BPAI

Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences

Patent and Trademark Office (P.T.O.)

*1 EX PARTE RESEARCH AND MANUFACTURING CO., INC.

Appeal No. 88-3277

October 25, 1988


 Request filed January 28, 1987, Control No. 90/001,155, for the Reexamination of Patent No. 3,680,420, issued August 1, 1972, based on Serial No. 82,994 filed October 22, 1970. Cryogenic Ultramicrotome Apparatus.


Edwin M. Baranowski et al. for appellant


Primary Examiner--Donald R. Schran


Before Cohen, Lyddane, and Garris


Examiners-in-Chief


Lyddane


Examiner-in-Chief


 This is a decision on an appeal from the final rejection of claims 1, 6, 10 through 14, 16, and 21 in the reexamination proceeding of U.S. Patent No. 3,680,420. These are all the claims remaining in this proceeding. No claim is allowed.


 The subject matter on appeal relates to a microtome for sectioning biological tissues or the like under cryogenic conditions. Claims 1, 12, and 21 are illustrative of the invention as well as representative of the subject matter on appeal, and read as follows:


 1. Cryogenic equipment for a microtome having a pivoting fulcrum comprising a frame, a container made of insulating material, a microtome knife positioned in said container, an inverted U-shaped specimen holder assembly mounted on the free end of said fulcrum, the spaced legs of said specimen holder assembly straddling a wall of said container and movable reciprocably and freely relative thereto, the outer leg of said specimen holder assembly extending into said container, a tissue holder removably mounted on said outer leg in a position where a tissue specimen mounted on said tissue holder is sectioned by the cutting edge of said knife when said fulcrum moves through one of its reciprocating passes.


 12. A microtome for sectioning biological tissues or the like under cryogenic conditions comprising a frame, a fulcrum mounted pivotally on said frame, a container of insulating material for accommodating a quantity of cryogenic fluid mounted on said frame, a microtome knife positioned in said container, first means on said fulcrum freely bypassing a wall of said container and extending into the interior of said container, and second means mounted on that portion of the first means extending into the interior of said container for supporting a tissue specimen to be sectioned by said knife.


 21. A microtome for sectioning biological tissues or the like under cryogenic conditions comprising a frame, a fulcrum mounted pivotally on said frame, a container of insulating material for accommodating a quantity of cryogenic liquid mounted on said frame, a microtome knife positioned in said container, the cutting edge of said knife being located in substantially the same horizontal plane as the pivot point of said fulcrum, an inverted U-shaped specimen holder assembly mounted on the free end of said fulcrum and extending freely over and around one wall of said container, the outer leg of said assembly extending into the interior of said container, and a tissue holder mounted on the lower portion of said leg for moving a tissue specimen on said holder relative to the cutting edge of said knife.


  *2 The references of record relied on by the examiner in rejections of the appealed claims based on 35 USC 102(b) and on 35 USC 103 are as follows:

   Christensen, "A Way To Prepare Frozen Thin Sections Of Fresh Tissue For Election Microscopy", (June 1968) in Autoradiography of Diffusible Substances, (1969), pages 349-362.

   Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin FTS 26-69 (hereafter Sorvall bulletin), Copyright Registration No. A90038, dated August 29, 1969.


 Claims 1, 11, and 21 stand rejected under 35 USC 102(b) as being anticipated by the Sorvall bulletin.


 Claims 12 through 14 stand rejected under 35 USC 102(b) as being anticipated by the Christensen article.


 Claims 6, 10, and 16 stand rejected under 35 USC 103 as being unpatentable over the disclosure of the Christensen article in view of the Sorvall bulletin. [FN1] The examiner considers that it would have been obvious to one having ordinary skill in the art of microtomes to have modified the fulcrum arm disclosed in the Christensen article to have included an inverted U at the end thereof as disclosed in the Sorvall bulletin.


 We refer to pages 4 through 6 of the examiner's answer for the full statement of the examiner's rejections of the claims on appeal.


