitron Company, list these packages and give audience viewing data. Tr. 421. Similarly, "PM Magazine" is listed in the BIB book as available for syndication and its viewing data is listed in ROSP and SPA. Tr. 423.
Certain music video shows are listed in the BIB book. Tr. 425. MPAA recognizes them as syndicated, and would make an internal distribution to the syndicator of that program, such as CPT or Golden West, and not to Warner. Tr. 700.
Classification of "Night Tracks/Chartbusters." In the 1983 cable royalty distribution proceeding, "Night Tracks/Chartbusters" was originally listed by the Program Suppliers/MPAA in Phase I as a syndicated program. Program Suppliers 1983 Ph. I Direct, Ex. 21. At the close of the 1983 Phase I proceeding, MPAA reclassified "Night Tracks/Chartbusters" as belonging in the Commercial Television category, and deleted the program from its Phase II program listing. MPAA 1983 Ph. II Ex. 13. In this proceeding, MPAA has again classified "Night Tracks/Chartbusters" as a locally-produced program within the Commercial Television category. Tr. 415.
Positions of the Parties
Warner
It is Warner's position that it is entitled to come directly before the Tribunal to advance its claim for cable copyright royalties.
Copyright Ownership. Warner argues, first, that against all other parties in the production and distribution of music videos, it is the relevant copyright owner to receive cable royalties. Vis-a-vis the recording artist and the music video production companies, Warner has contracted for the copyright in the music video. Vis-a-vis the producers of music video shows, Warner has extended only a nonexclusive license to use its music videos, which, Warner notes, according to Section 101 of the Copyright Act, does not constitute a transfer of copyright ownerhip. Therefore, Warner asserts, it is the only proper distributee of royalties attributable to the secondary transmission of its music videos.
Components of programs v. complete program. Responding to the position of other parties that music videos are merely components of a program and that the Tribunal, by precedent, does not consider directly program components, Warner argues that music videos are complete programs in and of themselves. Each music video, according to Warner, is a separate audiovisual work, requiring the same creative contributions as a full-length movie and entitled to the same copyright protection as a full-length movie.
Warner acknowledges that music videos are short, averaging about 3 to 5 minutes in length, but Warner believes the difference in the running time of audiovisual works has no significance for copyright purposes. Warner, therefore, considers its legal position the same as that of a locally hosted movie program in which the individual movies are not considered components of the entire program, but complete programs themselves.
Warner especially relies on MPAA's internal treatment of cartoons, whose running time are directly comparable to Warner's music videos. Warner notes that the suppliers of these cartoons get direct compensation from MPAA, and thus MPAA's own policies support Warner's position.
Other parties in the chain of distribution. Warner disagrees with the Phase II parties who argue that the Tribunal should distribute whatever cable royalties pertain to the syndicator *8414 or local station producer of the music video shows, instead of to Warner, and that Warner's compensation, if any, should derive from the contractual agreements it enters into with the syndicator or local station producer.
Warner notes that there are two separate copyrights under consideration before the Tribunal: Warner's copyright in the music videos, and the syndicators/station producer's copyright in the music video show.
Warner states that each music video show consists overwhemingly of a series of separate music videos which are supplied by, and the copyright in which is owned by, Warner and a variety of other record companies. If the music video shows are copyrightable at all, Warner argues, they are copyrightable as compilation works only.
Warner believes that the Tribunal should directly consider the valuation of both the copyright owners of the music videos and the copyright owners of the music video shows. Warner believes that the Tribunal should not award the copyright owners of the music video shows alone for the entire value of the show, and leave Warner to its contract remedies, because, the Warner's view, the entire value of the wall-to-wall music video shows lie in the music videos themselves, and any allocation of royalties attributable to Warner's music videos to the producers of the shows would, therefore, be an expansion of the producers' copyright interest in the shows.
Warner also believes that in all other pertinent situations, such as locally-hosted movie programs, locally compiled cartoon shows, and "PM Magazine," the parties and the Tribunal recognize that the syndicated elements of the shows merit direct consideration.
Classification of "Night Tracks/Chartbusters." Consequently, Warner argues that programs like, "Night Tracks/Chartbusters," which consist primarily of syndicated programs and only a minor amount a station-produced content should be classified by the Tribunal as a syndicated program.
MPAA, NAB and Multimedia
It is the position of MPAA, NAB and Multimedia that Warner should not be entitled to come directly before the Tribunal to advance its claim for cable copyright royalties. These three parties do not dispute Warner's copyright ownership or that Warner might ultimately deserve some share of the royalties which are attributable to music video shows. Their view is only that Warner should seek its compensation through its contractual arrangements with the syndicator and/or local station producer, rather than directly from the Tribunal.
Components of a program. The three parties argue that although music videos may be copyrightable works under the Copyright Act, they are only components of the television broadcast programs that are retransmitted by cable systems. They cite as the applicable precedent, the Tribunal's 1978 cable distribution decision to give no award to the copyright owners of cartoon characters on the ground that cartoon characters are mere components of a program.
All three parties argue that the Tribunal's policy against directly considering the claims of the owners of components of a program should continue to apply. Reversing the Tribunal's cartoon character precedent of many years' standing, it is feared, would throw open the doors to a multitude of new claimants who could potentially force the Tribunal into another layer of allocation decisions, possibly a "Phase III," which would be unwieldly and unsatisfactory in its results.
