Copyright Royalty Tribunal

NOTICES
 
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
 
[Docket Nos. 83-2, 84-2 83 JD]
 
Distribution of the 1982 and 1983 Jukebox Royalty Funds; Order Consolidating
Proceedings and Setting Future Procedural Dates
 
Monday, August 5, 1985
 
*31645 Consolidation

  On November 5, 1984, the Tribunal declared that a controversy existed in the distribution of the 1983 Jukebox Royalty Fund. On January 7, 1985, the Tribunal determined at a pre-hearing conference that the controversy existed only as to 5% of the fund which represents Spanish language musical works performed on jukeboxes. On May 30, 1985, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit vacated the 1982 Jukebox Royalty Distribution Determination for the disputed ten percent of the fund and remanded for further proceedings. The part of the fund which was in dispute was Spanish-language musical works performed on jukeboxes. The Tribunal finds that the parties and issues of the remanded 1982 proceeding and the 1983 proceeding are substantially the same, and that the time and resources of the parties and the Tribunal would better served by consolidating the two proceedings. The Tribunal has not yet received the Court's mandate. However, in the interest of conserving time to meet our statutory deadline, the Tribunal has determined to issue this order. Accordingly, the remanded part of the 1982 Jukebox Distribution Proceeding and the 1983 Jukebox Distribution Proceeding are hereby consolidated.

 Evidentiary Hearing Required

  In the judgement of the Tribunal, the Court of Appeals' opinion in A.C.E.M.L.A. v. CRT makes it necessary *31646 to hold an evidentiary hearing on the following questions:

 Status of Claimants. In the view of the Court of Appeals, the status of A.C.E.M.L.A., Latin American Music, and Latin American Music, Inc. (collectively, LAM) was left unresolved by the 1982 jukebox final determination, and it treated LAM as performing rights societies "for purposes of this appeal" but specifically did not foreclose "further examination of this issue by the CRT on the remand." The Court's opinion further appeared to say that a settlement among performing rights societies would only be effective in eliminating the necessity for proving entitlement if it was a settlement among all performing rights societies. The Copyright Act of 1976 defines ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC, Inc. as performing rights societies. 17 U.S.C. 116(e)(3). No further inquiry is necessary. However, the Tribunal will make inquiry into the status of A.C.E.M.L.A., Latin American Music, Latin American Music, Inc. and Italian Book Company (IBC) in this consolidated proceeding.

 Entitlement--The Court stated that the CRT must "provide all the claiming societies an opportunity to prove entitlement to the ten percent of the 1982 fund that remains in controversy." We note that at the time the appeal was taken, we had retained 10 percent of the fund solely to assure sufficient funds to resolve any controversy, but after finding that Michael Walsh and Sammie Belcher, two individual claimants, had not appealed and that the extent of LAM's claim was 5 percent, we distributed another 5 percent of the fund. We believe we were correct in our analysis, and therefore, the parties need only prove entitlement to the five percent of the 1982 fund that remains in controversy in this consolidated proceeding. For the 1983 proceeding, the Tribunal believes it is necessary for ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC, Inc. to prove entitlement to 100 percent of the fund, and for LAM to prove entitlement to 5 percent of the fund. IBC must submit its 1983 claim, either a percentage of the fun or an absolute dollar figure, and must prove entitlement accordingly.

 Criteria for Proving Entitlement for Amounts in Controversy

  On January 7, 1985, the Tribunal heard oral argument on how the parties might prove entitlement to the portion of the fund which represents Spanish-language music performed on jukeboxes. ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC Inc. recommended either a survey of radio performances or a survey of radio and other media performances. LAM recommended an actual survey of jukeboxes to be funded by the royalty pool. The Tribunal has been reluctant to instruct parties how to prove entitlement, because it does not want to restrict or inhibit the production of any relevant evidence. Therefore, the following is intended to give the parties guidance only, and is not meant to foreclose any type of submission by any party.

 Survey of jukeboxes. The Tribunal recommends a survey of jukeboxes. The question has been raised whether the claimant(s) or the Tribunal should bear the cost. The Tribunal does not have an appropriation to conduct a survey of jukeboxes. Further, it does not believe it has the authorization to conduct the type of survey receommended by LAM. Section 807 authorizes the Tribunal to assess "the reasonable costs" of a distribution proceeding. We believe that the cost of a jukebox survey of Spanish-language music would be so great in comparsion to the actual amount of Spanish-language music which the survey would find that we do not believe we could determine it "reasonable" under Section 807. However, any party may submit to the Tribunal a survey of jukeboxes at its own cost.

 Sworn statement from jukebox operators. The Tribunal will accept into evidence and weigh the value of sworn statements from jukebox operators regarding jukebox play. The Tribunal reminds the parties that these representations, as all representations made to the Tribunal, are subject to Title 18, Section 1001 of the U.S. Code which makes misrepresentations to a governmental body punishable by fine and/or imprisonment.

 Survey of radio and other media performances. The Tribunal recommends a survey of radio and other media performances. Pursuant to that recommendation, we will require all parties to make available to all parties and the Tribunal a representative sample of the top Spanish-language songs in their catalogue so that any party can conduct performance surveys. The Tribunal would like to see the result of any survey segregted by media and by year.

 Hit Songs Charts. The Tribunal will weigh the evidentiary value of hit songs charts. The charts may be national, regional, or local. They may be radio charts, retail outlet charts, trade magazine charts, or any other charts any party believes are relevant.

 Procedural Dates

  August 9, 1985--All parties shall furnish to all parties and the Tribunal a representative sample of the most preformed Spanish-language songs in the catalogue, which shall include the full title of the work, the author(s), the publisher and the name of the most popular performer(s) of the work.

 September 3, 1985--All parties shall file with the Tribunal and all the parties the results of any performances survey they might have conducted. All parties shall file any comments they might have on the replies to the Tribunal's fact-finding letter of May 16, 1985.

 September 13, 1985--All parties shall file their written direct case. Part I shall include the following documentation to prove claimant is a performing rights society:

 (a) Documentation of the ownership and structure of the claimant;

 (b) The form(s) of the agreement with the copyright owners

 (c) A list of the entities to whom the claimant licenses the public performance of the works;

 (d) Documentation of the claimant's distribution system. [FN1]

   FN1 The Tribunal has no subpoena power and therefore cannot compel production of these documents. Further, the Tribunal does not intend to state that failure to produce any one of these documents will result in an adverse finding. However, the extent to which these documents are or are not produced will necessarily affect the Tribunal's analysis. The burden of proof falls on the claimant to prove entitlement, and within that burden is the burden to prove performing rights society status for those parties not already defined as such by the Copyright Act. Hence, a party fails to provide the necessary documentation at its own risk.

 Part II shall include all pertinent facts which a claimant believes tend to prove entitlement. For statutorily-defined performing rights societies, the written direct case shall consist of one part to prove entitlement. The written direct case may incorporate by reference the record evidence from past proceedings.

 Septemberr 30, October 2, October 3--The Tribunal will hold hearings at a time and place to be announced. The Tribunal will take testimony and hear arguments on the status of the parties, the validity and relevancy of any surveys, and any other proofs of entitlement offered by each party.

 October 17, 1985--All parties shall file Proposed Findings of Facts and Conclusions of Law.

 October 24, 1985--All parties shall file Reply Findings of Facts and Conclusions of Law.

 July 30, 1985.

 Edward W. Ray,

 Acting Chairman.

 [FR Doc. 85-18486 Filed 8-2-85; 8:45 am]


Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.