 Appellant has argued, with respect to claims 12 through 14, that the examiner has not properly applied 35 USC 102(b) and not properly construed 35 USC 112 with respect to the "means" clauses. Appellant cites Pennwalt Corp. v. Durand-Wayland, Inc., 833 F.2d 931, 4 USPQ2d 1737 (Fed.Cir.1987), as stating that not any means is properly covered by a "means" clause, but rather only "structure ... which performs that function [which] is the same as or an equivalent of the structure disclosed in the specification" (brief, page 11). It is also argued that no means other than the "U-shaped" specimen holder is described in appellant's patent, thus no interpretation other than that derived from the patent disclosure is proper. Appellant also contends that even if the literal meaning of the claim 12 language "freely bypassing" is considered by itself, in the Christensen article it is the fulcrum arm that penetrates the container wall, not a separate means attached to the fulcrum. It is maintained that the arm of Christensen also does not "bypass, avoid or go around the wall of the container" (brief, page 17) and that the Christensen article does not illustrate the cutting edge in the plane of the pivot (claim 13) or bypassing of the wall during complete oscillation (claim 14).


 Appellant next argues the propriety of the rejection of claims 1, 11, and 21 under 35 USC 102(b) as being anticipated by the Sorvall bulletin. Appellant urges that the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin-FTS (Bulletin 26-69) was not a "printed publication" under 35 USC 102(b). Appellant asserts that, as of June 5, 1969, the Sorvall bulletin was not finished, since Dr. Christensen's revisions had not yet been received (brief, page 27) and that the date of publication, June 2, 1969, listed on the application for registration of a claim to copyright was five days after Mr. Clutter's letter requesting Dr. Christensen to review and comment on the Sorvall bulletin and three days before Dr. Christensen's response to Mr. Clutter's letter. Appellant also notes that the affidavit of Mr. Lindgren states that the Sorvall bulletin was intended for use within the company and that all copies were destroyed after being criticized by Dr. Christensen. Mr. Lindgren also stated that he did not prepare the copyright application and that the dates therein are inaccurate.


  *3 It is further argued that "publication" under 35 USC 102(b) means  "accessible to the interested public." Appellant cites Carella v. Starlight Archery, 804 F.2d 135, 231 USPQ 644 (Fed.Cir.1986) for its holding that the characterizer of the information as a "printed publication" must provide proof of dissemination or the availability and accessibility of the item to the persons concerned with the art to which the document relates. Appellant queries as to what person "of ordinary skill in the art" conducts research in the Copyright Office in the title record index for copyright registration, as opposed to conducting research in a library where there are specific subject indexes.


 Appellant also notes that photocopies of copyright deposits could be provided by the Copyright Office only under copyright Regulation Section 201.2(d)(4)(i)- (iii), i.e. only upon specific authorization of the owner, for pending litigation, or by a court order. It is asserted that copies are otherwise not available. Appellant maintains the position that all the available evidence regarding the Sorvall bulletin shows that its only circulation was in private correspondence with Dr. Christensen, who was a consultant to the assignee at that time.


 Another major point asserted by appellant with respect to the Sorvall bulletin is that it was not publicly available before October 22, 1969 (hereafter critical date) which was one year before the filing date of the application from which issued the patent which is subject to this reexamination. Appellant asserts that the letter from the Office of the General Counsel of the Copyright Office to the Patent and Trademark Office, dated September 24, 1987, states that records of the Copyright Office show that the copyright registration number was assigned sometime between August 29, 1969 and September 15, 1969. Appellant notes that at that time in 1969, inspection of copyright records was only possible with a completed copyright registration at times not interfering with the work of the Copyright Office (brief, page 32). Appellant states that the exact date that the index card was placed in the Copyright Office catalog files could not be ascertained, but that the General Counsel estimated that such would occur in a six to eight week time frame from September 15, 1969. Appellant notes that October 22, 1969, the critical date, is five weeks from September 15, 1969.


 Appellant also relies on the affidavit of Thomas H. Nichols [FN2], Head of Records Section in the Copyright Office in 1969. This "affidavit" indicates processing of the catalog card, referring to the Sorvall bulletin, would likely have continued through at least mid-November of 1969 and that the catalog card and deposit copy would have been unavailable until at least that date.


 Appellant next argues that even if the Sorvall bulletin is considered a  "publication", that it fails to describe appellant's claimed invention. It is argued that, at most, the Sorvall bulletin shows a "black box" interposed upon a bowl of a microtome. It is maintained that reconstruction of the claimed device would only be possible through hindsight. Appellant refers to Dr. Haglar's letter to Dr. Christensen dated June 3, 1987 (Patent Owner's citation BK, Paper No. 12; brief, page 37) where it is stated that despite his background in cryogenics and electrical engineering, the pictures and description are not enough to understand the function of the device presented in the pictures of the 26-69 Sorvall bulletin. Appellant questions how the subject matter of claim 1 and as described in the '420 patent could be evident when even such skilled practitioners as Dr. Christensen, Dr. Haglar, Mr. Lindgren, and Mr. Roberts, all persons skilled in the art, had difficulty in achieving a complete understanding of the invention.