Additionally, NAB disagrees with Warner's contention that because Warner retains the copyright in its music videos that it must be considered directly by the Tribunal. NAB notes the same could be true for an author of a poem which is recited on a television program, and states that it believes that the policy to cut off claims at the program level is within the Tribunal's discretion, and leaving the owners of retransmitted program components to collect royalties from program owners is the most rational course.
Other parties in the chain of distribution. The three parties believe the Tribunal should make its distribution to the syndicator and/or the local station producer of the music video shows and should direct Warner to obtain whatever compensation it believes it should receive from the music video show copyright owners.
The parties disagree with Warner that wall-to-wall video shows, such as the seven programs Warner described in its direct case, are the only consideration before the Tribunal. MPAA and NAB allege that Warner put forward only the wall-to-wall video shows to convince the Tribunal that rewarding the compiler rather than the underlying copyright owner would be putting the cart before the horse. However, both MPAA and NAB argue that wall-to-wall video shows are only one end of the spectrum. Videos might constitute 80% of a program, 50% of a program, 10% of a program, etc. NAB fears that granting a music video owner entitlement to come directly before the Tribunal would have them claiming for segments of videos used in news or entertainment programs. MPAA cites the need in Tribunal procedures for bright line tests, and believes that making its distribution only to program owners is a policy that works well.
MPAA claims that its internal distribution procedures are not inconsistent with its proposed policy regarding Warner. With regard to cartoons, MPAA states that if a producer of cartoons licensed a syndicator of a cartoon show, it would internally distribute to the syndicator, leaving the producer to negotiate with the syndicator. In the case of cartoons directly supplied to local broadcast stations, MPAA believes that the cartoon producer should be compensated rather than the local station compiler of the cartoons for reasons it believes are distinguished from music videos. Cartoons are generally packaged in groups of 100 or more, and are listed in industry books as available for syndication. They receive national ratings as syndicated programs. MPAA believes this is evidence of a general industry understanding that cartoon packages are syndicated programs in and of themselves.
NAB's position on short-length cartoons is different from MPAA's. NAB believes that MPAA's internal distribution scheme with respect to locally compiled cartoons is an example of the marketplace making its own arrangements, and should be respected in light of the Tribunal's policy encouraging private settlements, but that if the owners of the cartoons were to make a claim directly to the Tribunal for a separate royalty award, they, too, should be denied.
Classification of "Night Tracks/Chartbusters" MPAA believes that "Night Tracks/Chartbusters" should be properly classified in the Commercial Television category consistent with the Tribunal's definition of a commercial television program issued last year.
NAB believes that "Night Tracks/Chartbusters" should be classified as a syndicated series within the Program Suppliers category for the 1984 proceeding. NAB notes that "Night Tracks/Chartbusters" was initially categorized by MPAA as a syndicated program in the 1983 Phase I proceeding and remained so when the Tribunal reached its 1983 Phase I percentage allocations. In the 1984 Phase I proceeding, all parties agreed to settle for the same awards they received in the 1983 Phase I proceeding, and NAB believes that equity demands that a *8415 program be categorized consistently in Phase I and Phase II of any single proceeding. NAB does not take a position on the proper categorization of "Night Tracks/Chartbusters" for future Tribunal proceedings.
Multimedia believes that "Night Tracks/Chartbusters" should be classified as a syndicated series within the program Suppliers category for the same reasons as those stated by NAB.
Conclusions of Law
Warner is entitled to come directly before the Tribunal to advance its claim for cable copyright royalties
Our analysis of whether Warner is entitled to come directly before the Tribunal proceeds from the agreed-upon point that Warner is the copyright owner of music videos which have been retransmitted by cable systems. Therefore, the question is, are there any policy reasons within the Tribunal's discretion for denying Warner direct access to Tribunal proceedings
In the 1978 cable royalty distribution proceeding, the owners of such cartoon characters as Bugs Bunny, Miss Piggy, Kermit the Frog, Big Bird, Superman, and Bozo the Clown claimed a right to cable copyright royalties by virtue of their being copyrighted components of programs. 1978 Cable Royalty Distribution Determination, 45 FR 63026, 63031 (1980). The Tribunal stated:
(W)e have concluded that our awarding cable royalties to the Character claimants would not be consistent with the general scheme adopted by Congress in section 111. We conclude that the Congress did not contemplate this Tribunal awarding royalty fees to the copyright owners of individual components of programs. As was noted during the oral argument of this issue, approval of this claim might well require the Tribunal to award fees to authors of screen plays and novels that were adapted into programs. We are satisfied that Congress did not intend such a result. Id., at 63033.
We continue to hold to our ruling rendered in the 1978 proceeding, but we have been persuaded by Warner that music videos, unlike cartoon characters, are complete program units in and of themselves. They can be considered individual programs, just as individual cartoons are which are compiled by local stations, and just as feature-length movies are which are compiled into locally-hosted television programs.
The next question for us to determine is whether some other party in the distribution chain is the more proper distributee of whatever cable royalties are attributable to music videos. Here, there are two features to the music video controversy which are distinct from the NBC-Worldvision controversy. One, Warner has retained the full copyright in its music videos, giving only a nonexclusive license to those who distribute and use it, whereas NBC assigned an exclusive distribution right to Worldvision. Second, the NBC-Worldvision controversy has as its subject matter one copyrighted property, "Little House," whereas in the music video controversy, there are two copyrighted properties--Warner's music videos, and the syndicator's or local station's music video shows.
