IP Jury Verdicts

United States District Court,D. Minnesota

ITRON, INC. V. RALPH BENGHIAT

No. 99-CV-501

December 20, 2002

IP ISSUE: PATENTS

COUNSEL:

Plaintiff: Randall Thomas Skaar; Patterson Thuente Skaar and Christensen; Minneapolis, MN James Hugh Patterson; Patterson and Allison; Minneapolis, MN Eric Hugh Chadwick; Patterson and Allison; Minneapolis, MN Aaron Wayne Davis; Patterson Thuente Skaar and Christensen; Minneapolis, MN

Defendant: Edward Michael Laine; Oppenheimer, Wolf and Donnelly; Minneapolis, MN Ernest W. Grumbles; Oppenheimer, Wolf and Donnelly; Minneapolis, MN Bridget A. Sullivan; Oppenheimer, Wolff and Donnelly; Minneapolis, MN Guy Porter Smith; Oppenheimer Wolff and Donnelly; Los Angeles, CA Russell E. Hattis; Hattis Law Office; Highland Park, IL David C. Bohrer; Oppenheimer Wolff and Donnelly; Palo Alto, CA Alison J. Choppelas; Oppenheimer Wollff and Donnelly; Palo Alto, CA Cyrus A. Morton; Oppenheimer Wollff and Donnelly; Minneapolis, MN Timothy T. Huber; Oppenheimer Wollff and Donnelly; Palo Alto, CA Mark Phillip Wine; McDermott Will and Emery; Los Angeles, CA

JUDGE: John R. Tunheim

TOTAL: $5,000,000-999,999,999

STATE: Minnesota