  *4 Lastly, appellant argues the rejection of claims 6, 10, and 16 under  35 USC 103 as being unpatentable over Christensen in view of the Sorvall bulletin. In general, appellant asserts that there is no teaching, suggestion, or motivation for combining the disclosures of the Christensen article and the Sorvall bulletin to arrive at appellant's claimed combination. We refer to pages 9 through 51 of appellant's brief for the full statement of appellant's position with respect to all of the rejections of the claims on appeal.


OPINION

 In arriving at our decision on this appeal, we have given careful consideration to the entire record of this reexamination proceeding, and particularly to the arguments presented by the appellant in the brief and at the oral hearing, and to the arguments presented by the examiner in the answer. Upon evaluation of all the evidence before us in this record, it is our conclusion that the Sorvall bulletin is not a "publication" under 35 USC 102(b). Thus, we are constrained to reverse the examiner's rejection of claims 1, 11, and 21 under 35 USC 102(b) as being anticipated by the Sorvall bulletin, as well as the rejection of claims 6, 10, and 16 under 35 USC 103 as being unpatentable over the Christensen article in view of the Sorvall bulletin. However, we are in agreement with the examiner's position with respect to the rejection of claims 12 through 14 under 35 USC 102(b) as being anticipated by the Christensen article. Our reasoning for these determinations follows.


 It is our view that the initial question to be resolved is whether or not the Sorvall bulletin 26-69 is a "printed publication" within the meaning of 35 USC 102(b). The examiner has maintained the position that the certified date of publication is June 2, 1969, as listed in item 4 on the application for registration of a claim for copyright.


 We note that 17 USC § 209 (Copyright Act of 1909) states that the certificate of registration of copyright "shall be admitted in any court as prima facie evidence of the facts stated therein." Noting that FORM A, which forms a part of this certificate for registration, in the instructions on page 1 states that "[t]he application should not be submitted until after the date of publication given in line 4, and should state the facts which existed on that date." Line 4 of the application is for the date of publication. The instructions are to "[g]ive the complete date when copies of this particular edition were first placed on sale, sold, or publicly distributed. The date when copies where made or printed should not be confused with the date of publication." The date given in item 4 as the date of publication is June 2, 1969.


  *5 Since this certificate of registration "shall be admitted in any court as prima facie evidence of the facts stated therein", it is our conclusion that the certificate of registration of the Sorvall bulletin 26-69 is prima facie evidence of the publication thereof on June 2, 1969. The "date of publication" is defined in 17 USC § 26 (Copyright Act of 1909) as "the earliest date when copies of the first authorized edition were placed on sale, sold, or publicly distributed by the proprietor of the copyright or under his authority." Thus, the certificate of registration provides prima facie evidence that the Sorvall bulletin 26-69 was a "printed publication" under the provisions of 35 USC 102(b).


 However, this prima facie evidence may be rebutted by convincing factual evidence to the contrary. As rebuttal evidence, appellant has presented copies of a letter from Mr. Clutter to Dr. Christensen dated May 28, 1969 requesting that Dr. Christensen "review" a "supplementary bulletin detailing the FTS that John Evans wanted to take on his tour of Europe." Also of record is a return letter from Dr. Christensen to Mr. Clutter dated June 5, 1969 stating that Dr. Christensen had "taken the liberty of revising the text, and a copy of the revised version is enclosed." Attached to Dr. Christensen's letter is a copy of what is asserted to be the revision. Additionally, appellant has proffered an affidavit of Cyrus G. Lindgren dated September 5, 1987, in which Mr. Lindgren asserts that "Bulletin 26-69 was printed as preliminary product information for use within the company," and that "Bulletin 26-69 was not distributed to sales personnel of Ivan Sorvall, Inc. or others" because it had been "immediately criticized and revised by Dr. Christensen resulting in the preparation of Bulletin 28-69. Copies of Bulletin 26-69 were therefore of no use to the company and were destroyed." Mr. Lindgren also states that, with regard to the application for Copyright Registration A90038, that he "recalls that he did not, himself, prepare this application," and "states to the best of his knowledge that the June 2, 1969 date contained in Sections 4 and 11 of the application referring to the date of publication of Bulletin 26-69 is inaccurate. This Bulletin was never put into use or distributed ..."