Warner argues that solely because it has retained it copyright, the Tribunal must consider it directly, and may not distribute royalties attributable to its music video to any other party. We do not agree with Warner on that point. Rather, we side more with NAB which believes that the Tribunal has discretion to order its proceedings along rational lines so long as all those involved have an opportunity in the marketplace to adjust their interests accordingly. To agree with Warner on this point would ultimately require the Tribunal to consider every copyrightable interest, such as poems and cartoon characters, leading to a proliferation of claims that would be unmanageable and beyond our resources.
But the fact that Warner has retained its copyright does give Warner a more persuasive argument that it should be considered directly, and we now look to whether, on balance, the Tribunal should consider both the copyright owners of music videos and music video shows, or only the owners of music video shows.
The seven music video shows which Warner has put into evidence are illustrative of three different situations. In the case of "Night Tracks/Chartbusters," the music videos are supplied by Warner directly to the production company commissioned by the local broadcast station. In analogous situations, such as cartoons and "PM Magazine" and locally-hosted movie shows, MPAA, internally, has considered these as syndicated programs entitled to direct compensation. Although to this point, the Tribunal has never been called upon to consider the validity of this categorization, we agree that MPAA's practice is appropriate. [FN2] We do not agree that MPAA's attempted distinctions between cartoons and music videos are valid. Therefore, where Warner supplies a local television station directly, it seems appropriate to consider directly both claims, the syndicators in the music video, and the local station's in the music video show.
FN2 See, also, 1983 Cable Royalty Distribution Proceeding, 51 FR 12792, at 12815, where NAB asserted only an interest in the "wrap around" portions of the "Elvira" series, not in the movies contained therein.
In the case of "Top 40 Videos" and "New York Hot Tracks," Warner supplied its videos to a program producer who in turn contracted with a syndicator to distribute music video show. The syndicators, Columbia Pictures Television, and Golden West Television Productions have filed claims for the music video shows. However, in the case of "Great Record Album Collection," "Houghton & Wirth," "Garvin & Lott," and "America Rocks/Hit City," the distribution from Warner is the same, but the syndicator has not filed a claim for the music video shows. These last four instances illustrate that to deny Warner the right to come directly before the Tribunal would be to deny Warner's claim for the use of its music videos in these four shows entirely. We believe that as reasonable as it may be for the Tribunal to establish rational points in the distribution chain where it will consider and valuate works, the recommended policy of the parties would work unfairly toward Warner who would have to rely upon another party to file timely, or othewise lose its claim.
We recognize the force of the arguments of MPAA, NAB and Multimedia who fear a multitude of new claimants and more and more difficult allocation decisions. We emphasize that our holding is that where a music video is shown in its entirety, i.e., that is a complete program, and the copyright is retained entirely by the music video producer, the owner's claim is considered part of the Program Suppliers category, and may come directly to the Tribunal. If there are any controversies between the music video owner and the copyright owner of the music video shows, those controversies will be addressed in Phase II. Consequently, a segment of a music video, such as those seen on news and entertainment programs, comes under our ruling on components of programming, and would not be a part of the claim of any music video copyright owner.
In addition, the example of a poem which NAB raises would not be considered directly by the Tribunal because it is not a program, i.e., it requires additional creative contributions, such as a performer, and is not a complete unit in and of itself.
*8416 We emphasize that we have been careful not to state whether the copyright ownership in the non-musical audiovisual portions of the music video has a quantifiable value or is de minimis. That question was not litigated in this proceeding, and we do not reach it here.
"Night Tracks/Chartbusters" is properly classified as a syndicated program with the Program Suppliers category
Shortly after the Tribunal published its 1983 cable royalty distribution determination, the Program Suppliers moved the Tribunal to issue declaratory rulings regarding Phase I program categorizations. Pursuant to their request and comments received from the Joint Sports Claimants, NAB and Multimedia, the Tribunal issued an advisory opinion on May 16, 1986. The opinion stated, among other things, that: (1) syndicated series and specials within the Program Suppliers category are "programs licensed to/produced by and broadcast by two or more broadcast stations during the calendar year in question," and (2) local programs within the Commercial Television category are "programs licensed to/produced by and broadcast by a single broadcast station during the calendar year in question."
In response to a request by the Phase I parties to facilitate a settlement agreement for the 1984 Phase I proceeding, the Tribunal modified its advisory opinion to provide that, "for purposes of the 1984 Proceeding, programs syndicated to and broadcast by only one U.S. commercial television station during 1984, which were not produced by or for that station, will be treated as part of the 'syndicated program' allocation, not the 'local program allocation.' " Notice Commencing 1984 Cable Distribution Proceeding, 51 FR 21587 (June 18, 1986).
The purpose of this modification was to allow for those instances where the syndicator of a television program was successful in syndicating his or her program to only one station in the U.S. We agreed with the parties that the modification should apply to the 1984 distribution proceeding, and we now state that the modification is adopted for subsequent proceedings as well.
It appears from a review of the record developed during the hearing of the music video controversy, that an addition to the program category definitions is warranted. We have seen that there are a number of programs, although produced locally by the commercial television station, are comprised "wall-to-wall" of syndicated elements, such that it has been MPAA's practice to consider them syndicated programs and to make internal distributions accordingly. We agree that MPAA's practice is appropriate, and we therefore believe that "Night Tracks/Chartbusters" is properly classified as a syndicated program within the Program Suppliers category.