 On the basis of the evidence before us, it seems apparent that the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69 was only distributed within the company and to Dr. Christensen. Although there were apparently no restrictions placed on Dr. Christensen's use of the bulletin, Dr. Christensen was, in our view, within the employ of Ivan Sorvall, Inc., and therefore the bulletin apparently was never circulated or distributed outside the company or its employees. We refer to the letter of Dr. Christensen to Mr. Baranowski dated June 3, 1987 (Patent Owner's citation BI, Paper No. 11) as evidence of the relationship between Sorvall and Dr. Christensen. Dr. Christensen states in the penultimate paragraph thereof that "[m]y financial arrangement with Sorvall was a 5% royalty on all FTS instruments sold for the first 5 years. After the 5 years were up, I had little further contact with Sorvall."


  *6 Thus, in view of the evidence before us, it appears that the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69 was not "placed on sale, sold, or publicly distributed" (17 USC 26). Therefore, not only was the June 2, 1969 date "inaccurate" as the date of publication, but the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69 was not even "published" under the meaning of the copyright laws. Therefore, we find that the evidence of record rebuts the prima facie evidence of the fact stated in item 4 of the application for registration of a claim to copyright that June 2, 1969 was the date of publication of the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin FTS 26-69.


 The next issue to be resolved, is whether the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69 was publicly available before October 22, 1969, the critical date. There is no dispute apparent from the record that the Sorvall bulletin was "printed", but only whether the bulletin was a "printed publication". The "printed publication" bar found in 35 USC 102 is based on the principle that once the invention is in the public domain, it is no longer patentable by anyone. See In re Bayer, 568 F.2d 1357, 196 USPQ 670, 675 (CCPA 1978). In re Bayer, supra, states that "[t]he date on which the public actually gained access to the invention by means of the publication is the focus of inquiry" and further states that "[a]ccordingly, under 35 USC 102(b), delays within a university library, or within any other organization responsible for the publication of printed documents, are of utmost significance because public access to the document is thereby deferred, thus postponing the commencement of the one year time bar". The publication bar under 35 USC 102 is a legal determination based on underlying issues of fact, and therefore must be approached on a case-by-case basis. See In re Wyer, 655 F.2d 221, 210 USPQ 790, 795 (CCPA 1981). As stated in In re Bayer, supra, "[i]t is well settled that in determining whether a printed document constitutes a publication bar under 35 USC 102(b) the touchstone is public accessibility." This was amplified in In re Wyer, supra, as requiring "the accessibility to at least the pertinent part of the public, of a perceptible description of the invention, in whatever form it may have been recorded. Access involves such factual inquiries as classification and indexing." Wyer went on to state that a reference is regarded as a "printed publication" and a bar to patentability

   upon a satisfactory showing that such document has been disseminated or otherwise made available to the extent that persons interested and ordinarily skilled in the subject matter or art, exercising reasonable diligence, can locate it and recognize and comprehend therefrom the essentials of the claimed invention without need of further research or experimentation.


  *7 Thus, we must determine, based on the evidence before us, whether the copies filed by appellant with the application for registration of a claim to copyright were sufficiently accessible to the public and to persons skilled in the pertinent art to qualify as a "printed publication." Appellant relies on the letter from the General Counsel of the Copyright Office as evidence that, although the exact date the index card was placed in the Copyright Office catalog files could not be ascertained, the General Counsel estimated it would have occurred in a "six to eight week time frame" from September 15, 1969.


 We make the following observations with respect to the letter from Dorothy Schrader, General Counsel of the Copyright Office, dated September 24, 1987, which are pertinent to the issue of public accessibility of the Sorvall Bulletin 26-69. We note that paragraph 4 of the letter states that

   [t]he catalog entries for works registered in 1969 are maintained in card catalog drawers accessible by title of the work, claimant, and author.... Unless they are selected for addition to the collections of the Library of Congress, the deposit copies are maintained in a storage facility under the custody of the Copyright Office. The deposit copies for Sorval [sic, Sorvall] Bulletin 26-69 have been maintained under the custody of the Copyright Office.