The modified definitions of syndicated series and of local programs are as follows. Syndicated series and specials within the Program Suppliers category are 1) programs licensed to and broadcast by at least one commercial television station during the calendar year in question; 2) programs produced by or for a broadcast station and which is broadcast by two or more broadcast stations during the calendar year in question; 3) programs produced by or for a broadcast station which are comprised predominantly of syndicated elements, such as music video shows, cartoon shows, "PM Magazine," and locally-hosted movie shows. Local programs within the Commercial Television category are programs produced by or for one commecial television station, broadcast by that one station only in the calendar year in question and not coming within the exceptions described in (3) of the Program Suppliers definition.
Controversy Three: MPAA, Multimedia and NAB
4Findings of Fact
The claimants. MPAA is a trade association which represents 86 producers and/or syndicators of syndicated movies, television series and specials. MPAA Ex. 2. Collectively, the 86 claimants seek the cable royalties attributable to 5,796 different syndicated series, movies and specials which were retransmitted by cable systems in 1984. MPAA Ex. 4; Tr. 665.
Multimedia is the producer and syndicator of the following programs: "Donahue"--260 hours of news/interview programs, including 210 original programs, and 50 repeats in 1984; "Sally Jessy Raphael"--175 half-hours of interview/talk programs; "Pop! Goes the Country"--26 half-hour country music programs; "Music City U.S.A."--26 half-hour country music programs; "Austin City Limits"--10 half-hour country music programs; "Young People Specials"--10 half-hour children's features (five original and five repeats); "Music and Entertainment Specials"--25 prime-time country music specials in 1984 (ten original and fifteen repeats). Multimedia/owned television broadcast stations also produced and distributed a weekly half-hour information program--"Georgia Farm Monitor," four coaches/interview shows, and a half-hour Christmas special. Multimedia Direct, Testimony of Richard Thrall, pp. 3-4; Tr. 257- 261, 237.
NAB is a trade association which represents 59 television broadcast stations. Collectively, the 59 stations seek the cable royalties attributable to 121 programs which the stations produced and which were syndicated to and broadcast on other stations in 1984. NAB Ex. II-2; Tr. 320-322; Tr. 337.
The Nielsen Study. As a part of its case for several distribution proceedings, MPAA has commissioned a special Nielsen study to prove its entitlement. 47 FR 9880; 48 FR 9554; 51 FR 12794. The study measures the number of hours of distant signal programming which are viewed by cable households. Id.
For this proceeding, MPAA selected to be included in the Nielsen study all U.S. commercial and noncommercial television broadcast stations reaching a minimum average of 100,000 Form 3 cable television households per six month period, or 200,000 for the first and second semiannual periods of 1984 combined. MPAA Direct, Testimony of Allen Cooper, p. 2. A total of 123 stations met MPAA's criteria: 63 network-affiliated stations, 40 independent stations (including 2 foreign language stations), and 20 noncommercial stations. MPAA excluded from its Phase II direct case the results derived from the 20 noncommercial stations because they were not considered relevant to an analysis of the Program Suppliers category. Id. The Nielsen study was comprised of six cycle data, that is, data collected at six different times of the year, January, February, May, July, October and November. MPAA Ex. 1, Memorandum, p. 2.
In the 1983 cable distribution proceeding, the Tribunal criticized MPAA's decision not to include in its Nielsen study certain types of programs such as parades, political programs, minor sports programs, programs on speciality stations, and programs syndicated on commonly-owned stations. 51 FR 12817. In this proceeding, MPAA designed its study to include the above-described categories of programs. MPAA Direct, Testimony of Marsha Kessler, p. 3.
The household viewing hours attributable to the programs of each of the three Program Supplier claimants were:
MPAA ................. 2,381,600,000 (approx.) 99.329%
NAB ................................ 9,714,260 0.405
Multimedia ......................... 6,376,193 0.266
*8417 MPAA Direct, Testimony of Allen Cooper, p. 3, revised; MPAA Exs. R-1, R-11.
The comparable Nielsen statistics for 1983 were:
MPAA ................. 2,217,169,720 99.197%
NAB ...................... 9,954,010 0.445
Multimedia ............... 7,998,202 0.358
51 FR 12816.
Among Multimedia-owned shows, "Donahue" improved from 5,037,016 household viewing hours in 1983 to 5,397,397 household viewing hours in 1984, or approximately 7.2%. MPAA Ex. R-1. The remaining Multimedia-owned shows, inclusive of the newly-offered "Sally Jessy Raphael," however, declined from 2,961,186 household viewing hours to 988,424 household viewing hours, or 66.6% Id.
Challenges to ownership. MPAA and NAB disputed the ownership of three programs, "The Dance Show," "Fight Back with David Horowitz," and "Miller's Court." NAB Ex. II-2; MPAA Rebuttal, Testimony of Allen Cooper, p. 14. The stations producing these programs stated in the questionnaires which they returned to NAB that they had not transferred their copyright interests and were thus the copyright owners of the programs. NAB Ex. II-1. MPAA, on the other hand, asserted that it represented the syndicators of those programs. TR. 583-589. NAB stipulated that MPAA represents the syndicators of the three programs. NAB Reply Findings, p. 7, fn. 16. The total viewing hours of these shows in the Nielsen study were 159.507. MPA Ex. R-11.
Multimedia asserted that 20 titles which MPAA claims to represent are actually in the public domain. Multimedia Rebuttal, Testimony of Richard Thrall, pp. 5-7. Those twenty titles are: "Popeye," "Lone Ranger," "Perils of Pauline," "My Man Godfrey," "My Dear Secretary," "Made for Each Other," "Terror By Night," "The Strange Love of Martha Ivers," "Laurel & Hardy," "The Stranger," "The Thirty-Nine Steps," "Tarzan and the Green Goddess," "Tarzan the Fearless," "Tarzan's New Adventure," "The Ape," "Angel and the Badman," "The Snows of Kilimanjaro," "The Fallen Idol," "Meet John Doe," and "His Girl Friday." Multimedia Rebuttal Ex. 7.
Of the 20 titles, MPAA had previously disclaimed one of them, "Meet John Doe," and had deleted the household viewing hours from its calculations prior to Multimedia's challenge. MPAA Ex. 4, addition.
Multimedia's challenge to the ownership of "Popeye," purported to show that copyrights to 12 episodes of "Popeye" had not been renewed. Multimedia Rebuttal, Testimony of Richard Thrall, p. 6; Multimedia Rebuttal, Testimony of Richard Thrall, p. 6; Multimedia Rebuttal Ex. 5. There are 674 separate "Popeye" cartoons available for syndication. MPAA Ex. 31 RX. Multimedia could not state whether any of the 12 cartoons which it challenges were broadcast in 1984 or whether they accounted for any viewing hours. Tr. 1519.
Multimedia restated its challenge to the ownership of "Lone Ranger," based upon the 1983 record. Multimedia Rebuttal, Testimony of Richard Thrall, p. 5. In the 1983 proceeding, the Tribunal found that there were 14 episodes of the "Lone Ranger" for which no renewal registration could be found, but that there were 182 half-hour "Lone Ranger" episodes in the MPAA claim. 51 FR 12816.
Regarding "The Thirty Nine Steps," the tribunal found in the 1983 proceeding, that is was properly represented by Janus Films, Inc. based upon a license from the copyright owner of the underlying work. 51 FR 12816. Multimedia, in this proceeding, requests reconsideration of the Tribunal's findings. Multimedia Proposed Finding, pp. 25-26.
The remaining 16 titles which Multimedia challenges account for 3,314,760 household viewing hours. Multimedia Rebuttal Ex. 7.
Criticisms of the Nielsen study. Multimedia challenged the validity of the Nielsen study in three respects. Multimedia Rebuttal, Testimony of Richard Thrall, pp. 1-5. The first criticism was that the Nielsen study's emphasis on six sweep periods works to deny any entitlement to several of Multimedia's specials. Id., p. 2. The examples cited were: although the "18th Annual Music City News Award"' aired on 20 Nielsen-measured stations, only one broadcast occurred during the sweep periods; the "Hank Williams Special" and the repeat of "Volunteer Jam" aired on 19 and 20 Nielsen sample stations respectively, but only eight telecasts in total fell within the six sweep periods; broadcasts of "Stubby Pringle's Christmas" and the repeat of "New Faces" were carried by 38 sample stations combined, but not one broadcast was measured by Nielsen because they fell outside of the sweep periods. Id., pp. 2-3. However, Multimedia did not provide in its direct case a complete list of which stations carried its programs and the dates the programs were aired. Tr. 1446-1447.
Multimedia's second criticism related to the cut-off point MPAA chose determined which stations would be in the Nielsen sample. MPAA's decision to raise the cut-off point from 95,000 cable households per semiannual period in 1983 to 100,000 cable households per semiannual period in 1984 resulted in the dropping of WBBM-TV, Chicago, Illinois from the Neilsen study. Multimedia notes that WBBM-TV is the flagship station of "Donahue" and the only station in the United States to carry "Donahue" live in 1984. Multimedia Rebuttal, Testimony of Richard Thrall, pp. 3-4.
On cross examination, MPAA introduced an exhibit which demonstrated that although four stations carrying "Donahue" were dropped from the Nielsen study in 1984 (WBBM-TV, Chicago, Illinois, WPLG, Miami, Florida, KSNT, Topeka, Kansas, and WCMH, Columbus, Ohio), three new stations carrying "Donahue") were added to the 1984 study (KSDK, St. Louis, Missouri, WBRE, Wilkes Barre/Scranton, Pennsylvania, and WDIV, Detroit, Michigan), and that the three new stations exceeded the four dropped stations in reaching distant cable subscribers by 120,110 households. MPAA Ex. 27RX. Multimedia witness Richard Thrall conceded the accuracy of MPAA's exhibit. Tr. 1487-1488.
Multimedia's third criticism was that the Nielsen viewing data did not comport with the results of similar data derived from the Nielsen ROSPs. Multimedia Rebuttal, Testimony of Richard Thrall, p. 4. According to Multimedia, the ROSP figures for viewing outside the designated market area (DMA) of a station should, in a typical case, exceed the Nielsen study figures because the non-DMA figures include some local viewing. Tr. 1457. However, for the twelve television series it analyzed, the Nielsen viewing data exceeded the ROSP viewing data, ranging from 3% in the case of "The Beverly Hillbillies" to 618% in the case of "Perry Mason." Multimedia Rebuttal Ex. 2, p. 5. Multimedia asserts that this indicates that the Nielsen viewing data are distorted. Multimedia Rebuttal, Testimony of Richard Thrall, pp. 4-5.