Paragraph 5 states that

   Sorval [sic, Sorvall] Bulletin 26-69 was registered, effective on the date of filing (August 29, 1969). The registration would have been publicly available on the date the registration number was assigned. The Copyright Office records indicate that registration number A90038 was assigned sometime between August 29, 1969 and September 15, 1969. The exact date is not ascertainable. Upon completion of the registration, the numbered application and the deposit copies are open to public inspection provided that, the volume of requests does not unduly delay Copyright Office indexing and filing work.

Paragraph 8 states

   [t]he date the catalog card for registration A90038 was placed in the catalog files cannot be ascertained. The records indicate only that it was cataloged on September 15, 1969. Cards would have been printed and filed manually some weeks later. The date for any particular work cannot be ascertained. A six to eight week time frame would be reasonable, but this is merely an estimate. There are no records of this.

Paragraph 9 states that "[t]he exact date of publication of the Catalog of Copyright Office Entries containing registration A90038 cannot be established. The publication records of the Cataloging Division indicate only that the volume containing A90038 was published sometime in 1972."


 Statements made by Thomas A. Nichols, Head of the Records Section, Service Division of the Copyright Office from March 1955 through August 1981, in the "affidavit" [sic] dated May 28, 1987 are also of interest. As stated in paragraphs 4 and 5, the documents, i.e. copies of Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69 filed with the application for registration, in the normal course, would have been shipped to a storage location at Pickett Street, Alexandria, about a month after September 15, 1969 which was approximately when a multi-lith mat was made in accordance with the copy of the card attached to the "affidavit" [sic] as exhibit B. However, Mr. Nichols notes that the Copyright Office moved from Capitol Hill to Crystal City, Virginia on April 1, 1969 and that "[f]or many months before and after that move, we were engaged in packing and unpacking." He states in paragraph 7 that

    *8 [t]he normal delay of about a month of getting materials to Pickett Street and getting them on the shelves would, at that time, probably have been more like two or three months. As a result, if the brochure in question had been turned over to the Materials Control Office even as early as September 15 (the date on which the multi-lith mat was prepared), it would not have reached the shelves and been available for retrieval until at least mid-November and probably later.

Based on the information provided to Mr. Nichols that "the catalogue card in question bears a date stamp of October 20, 1969" which was placed on the card by a counting machine, Mr. Nichols offers the opinion in paragraph 8 that "a card which was date stamped October 20, 1969 would not have entered the catalogue until at least November 20, 1969 and probably well after that." In paragraph 9, Mr. Nichols states that

   if a catalogue card had in fact been placed in the catalogue on the day of October 20, 1969, and if a member of the public had asked to see the document to which it referred, that request would have been processed in due course by the Service Division and a request made to the storage facility at Pickett Street. As indicated above, it is my opinion that such a request on October 20, 1969 would not have resulted in retrieval of the document because it would not yet have been shelved at Pickett Street.


 The declaration of Dorothy P. Harden, presently Head of the Accounting and Records Section of the Licensing Division of the U.S. Copyright Office and who, in 1969, held the position of Supervisory Publication Clerk of the Editing and Publishing Section which had the responsibility for the preparation and editing of Copyright Catalog cards, filed March 3, 1988, is directed to the catalog card of the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69. Ms. Harden states that "the date stamp indicates that it was 'counted' on October 20, 1969 and that it was handled by Editorial Reviser No. 9."


 The declaration of Dennis R. Everett, an employee of the U.S. Copyright Office who was the Assistant Section Head of the Copyright Office's Record Section in October 1969 which had among its responsibilities the maintenance and filing of new catalog cards, states in paragraph 4 that "[b]ecause of the many steps necessary to make catalog cards ready for filing, and at time backlogs in cards to be filed, it is not possible to specify precisely the date on which any given card was filed."