Although Multimedia asserts that many non-DMA counties are local, the opposite is true for WTBS. MPAA Ex. 30RX. All non-DMA counties for WTBS are distant, and additionally, nearly 30 counties inside the DMA are distant rather than local. Id.
*8418 Multimedia's Rebuttal Exhibit 2 does not consider other factors, such as the frequency a program was telecast in 1984, or the number of stations carrying the program. Tr. 1509-1511. MPAA introduced an exhibit analyzing 9 other programs. The exhibit showed the Nielsen data for these shows at levels 40 to 65% of the non-DMA viewing. MPAA Ex. 29RX.
NAB criticized the data MPAA had compiled for the NAB-represented claimants. NAB produced an exhibit based upon MPAA's Nielsen printouts purporting to show an additional 124,124 household viewing hours which should have been credited to NAB. NAB Ex. II-8X. MPAA conceded the validity of NAB's findings. Tr. 1338-1348.
Multimedia's claim. Multimedia asserts that its award should be increased from 1.0% in 1983 to 1.2% in 1984. Multimedia Direct, Testimony of Richard Thrall, p. 11. To support its request for an increased award, Multimedia notes that it syndicated 26 music and entertainment specials in 1984, seven more than in 1983. Id., p. 4; Tr. 247. Multimedia also seeks credit for the introduction of a new daytime syndicated talk/interview program, "Sally Jessy Raphael." Id. 175 daily syndicated episodes of "Sally Jessy Raphael" were produced, and by the end of 1984, it was carried on 25 broadcast stations. Tr. 246.
Multimedia also asserts that its other programs maintained their marketplace value in 1984. Multimedia Direct, Testimony of Richard Thrall, pp. 5-8. "Donahue's" broadcast ratings remained relatively constant from 1983 to 1984. Multimedia Ex. 3. Broadcast ratings for "Music City USA," "Pop! Goes the Country," "Austin City Limits," and "Young People Specials" remained close between 1983 and 1984. Multimedia Ex. 6; Tr. 243. The time for all Multimedia programs on all broadcast stations during 1984 was 1237 hours per week. This compares to 1241 hours per week during 1983. Multimedia Ex. 18; Tr. 253.
Multimedia submitted exhibits listing which of its programs appeared on superstations, and which of its programs appeared on any broadcast stations for which at least one cable system paid at the 3.75% rate to carry in 1983. Multimedia Exs. 15, 5.
NAB's claim. NAB requested the same allocation for 1984 as it received in 1983, 0.8% NAB Proposed Findings, par. 5. In support of its claim, NAB presented two exhibits. The first exhibit was a copy of a questionnaire on programs syndicated in 1984 which the NAB-represented broadcast stations filled out at NAB's request. NAB Ex. II-1. The second exhibit was a listing of the syndicated programs which the broadcast stations claim. NAB Ex. II-2. The listing was based entirely upon the response to NAB's questionnaire. Tr. 319. Ex. II-2 listed the titles of the syndicated programs, the station which originated the program, and the stations which carried the program. Tr. 329. NAB underlined which carrying stations were imported as a distant signal by Form 3 cable systems in 1983. Tr. 330. Carrying stations which were not underlined may have been imported by Form 1 or Form 2 stations, but NAB could not state whether this was so. Id. There were six programs for which no carrying stations were underlined. Tr. 355. NAB presented no evidence as to the marketplace value of its program aside from its list of programs and which broadcast stations carried them. NAB Direct.
MPAA challenged the accuracy of NAB's Exhibit II-2. MPAA Rebuttal, Testimony of Allen Cooper, pp. 9-11. MPAA analyzed four programs produced by WPIX, New York, New York, which accounted for approximately 9,000,000 of NAB's Nielsen household viewing hours: "INN Midday News," "INN Evening News," "Wall Street Journal Report," and "From the Editors Desk." MPAA compared NAB's Ex. II-2's listing of the stations which carried these programs to Nielsen's "Report of Syndicated Programs" (ROSP) listing for the four-week February, May, July, and November, 1984 periods, and found sizable discrepancies. The percentage of NAB Ex. II-2 broadcast stations purporting to carry the WPIX programs which did not show up in the ROSP were as follows: "INN Midday News,"--41.8%, "INN Evening News,"--29.3%, "From the Editors Desk,"--40.3%, "Wall Street Journal Report,"--36.%. Id., p.10.
MPAA witness Allen Cooper conceded that there could be valid reasons for the discrepancies, such as stations with audience levels below a certain minimum are not listed in the ROSP. Id., p. 11. NAB introduced evidence from the syndicated program Analysis (SPA), a report published by Arbitron, and certain other evidence correcting MPAA's analysis, which modified the discrepancies downward. The percentage of "no" listings after NAB modifications became, "INN Midday News,"--21.0%, "INN Evening News,"--15.0%, "From the Editor's Desk,"--13.5%, "Wall Street Journal Report,"--14.6%. NAB Exs. II-4X, II-5X, II-6X, II-7X.
MPAA also raised the issue of programs broadcast only on commonly-owned stations. MPAA found 39 programs that were listed in NAB Exhibit II-2 which were broadcast only by commonly-owned stations which it believed should be treated differently by the Tribunal. MPAA Ex. 14R; Tr. 1163. MPAA witness Allen Cooper testified that the "harm" criterion which the Tribunal uses to evaluate programs is not a factor in distribution by an originating station to a commonly-owned station, because no effort was made to sell the program to anyone, so no sales were lost as the result of cable retransmissions. Tr. 1163. Mr. Cooper also testified that if a program only gets aired on a commonly-owned station, that is a judgment regarding its marketplace value, since if the program had more marketplace value, it would have been offered and bought in the syndication market. Id.
Conclusions of Law
MPAA, Multimedia, and NAB have shown entitlement to 98.475%, 0.825% and 0.7% of the Program Suppliers Phase I allocation, respectively.
In each of the previous proceedings in which MPAA, Multimedia and NAB have litigated a Phase II controversy in the Program Suppliers category, the Tribunal has used the Nielsen data provided by MPAA as its starting off point, but not its sole basis, for making its allocation among MPAA, Multimedia, and NAB. In this year's proceeding, the Nielsen breakdown among the three claimants was:
MPAA ................. 2,381,600,000 (approx.) 99.329%
NAB ................................ 9,714,260 0.405
Multimedia ......................... 6,376,193 0.266
The programs proffered by NAB as belonging within its claim were disputed by MPAA, "The Dance Show," "Fight Back with David Horowitz," and "Millers Court." Both parties stipulated that NAB represented the producers of the shows and MPAA represented the syndicators. Following our ruling in the NBC-Worldivision controversy where we determined that as between the producer and the syndicator the Tribunal would award the syndicator, we find that these three disputed programs belong to MPAA's claim. However, the loss to NAB of the 159,507 household viewing hours represented by these three programs is almost entirely offset by the additional 124,124 household viewing hours which MPAA concedes should have been credited to NAB when MPAA did its analysis. Therefore, the Nielsen "starting off point" for the three claimants after these *8419 adjustments are made is MPAA--99.33%, NAB 0.404%, Multimedia, 0.266%.
Multimedia challenged 20 titles within MPAA's claim as actually being in the public domain. The purpose of Multimedia's challenge was two-fold--one, to indicate to the Tribunal that these allegedly public domain properties were only the "tip of the iceberg" of many more public domain works in MPAA's claim so that MPAA should be required to put forward evidence of its members' copyright ownership of all its works, and two, to alter the relative strengths of the three claimants in the Nielsen data.
Regarding Multimedia's challenge to the two most significant programs (going by Nielsen viewing data alone), "Popeye," and "Lone Ranger," we do not credit that Multimedia has raised enough doubts sufficient to shift the burden to MPAA to prove its ownership of these programs. Only a few episodes of both programs were shown to have had their copyright registration lapse. The great bulk of the episodes were unchallenged. Multimedia did not show that even these few episodes were aired in 1984 or comprise any of MPAA's claim.
MPAA by it own procedures, disclaimed in advance of Multimedia's challenge, one title, "Meet John Doe," and therefore its viewing hours were not included in MPAA's direct case. In the case of "The Thirty Nine Steps," we decline to reconsider our ruling we made in the last proceeding; it was subject to full argument from all parties then and in this proceeding, Multimedia has offered nothing new.
Looking at the remaining 16 titles which account for 3,314,760 household viewing hours, the Tribunal performed an analysis, assuming, for the sake of the analysis only, that those works were in the public domain. Those viewing hours were subtracted from MPAA's total viewing hours, and the relative strengths of the three claimants were recalculated. Even without those viewing hours, the percentage share of MPAA, NAB, and Multimedia remain the same down to the third decimal place--99.330%, 0.404% and 0.266%, respectively. The Tribunal chose, therefore, not to engage in any analysis of the 16 challenged titles. We can only repeat what we stated in the last proceeding, that Multimedia's challenges to MPAA are clearly de minimis, and the possibility that there exists a sizable number of public domain works in MPAA's claim that would have been revealed but for the limitations of Multimedia's resources simply does not appear plausible to us.
Two of Multimedia's challenges to the validity of the Nielsen data were not well taken. The dropping of WBBM-TV, the flagship station of "Donahue," from the Nielsen study did not adversely affect Multimedia, because it was shown by MPAA that the various additions and subtractions of stations in the study carrying "Donahue," on the whole, probably inured to the benefit of Multimedia, rather than to its detriment. Multimedia's comparison of the ROSP figures with MPAA's Nielsen data did not reveal differences that were unexplainable. We are satisfied that, in the case of WTBS programs, non-DMA viewing would indeed be lower than the Neilsen data, because much of the area within the Atlanta DMA is counted as distant viewing as far as WTBS is concerned. Whatever further discrepancies remain are more than adequately explained by the frequency of the broadcasts of the programs (which Multimedia did not take into account) and the number of other markets where the program was aired in addition to the one market Multimedia measured.
The third criticism Multimedia raised, that many of its specials are broadcast during times of the year which are not measured by the Nielsen data has some validity which we discuss below.
Comparing the Nielsen data from 1983 to 1984, we note that MPAA's relative share increased 0.13%, NAB's relative share decreased 9.2%, and Multimedia's relative share decreased 25.7%. While small fluctuations in the relative shares of the three parties might not warrant a change in awards, we consider NAB's loss of 9.2%, and Multimedia's loss of 25.7% sufficient evidence of changed circumstances to justify lowering their awards in 1984.