 It is our opinion that these statements by Ms. Schrader, Mr. Nichols, Ms. Harden, and Mr. Everett, none of which contradict any of the others, outline the general procedure for indexing and filing of the catalog cards and the shelving of the documents which existed within the Copyright Office at the time of registration of the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69. Although no specific dates are available for when the index card was cataloged or when the document would have been available on the shelves, Ms. Schrader states that a "six to eight week time frame" from September 15, 1969 would have been reasonable. Mr. Nichols opines that "a card which was date stamped October 20, 1969 would not have entered the catalogue until at least November 20, 1969." Under the normal operating conditions of the Copyright Office outlined by Ms. Schrader, the catalog card would have been available to the public sometime within the time frame of October 27 through November 10 of 1969. Thus, under normal conditions, the earliest estimated availability of the catalog card would have been five days after the critical date, October 22, 1969. However, as noted by Mr. Nichols the conditions existing in 1969 were not "normal" due to the relocation of the Copyright Office to Crystal City. Because of the conditions existing at that time, it is Mr. Nichols' opinion that a card having a date stamp of October 20, 1969, as does the catalog card of the Sorvall bulletin, "would not have entered the catalogue until at least November 20, 1969 and probably well after that." Furthermore, due to the conditions in 1969, i.e. relocation of the Copyright Office, it is also Mr. Nichols' opinion that the brochure in question even if received by the Materials Control Office as earlier as September 15, 1969 "would not have reached the shelves and been available for retrieval until at least mid-November and probably later."


  *9 We note that the court in In re Hall, 781 F.2d 897, 228 USPQ 453 (Fed.Cir.1986) observed that "[t]he probative value of routine business practice to show the performance of a specific act has long been recognized" and concluded that "competent evidence of the general library practice may be relied upon to establish an approximate time when a thesis became accessible." Here, we think it reasonable to rely upon the statements of the General Counsel of the Copyright Office, Ms. Schrader, as well as the statements of Mr. Nichols who was Head of the Record Section in the Copyright Office at the time in question as evidence of the general practice in the Copyright Office for indexing, cataloging, and shelving the document in question in estimating the time it would have taken for the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69 to become available to the interested public. It is our conclusion that the statements of Ms. Schrader and Mr. Nichols, as well as those of Ms. Harden and Mr. Everett, are competent and persuasive evidence, under the facts of this case, that the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69 was not accessible to the interested public prior to the critical date.


 Therefore, it is our conclusion that Sorvall Bulletin 26-69 was not a  "printed publication" under the provisions of 35 USC 102(b). Thus, the rejection of claims 1, 11, and 21 under 35 USC 102(b) as being anticipated by the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69, as well as the rejection of claims 6, 10, and 16 under 35 USC 103 as being unpatentable over the Christensen article in view of the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69, cannot be sustained.


 In resolving the question as to whether the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69 constituted a "printed publication" above, it was not necessary to reach the question raised by appellant as to whether or not the Copyright Office would have been a place where persons interested and ordinarily skilled in the subject matter, exercising reasonable diligence, would have attempted to locate it. Likewise, we also do not reach the question as to whether the Sorvall Supplementary Bulletin 26-69 describes appellant's claimed invention.


 We turn now to the only issue remaining before us, which is whether or not claims 12 through 14 have been properly rejected under 35 USC 102(b) as being anticipated by the Christensen article. Appellant has argued in the paragraph spanning pages 14 and 15 of the brief that in view of the manner in which 35 USC 112 requires "means" claims to be interpreted, "no interpretation other than that derived from the patent disclosure is proper" since no means other than the "U-shaped" specimen holder is described in the patent specification. Pennwalt Corp. v. Durand-Wayland, Inc., 833 F.2d 931, 4 USPQ2d 1737 at 1738 and 1739 (Fed.Cir.1987) is cited by appellant as supporting this proposition. We recognize that the examiner has distinguished the Pennwalt Corp. case from the facts of the instant reexamination proceeding by noting that Pennwalt "was an infringement action not patentability." Notwithstanding the accuracy of this statement, the principle stated by the CAFC in Pennwalt at 1739 that

    *10 [t]he statute means exactly what it says: To determine whether a claim limitation is met literally, where expressed as a means for performing a stated function, the court must compare the accused structure with the disclosed structure, and must find equivalent structure as well as identity of claimed function for that structure [emphasis in original]

is not without some relevance to a patentability determination in a pending patent application or in a reexamination proceeding. More particularly, we make reference to 35 USC 112, last paragraph, regarding construing "means" recitations in a claim.


 We note that the CAFC has held that claims subject to reexamination will be given "their broadest reasonable interpretation consistent with the specification, and limitations appearing in the specification are not to be read into the claims." See In re Etter, 756 F.2d 1852, 225 USPQ 1 at page 5 (Fed.Cir.1985). We also note that in order to anticipate a means-plus-function limitation of a claim in an application, structure must be present in the reference which is capable of performing the functional limitation of the means claimed in the application. See In re Mott, 557 F.2d 266, 194 USPQ 305 (CCPA 1977). Thus, Pennwalt is not inconsistent with Mott, but merely states it differently that one "must find equivalent structure as well as identity of claimed function for that structure." Thus, in order to anticipate appellant's claim 12, the Christensen article must show a means (i.e. equivalent structure) which performs the identical function of "freely bypassing a wall ... and extending into the interior of said container." We concur with the examiner's position that this "means" as well as function is provided by the portion of the fulcrum arm which extends over and freely bypasses the recessed wall of the container as illustrated in the Figure on page 351 of the Christensen article. We cannot agree with appellant's argument that the device shown in the Christensen article "does not bypass, avoid or go around the wall of the container" (brief, page 17). It is our view that the Figures in the Christensen article clearly show the container having a recessed wall which a portion of the cutting arm (fulcrum) clearly bypasses or avoids in the manner discussed on page 354 and illustrated at item 3 in Figure 4 on page 355 of the Christensen article. In order for the discussed cutting to take place, it is inherently necessary that the portion of the cutting arm freely extending over the recessed upper wall of the bowl must "freely bypass" rather than engage the recessed upper wall because such engagement would interfere with the normal cutting operation of the microtome knife.


 Appellant's argument that the Christensen article does not illustrate a cutting edge of a knife in the plane of a pivot point is also not persuasive. Appealed claim 13 requires that "the cutting edge of said microtome knife is in substantially the same plane with the pivot point of said fulcrum." This claim does not define any particular plane but only requires that the cutting edge of the knife and the pivot point of the fulcrum be in substantially the same plane. The illustration that the examiner has provided on page 8 of the examiner's answer (which is taken from the illustration of the Christensen device provided by appellant on page 18 of the brief) makes it clear that there is at least one plane in which the cutting edge of the microtome knife and the pivot point of the fulcrum would lie to be substantially coplanar. This is all that is required by claim 13 and thus this limitation is fully met by the structure of the device disclosed in the Christensen article.


  *11 Likewise, the limitation of claim 14 requires that "said first means moves freely relative to said container wall during the complete oscillating movement of said fulcrum." The first means is the portion of the fulcrum arm which freely bypasses the recess in the wall of the container of the device in the Christensen article. It is clear to us that, in order for the microtome of the Christensen article to operate in its intended manner, the first means must move freely relative to the container wall during the complete oscillating movement of the fulcrum. It is this oscillating movement which provides the sections and ribbons which are illustrated in Figure 4 of the Christensen article. In our view, we consider that one skilled in the art would perceive the cutting arm, fulcrum, and recess in the wall of the bowl of the Christensen device as permitting full oscillatory movement during normal operation of the microtome in order to operate in its intended manner. We note that skill is presumed on the part of the artisan reviewing the disclosure of Christensen rather than the converse. See In re Sovish, 769 F.2d 738, 226 USPQ 771 (Fed.Cir.1985).


 Accordingly, the decision of the examiner rejecting claims 12 through 14 under 35 USC 102(b) is affirmed but the decision of the examiner rejecting claims 1, 11, and 21 under 35 USC 102(b) and rejecting claims 6, 10, and 16 under 35 USC 103 is reversed.


 37 CFR 1.136(a) does not apply to the times for taking any subsequent action in connection with this appeal.


AFFIRMED-IN-PART


BOARD OF PATENT APPEALS AND INTERFERENCES


Irwin Charles Cohen


Examiner-in-Chief


William E. Lyddane


Examiner-in-Chief


Bradley R. Garris


Examiner-in-Chief


FN1. Although the restatement of the rejection of claims 6, 10, and 16 on page 5 o f the examiner's answer failed to include any statutory basis for the rejection, we note that the rejection of these claims, appearing at page 7 of the final rejection dated November 20, 1987, was made under the proper statutory basis an d we have merely restated this basis for completeness.


FN2. Although appellant has charcterized the submission from Mr. Nichols as an  "affidavit", this "affidavit" was not properly executed before a notary public or other appropriate official and therefore cannot be deemed to be an "affidavit". We note that the format thereof is also not appropriate for a declaration pursuant to 37 CFR 1.68. However, we have carefully weighed the statements of Mr. Nichols in our evaluation of the factual evidence before us on this appeal.