Taking Multimedia up first, Multimedia requested an increased award based upon having distributed more specials in 1984 than ever before, and upon the introduction of a new show, "Sally Jessy Raphael." This is intended to give the impression that, strictly in time, more of Multimedia's product was in distribution in 1984 than ever before. However, by Multimedia's own exhibit, the amount of time of Multimedia's product on television stations remained completely stable from 1983 to 1984.
The amount of Multimedia product on television broadcast stations is not, alone, the relevant consideration. The relevant consideration is how much of Multimedia's product was retransmitted by cable systems on a distant signal basis in 1984 and what was the marketplace value of those programs. Although Multimedia's program time may have remained the same from 1983 to 1984, its Nielsen viewing hours dropped 25.7%. We stated in last year's proceeding that the overall reliability of the Nielsen study may be somewhat less when the focus is on individual programs. Implicit in that statement is the Multimedia argument that its specials which are not aired during sweep periods are therefore overlooked by the Nielsen study. We will contiuue to give some credence to this argument, although we recognize that MPAA's specials may similarly suffer, and also, considering the continued strong showing of "Donahue" in 1984, we have decided not to lower Multimedia's award by the full 25% loss in the Nielsen data, but to give it a lesser decrease of 17.5% from 1983. The result is a lowering of Multimedia's award from 1.0% to 0.825%.
However, for Multimedia to continue to prevail in its argument that its programs are overlooked by Nielsen, it must provide the Tribunal with more information. We would like to see not simply the amount of Multimedia product on television broadcast stations, but the dates the programs were aired, whether the programs aired within or outside a Nielsen sweep period, and which cable systems carried them on a distant signal basis, and their subscribership.
Regarding NAB, we have decided to decrease its award from 0.8% to 0.7%, or about 12.5%. This exceeds the loss in Nielsen viewing strength which we have already stated was 9.2%. In the last proceeding, we agreed that MPAA's decision not to categorize parades, political programs, minor sports programs, programs on specialty stations, and programs syndicated on commonly-owned stations as syndicated programs was incorrect and probably resulted in an underrating of NAB's claim. This year MPAA has made the appropriate corrections, and we find that the credit we gave NAB on this point probably exceeded the amount that was warranted. Additionally, in the last proceeding, we noted in the findings of fact and in the conclusions of law that NAB made no effort to demonstrate the marketplace value of its programs. However, based on testimony of previous proceedings, we gave credit to NAB's programs for their regional appeal. We note again, this year, that NAB has included no evidence on the marketplace value of its works, and we wish to state that mere reliance on previous testimony is not sufficient. As MPAA observes in its proposed findings, although certain of NAB's *8420 programs remain the same each year, such as the WPIX programs, a great number of them are new and their value should be established on the record for the Tribunal. Our decrease in the award to NAB reflects the changed Nielsen viewing percentages, a revision of our view that the Nielsen date underrated NAB for certain categories of programs, and NAB's lack of established marketplace value for many of its works.
We also note questions we have on the completeness of NAB's presentation. For those carrying stations which were not underlined, which meant they were not carried by Form 3 systems, NAB could only surmise that they could have been carried by Form 1 or 2 cable systems, but could not say so definitely. There were six programs for which both the originating station and the carrying stations were not underlined and therefore could have been entirely outside of the universe of this proceeding.
We were also troubled by the allegation of flaws in the collection and verification of data from the NAB-represented broadcast stations raised by MPAA.
Together, these questions we have about the programs which NAB could not verify were retransmitted by cable systems on a distant signal basis, and the possibility of flaws in the exhibits, did not enter into our lowering of NAB's award to 0.7%, but these concerns will need to be met in the future if NAB's level of award is to be maintained.
Last year we reserved the question of programs broadcast on commonly-owned stations, and requested better elucidation on the issue for this proceeding. While we do not necesarily disagree with MPAA's description of the nature of programs broadcast on commonly-owned stations, those programs nonetheless do meet our definition of a syndicated program, they are viewed, and may have some marketplace value, and we note that on other occasions MPAA has consistently urged the Tribunal to makes its allocation on Nielsen viewing alone.
Finally, in the last proceeding, the Tribunal did not find sufficient record evidence to justify making separate allocations in the Phase II Program Suppliers category for the basic fund, the 3.75% fund and the syndex fund. Again, in this proceeding, we find no basis for making separate allocations.
Allocations
Pursuant to the Phase I settlement, the Tribunal has adopted the following allocation to categories of claimants in Phase I of the 1984 cable copyright royalties fees available for distribution:
After subtracting the stipulated award to National Public Radio of 0.18% of the entire fund,
------------------------------------------------------------------
Category Basic 3.75% Syndex
------------------------------------------------------------------
Program Suppliers ..................... 67.10 72.00 95.50
Joint Sports .......................... 16.35 17.50 0
Public Broadcasting Service ............ 5.20 0 0
Commercial Television .................. 5.00 5.00 0
Music .................................. 4.50 4.50 4.50
Devotional Claimants ................... 1.10 0.75 0
Canadian Claimants ..................... 0.75 0.25 0
Commercial Radio .......................... 0 0 0
------------------------------------------------------------------
The allocation adopted by the Tribunal under Phase II for the individual claimants is as follows:
PROGRAM SUPPLIERS:
Motion Picture Association of America, Inc.....98.475%
Multimedia Entertainment, Inc.....0.825
National Association of Broadcasters.....0.700
Dated: March 11, 1987.
J.C. Argetsinger,
Chairman.
[FR Doc. 87-5659 Filed 3-16-87; 8:45 am]
Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.